Why so many women reporting on sport on the BBC?

[Guinness Boy]

A typical Goldstone fishing trip.

1) Post ill considered sub Daily Express nonsense. Make it as near the knuckle as possible without actually swearing or breaking board rules.
2) Light blue touch paper and retreat. Do not return to thread
3) Knock one out

At least it's been worth reading this thread for Edna's comments.....

 

[hans kraay fan club]

Suzy Perry, Clare balding, Hazel Irvine, Sue Barker, Gabby Logan.....all good sports presenters, all know what they are talking about. The BBC has a fair few females that are around the grounds reporting during Final Score.

Perry knows her motorsport, and Balding and Irvine are excellent presenters. Not having the simpering Barker or the dreadful Logan though. Both very poor presenters, in my (personal) opinion.

Not because they're ladies, of course. Just because they are poor.

No issue with the likes of Oatley commentating on MotD either. All the time they still allow Motson to continue, pretty much anybody else is preferable.

 

[edna krabappel]

Perry knows her motorsport, and Balding and Irvine are excellent presenters. Not having the simpering Barker or the dreadful Logan though. Both very poor presenters, in my (personal) opinion.

Not because they're ladies, of course. Just because they are poor.

No issue with the likes of Oatley commentating on MotD either. All the time they still allow Motson to continue, pretty much anybody else is preferable.

Logan, I can live with. Barker is cringeworthy though. Never get the impression she knows her stuff with the exception of tennis, and as you say, it's the simpering arse kissing towards whoever happens to be the guest (used to be Ally McCoist on QOS but also applies to John McEnroe etc).

 

[ALBION28]

Every time I watch BBC news the sport is reported by a woman. Why? All the sport being reported is played 100% by men. What do these ladies know about football, rugger, F1?

The BBC really has gone too far ... again.

I'm with you. Ignore the PC brigade. I am partially deaf and the higher pitch of female voices is spoiling my enjoyment of the reporting of sport.

 

[edna krabappel]

Case rests, m'lud.

 

[The Large One]

I'm with you. Ignore the PC brigade. I am partially deaf and the higher pitch of female voices is spoiling my enjoyment of the reporting of sport.

For all of this talk of a 'PC Brigade', does anyone know of it real (not imagined) existence?

 

[Guinness Boy]

For all of this talk of a 'PC Brigade', does anyone know of it real (not imagined) existence?

 

[mejonaNO12 aka riskit]

Women presenters? Fine.

Women Commentators? I'm yet to have been convinced. It's clearly not a sexist thing (he says). It's a voice pitch thing and it's 100% my preference. I'm so STUCK in a BLOKE talking over the footer that this simple little change really challenges me. Especially in the first ever match on MOTD by a female commnetator. I just remember her shout "YA-KOO-BOOOOO!!!!" as Yakubu scored. It was SO unnatural.

Again, it'll just be me being stuck in my audio ways. Actually thinking about it, it's only FOOTBALL that a female commentator annoys me on.

Perhaps I should see a shrink.

 

[Pavilionaire]

I feel the same way about female commentators as I do about female comedians. Yes, there are a few good ones out there but most are banal or even rubbish in my personal opinion.

 

[Badger]

All the time they still allow Motson to continue, pretty much anybody else is preferable.

John Motson is to football commentary, what Paul McCartney is to music.

 

[hans kraay fan club]

John Motson is to football commentary, what Paul McCartney is to music.

In the 'untouchable' sense, yes.

I'd say he's worse, though. McCartney is DULL and irrelevant. Motson is often plain wrong.

 

[Muzzy]

Certainly helps to explain the up sales in microwaveable food these days!

Sorry ladies, just kidding.

 

[edna krabappel]

I'd say he's worse. McCartney is DULL and irrlevant. Motson is often plain wrong.

The thing that grates for me with Motty is that little laugh thing he can't help doing at times, you know the "I fancy that <chuckle> Rooney won't be quite so keen on seeing that one again!". That, and the somewhat dated style he has, which always seems to me to be like something out of a Roy of the Rovers comic.

