[News] Should we Bring Back National Service?

[WATFORD zero]

Oh for fucks sake.

Get them picking litter then. Scrubbing toilets.

Or maybe you’re right. Let them sit on their arses wasting tax payers money because people think their jobs are so precious that nobody but the super motivated, super qualified could possibly do it.

Designing waterproof walls? Doesn’t sound that hard, tbh.

You started it. You're on your own

Done, it's called Glass

 

[The Clamp]

Could we perhaps set them to work digging my government over-spill ditches?

 

[Sid and the Sharknados]

I think you can understand why Canada are reluctant to. They’re not a great expeditionary force, and never really have been. They’re not a nuclear power. They face no real direct threat.

Given Canada faces Russia directly over the (rapidly melting) Arctic, I'd think they have some good reasons to be concerned.

 

[Deportivo Seagull]

National service isn’t about serving on the frontline. Nor is the peace Corp, the wildlife trust, nursing, charity work.

I’m not talking about tarining people up for the special forces !

Perhaps they could clean some hospital wards or help build flood defences?

And who knows. Maybe a bit of sqaure bashing in -2 at 6pm on a Friday night while their employed mates are down the pub chatting up birds and having a laugh might motivate them to get their act together.

If they aren’t train for an active role then why bother. The military isn’t a dumping ground.

 

[The Clamp]

If they aren’t train for an active role then why bother. The military isn’t a dumping ground.

I wasn’t for one second suggesting it was.


I haven’t served but went to a military foundation school, CCF and all that. With the expectation I would go onto join the forces. I spent many years in the ATC, have many family members in service, past and present and have a great respect for the military.

Even at cadet level, which we had to do compulsorily, I saw people who didn’t want to train or take part at first, turn from unmotivated sacks of spuds to willing and able cadets.

When the compulsory two years was over the ones who wanted to drop out had to do compulsory community service.

I don’t believe the military was seen as a dumping ground during NS and I don’t see any reason it should be so today.

 

[studio150]

Might bring some discipline back in this country

Well National Service certainly tamed The Krays

 

[studio150]

Anything military, absolutely no.

Something that lasts say just a month, around 16/17, and involves some kind of community/social/environmental contribution before you leave education and enter adulthood, possibly yes.

Yes lets pressgang youngsters into this, it's bound to be a vote winner...oh those that have to do this can't vote.

 

[Deportivo Seagull]

I wasn’t for one second suggesting it was.


I haven’t served but went to a military foundation school, CCF and all that. With the expectation I would go onto join the forces. I spent many years in the ATC, have many family members in service, past and present and have a great respect for the military.

Even at cadet level, which we had to do compulsorily, I saw people who didn’t want to train or take part at first, turn from unmotivated sacks of spuds to willing and able cadets.

When the compulsory two years was over the ones who wanted to drop out had to do compulsory community service.

I don’t believe the military was seen as a dumping ground during NS and I don’t see any reason it should be so today.

The military now, to when NS was in place is light years apart. NS would be a buggeration factor more than anything else. it’s highly technical and the resources should be aimed at that, not getting Load of 18 years old marching up and down. It shouldn’t be forgotten that many who served in Korea where NS, it was an active role back in the day.

 

[The Clamp]

The military now, to when NS was in place is light years apart. NS would be a buggeration factor more than anything else. it’s highly technical and the resources should be aimed at that, not getting Load of 18 years old marching up and down. It shouldn’t be forgotten that many who served in Korea where NS, it was an active role back in the day.

Fair enough.

We shall just have to improve education resources and see if we can’t get them into decent jobs.

To be honest, that was my last resort but okay

 

[Wrong-Direction]

I think everyone's missing the point? If we go to war with Russia we'd all be wiped out fairly quickly

 

[Thunder Bolt]

I think everyone's missing the point? If we go to war with Russia we'd all be wiped out fairly quickly

4 minutes.

 

[The Clamp]

4 minutes.

Just enough time to send a few over the top.

Cry God for Harry, England, and Saint George, Pip, Pip and a Tally Ho! Baaaaah!!

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Could we perhaps set them to work digging my government over-spill ditches?

Get the ones in brexit voting areas to pick fruit.

 

[Super Steve Earle]

National Service might work as long as it could be done at home with a keyboard.

 

[Sid and the Sharknados]

You started it. You're on your own

Done, it's called Glass

Funnily enough, designing glass flood walls is a right pane in the glass ( I couldn't resist that as soon as it occurred to me).

Seriously though, you have to make sure the wall doesn't bend under the weight of water and cause the glass to drop out.

 

[The Clamp]

Funnily enough, designing glass flood walls is a right pane in the glass ( I couldn't resist that as soon as it occurred to me).

Seriously though, you have to make sure the wall doesn't bend under the weight of water and cause the glass to drop out.

They had to put in glass flood defences for some of my friend’s places in Shoreham who’s gerdens lead down to the river.

Bloody slog to get the council to agree to it and pay for it.

They were quite happy to brick up the end of people’s property.

 

[Zeberdi]

Mods - Can we close the thread now please. It has gone way off topic - it doesn’t seem much point in keeping it open tbh.

It was meant as a serious topic thread but clearly the discussion is over.

 

[Sid and the Sharknados]

They had to put in glass flood defences for some of my friend’s places in Shoreham who’s gerdens lead down to the river.

Bloody slog to get the council to agree to it and pay for it.

They were quite happy to brick up the end of people’s property.

Well quite, I'm not joking about that bit. It's much more difficult and expensive.

 

[Sid and the Sharknados]

Mods - Can we close the thread now please. It has gone way off topic - it doesn’t seem much point in keeping it open tbh.

It was meant as a serious topic thread but clearly the discussion is over.

I mean, you're perfectly entitled to ask for your own thread to be closed, but some of us are still enjoying the conversation.

 

[Zeberdi]

Well quite, I'm not joking about that bit. It's much more difficult and expensive.

Can you stop trolling my thread with off topic comments - it is very annoying. If you have no interest in discussing the topic why are you even posting on here?

I mean, you're perfectly entitled to ask for your own thread to be closed, but some of us are still enjoying the conversation.

Then go and have a conversation about your engineering business on another thread please.

You are deliberately trolling this one. It’s not the first time you have used this tactic to derail threads either.