Another pie thread - what do you want next season...?

[fataddick]

Hope we never have to play Scunthorpe.

As long as you play Bristol City first. That's the gentlemanly way.

 

[The Peanut Roaster]

As long as you play Bristol City first. That's the gentlemanly way.

 

[Triggaaar]

Chicken Balti doing well in the poll, did they sell well at the games? I had one when they were out of both chicken and steak, and it wasn't good - complete contrast to the standard.

Balti is a good option for cheap, shit pies, where it masks the quality of the pie and filling, it shouldn't be used for Piglet's Pantry.

 

[MACROBLUE]

Steak and Kidney and Cheese and Onion please.

 

[The Peanut Roaster]

Pork and apple.

 

[The Large One]

Chicken Balti doing well in the poll, did they sell well at the games? I had one when they were out of both chicken and steak, and it wasn't good - complete contrast to the standard.

Balti is a good option for cheap, shit pies, where it masks the quality of the pie and filling, it shouldn't be used for Piglet's Pantry.

Quality, for me, varied. The first few I had came out OK. Subsequent ones improved as time went on and were ultimately excellent.

About 15,500 were sold for the 18 or so games they were available.

Interesting you judge it on just one pie.

 

[Triggaaar]

Interesting you judge it on just one pie.

They're not complicated, and I imagine the ingredients are the same each time, so I didn't expect the taste to vary (obviously some won't be as hot, and some won't be as crispy etc). I never had a chicken and ham pie that wasn't nice, and although the quality of the steak varied a bit (as expected) they were all fairly good too.

 

[The Large One]

They're not complicated, and I imagine the ingredients are the same each time, so I didn't expect the taste to vary (obviously some won't be as hot, and some won't be as crispy etc). I never had a chicken and ham pie that wasn't nice, and although the quality of the steak varied a bit (as expected) they were all fairly good too.

It can vary.

Don't forget, the pies are hand-made. They also might not get the same supplier of chicken, beef etc (not that they get them from Forfars, as some numpty on here said) They might be to a given (constantly evolving) recipe, but a slip of the hand in cooking one particular batch... etc.

 

[Window Licker]

This should apply to all food. Everything is better with cheese.

Agreed, too bad they'd have to get past the health and safety implications first as everyone knows melted cheese is the hottest substance known to man.

 

[The Large One]

Agreed, too bad they'd have to get past the health and safety implications first as everyone knows melted cheese is the hottest substance known to man.

Apart from a McDonald's apple pie, that is.

 

[Horton's halftime iceberg]

Any other veggie option, squash very good but would be nice to vary it week to week.

 

[Daffy Duck]

What about a baked bean pie, like the ones you used to get in the pie shop at the top of St James's Street years ago? They were superb.