Bit of a living legend, I know, but I'm not keen.

 

[Badger]

In the 'untouchable' sense, yes.

I'd say he's worse, though. McCartney is DULL and irrelevant. Motson is often plain wrong.

They both used to be good at their profession (in McCartney's case I'm talking about his singing), now they are both awful and should retire.

WTF happens to Motson's voice when someone has a shot on goal? It's like someone is squeezing his testicles.

 

[edna krabappel]

They both used to be good at their profession (in McCartney's case I'm talking about his singing), now they are both awful and should retire.

McCartney probably needs the money though, you know?

 

[hans kraay fan club]

The thing that grates for me with Motty is that little laugh thing he can't help doing at times, you know the "I fancy that <chuckle> Rooney won't be quite so keen on seeing that one again!". That, and the somewhat dated style he has, which always seems to me to be like something out of a Roy of the Rovers comic.

Bit of a living legend, I know, but I'm not keen.

They both used to be good at their profession (in McCartney's case I'm talking about his singing), now they are both awful and should retire.

WTF happens to Motson's voice when someone has a shot on goal? It's like someone is squeezing his testicles.

All that, yes, and the fact he often calls it plain wrong "And it's a goal! It's in. No actually he's cleared it. Good chance, that"

And the fact he decides on his own pronunciation of players' names, and refuses to budge. Such as Olivier Giroud, which Motty insists ends 'RUDE', in contrast to the rest of the world, who use a silent D. Yesterday a case in point:

Motty: "Great penalty from GiRUDE"

Stadium announcer clearly audible in the background: "Arsenal's second, number 17, Olivier.."

60,000 Gooners: "GIROOOOOOOO"

Motty: "And that's GiRUDE's second of the game"....

 

[Pavilionaire]

Maybe it's just me, but Motson never seems to know what's actually happened until about 5 seconds later, i.e.
"Was it offside? The referee didn't give it."
"Was the whole of the ball over the line? He's given it!"
"And it's...oh...yes, I think...yes, there...it's Suarez who looked as if he might have got the final touch".

 

[edna krabappel]

All that, yes, and the fact he often calls it plain wrong "And it's a goal! It's in. No actually he's cleared it. Good chance, that"

And the fact he decides on his own pronunciation of players' names, and refuses to budge. Such as Olivier Giroud, which Motty insists ends 'RUDE', in contrast to the rest of the world, who use a silent D. Yesterday a case in point:

Motty: "Great penalty from GiRUDE"

Stadium announcer clearly audible in the background: "Arsenal's second, number 17, Olivier.."

60,000 Gooners: "GIROOOOOOOO"

Motty: "And that's GiRUDE's second of the game"....

It was his insistence on overemphasising the second syllable of a particular Chelsea striker's surname that used to get on my nerves. "Drog-BAAAAA!"

 

[hans kraay fan club]

It was his insistence on overemphasising the second syllable of a particular Chelsea striker's surname that used to get on my nerves. "Drog-BAAAAA!"

'Gylfi SigGURDson'

 

[Giraffe]

Yep Motson grates on me a bit now too I'm afraid, but guess that's why he drifts off to lesser games.

Female commentators are wrong for the same reason as why it is difficult to listen to children commentating, the pitch and tone are just annoying. I also find it difficult to stomach when I hear a girly scream at the football. It's a mans game and whilst I'm happy for women to participate in it they need to realise they need to act like men to do it.

If I turned up at a cookery class at the WI would try and fit in, I wouldn't start farting and swearing. It's the same thing. And yes there are men on hear who have swallowed all this modern bollocks but frankly it's nonsense. Yes it would be nice to treat women exactly the same as men, likewise it would be nice if women treated men the same. BUT we are not. We are fundamentally different and recognising this and accepting that different sexes have different qualities is the way forward.

One quality that no woman has yet to posess is the ability to commentate on football matches. And until one can get a deep enough voice to do so they never will.