Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Music] Most over-rated albums



Flounce

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Nov 15, 2006
7,145
I think DSOTM is an interesting one.

It's my favourite album of all time and I think every second of it is a masterpiece which needs to be listened to as a whole.

But I also get how someone simply wouldn't get it. I don't think it's a "oh that's a nice tune in the background" album. I decide to sit down and fully engage in listening to it which is as twatty is it sounds but it's the truth. I won't choose one song from it, it has to be the whole thing.
I reckon DSOTM is the album I have listened to in it’s entirety more often than any other album.

I’m not sure sitting down and actually listening to a complete album is a thing these days? I have a mate who has, imo, a decent taste in music but he admits to only listening to the “tune” and has no interest in listening to the lyrics. I find that plain weird :shrug:

He HATES Dylan obviously. :smile:
 








heathgate

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Apr 13, 2015
4,011
I reckon DSOTM is the album I have listened to in it’s entirety more often than any other album.

I’m not sure sitting down and actually listening to a complete album is a thing these days? I have a mate who has, imo, a decent taste in music but he admits to only listening to the “tune” and has no interest in listening to the lyrics. I find that plain weird :shrug:

He HATES Dylan obviously. :smile:
I can relate to that....I listen to a track as an entity, a thing composed of several parts...each part being a lesser thing on their own...lyrics mean little to me, its the whole that gets me emotional about a track....

A small example...I am not a Ga Ga fan, though she has a powerful voice... On YouTube I came across however, an acoustic version of her track Joanne.... it got me right there because of the overall vibe, not the lyrical story.
 






PascalGroß Tips

Well-known member
Jan 29, 2024
1,345
Oh man, that's a hard position to support..... DARK Side..and Wish You Were Here are just iconic, surely?!... anyone over 50 would surely have those tracks in their heart somewhere.
Well I agree with you. I can remember the first time I heard DSOTM. Sometime around 1976/77 ish, I was round a mates house listening to music (we'd have been maybe 15/16). My mate was a big Ritchie Blackmore fan and that style of music ... so we'd have probably been listening to Rainbow or Deep Purple on the lounge record player. But I could also hear something else playing from his older sister's bedroom. Asked what it was and it was DSOTM ... which I went out and bought the following week. I need to listen to the whole thing from start to finish. It's not an album where I'd put individual tracks into a playlist ... same with Wish You Were Here ... Animals ...The Wall.
 


1066familyman

Radio User
Jan 15, 2008
15,631
Definition of overrated? Stuff I don't like.
Definition of overrated? Rock and Pop albums I don't like.

Definition of best? Rock and Pop albums I like.

I don't know why none of these threads have Rock and Pop in the title :shrug:
 


Nitram

Well-known member
Jul 16, 2013
2,508
I bought 'Aja' on cassette cheap in Woolworths because of the sample of 'Peg' on 'Eye Know' by De La Soul. Had little idea who they were. I've never been glamping or skiing, but must admit @Nitram, that I do very much like jazz, so am probably just a different type of w@nker :ROFLMAO: ).

If you like jazz, the sound they make is fairly irresistible. I get all the cocaine, chauvinist, self indulgent, antithesis of punk's DIY attitude critique. I agree with a lot of it. It's just that, on some days, when I'm in a certain mood, I think they might make a sound that no other band has ever beaten.
🤣 actually nothing to do with Jazz just my first thought about the pointless ‘my taste is better than yours pseudo bollocks’ that’s showing up in this thread.
 




DavidinSouthampton

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jan 3, 2012
17,793
I think DSOTM is an interesting one.

It's my favourite album of all time and I think every second of it is a masterpiece which needs to be listened to as a whole.

But I also get how someone simply wouldn't get it. I don't think it's a "oh that's a nice tune in the background" album. I decide to sit down and fully engage in listening to it which is as twatty is it sounds but it's the truth. I won't choose one song from it, it has to be the whole thing.
Does it depend on where you were and who you were with. DSOTM is a personal favourite and it came out during my first year at University with a great group of friends on the quad I was living on.
 








Sorrel

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
3,199
Back in East Sussex
A Love Supreme - John Coltrane

Every now and again I try to listen to records other people say are wonderful. But I can’t do it with jazz; never managed to get to the end of this one.

People then suggest other similar albums to try, but no: I’d rather sit in silence. Not sure if they count as “over” rated, but those who do rate them always rate them a great deal and I find them literally unlistenable.
 


Jul 20, 2003
21,751
A Love Supreme - John Coltrane

Every now and again I try to listen to records other people say are wonderful. But I can’t do it with jazz; never managed to get to the end of this one.

People then suggest other similar albums to try, but no: I’d rather sit in silence. Not sure if they count as “over” rated, but those who do rate them always rate them a great deal and I find them literally unlistenable.


Christ. If we are going jazz.


Ornette Coleman "The Shape Of Jazz To Come"

Nah.

Absolute bollocks.
 


Herr Tubthumper

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 11, 2003
65,490
The Fatherland
Steely Dan .... self indulgent, self obsessed, dead behind the eyes, more money than taste, more cocaine than sense, chauvinistic, over produced, cvnt rock for gated community dwelling shiit heads who'll spend 16 grand on Glastonbury glamping tickets "there's more 'snow' there than Val d'Isere" then complain about how they overdo the politics, and how you have to do it as its part of the 'season' and leave their vehicle pass on the windscreen of the 'landie' so all the neighbours will think they're soo fvcking cool where as the reality is just like in their real lives they're scared to set foot outside the over priced walls they surround themselves with in case one of those people you read about tries to rob you or touch you or look at you. Babylon Sister ? Babylon Fister more like .
:lol:
 




Flounce

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Nov 15, 2006
7,145
Christ. If we are going jazz.


Ornette Coleman "The Shape Of Jazz To Come"

Nah.

Absolute bollocks.
Modern Jazz to me is generally a bunch of guys in a band all playing different tunes but at the same time. It not only does nothing for me, it actually irritates me. I will take being called a heathen!

Trad Jazz or New Orleans Jazz I don’t mind, in fact some of it I quite like.
 


BN9 BHA

Flakey fanbase member 🙄
NSC Patron
Jul 14, 2013
23,733
Newhaven
If we are honest, this is exactly what this thread is about!

A bunch of people giving their subjective negative opinion on albums other people like.

'Anything by . . . ' is translated to 'i don't like a band that other people do.
This is what it turned into pretty quickly. :lolol:
 


Uncle Spielberg

Well-known member
Jul 6, 2003
43,575
Lancing
Aqua - Aquarium
 








WATFORD zero

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 10, 2003
29,439
Modern Jazz to me is generally a bunch of guys in a band all playing different tunes but at the same time. It not only does nothing for me, it actually irritates me. I will take being called a heathen!

Trad Jazz or New Orleans Jazz I don’t mind, in fact some of it I quite like.

A couple of quotes about Jazz.

I can't remember who said it but “Jazz ain't nothin' but a blues quartet fallin' down a flight of stairs” sometimes comes to mind

"At the time I couldn't understand it; the music just sounded like people were "noodling" about. Now, I can understand where they are noodling, why they're noodling and the difference between good and bad noodling. Without certain musical clues it just all sounded like noodles to me". Frank Zappa autobiography.

Now there was a man who knew about noodling :thumbsup:
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here