Keith Patel
**** off Lino.
I have no idea what Williamson is like.
Does anyone have a good word to say about him ?
No.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Dunk to join Fulham this week?
- Thread starter Zebedee
- Start date
No.
Ask Wes Brown.
nevergoagain
Well-known member
£3m plus Cisse would do me
The way I see it is we are selling a 23 year old who is easily one of our best players and could play in the Premiership quite comfortably (in my opinion) for a 30 year old who is deemed surplus to requirements from a side who avoided relegation by the skin of their teeth. As we have seen with other signings, a team's overall performance isn't necessarily related to an individual, however whenever I've seen Williamson play he has looked out of his depth. Perhaps you are right in that he would be decent at Championship level, however it seems quite short sighted unless we are going to reinvest the money we receive into the squad, which quite frankly we haven't had a great record of doing in the past (Ulloa, Bridcutt, Buckley) fees.
Peter Grummit
Well-known member
Dunk is on a long contract, we should keep him. Dunk, Uwe, Gordon and Rea is perfect for us at CB this year.
PG
PG
6/1 to join Newcastle, odds of him joining Fulham dropped slightly to 4/5 from evens overnight.
Ernest
Stupid IDIOT
Ream SINGING this morning, he is USELESS so I predict Big HELMET to score on Saturday
nwgull
Well-known member
I also agree. If Williamson had played 150 games in La Liga or Bundesliga for a team that had just been relegated, we'd be ******* ourselves silly over him.
Story is up on the DM site now:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/fo...change-deal-Brighton-defender-Lewis-Dunk.html
With one comment:
TNinfiniti, newcastle, United Kingdom, 7 minutes ago
Just pay them 10million to take MW off our hands.....A Drunk for some old Junk seems a 10mil bargain
For what it's worth, if Newcastle do come in with a bid, I'd tell them to shove Williamson and make it £6 million with a 30% sell-on clause, international appearance clause, club appearances clause etc to get the deal done. We're under no pressure to sell unless Dunk tells us he wants to leave, so if he's going to leave we should milk it for all we can (then finally bring in Marshall and Murphy).
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/fo...change-deal-Brighton-defender-Lewis-Dunk.html
With one comment:
TNinfiniti, newcastle, United Kingdom, 7 minutes ago
Just pay them 10million to take MW off our hands.....A Drunk for some old Junk seems a 10mil bargain
For what it's worth, if Newcastle do come in with a bid, I'd tell them to shove Williamson and make it £6 million with a 30% sell-on clause, international appearance clause, club appearances clause etc to get the deal done. We're under no pressure to sell unless Dunk tells us he wants to leave, so if he's going to leave we should milk it for all we can (then finally bring in Marshall and Murphy).
Last edited:
Bladders
Twats everywhere
Can they chuck in Goofran as well?
Text from my Geordie contact with a slightly better deal: "I'd be surprised; we've got Lascelles and Mbemba (on the way in - 4 birthdays ranging from '88 to '94) already as young centre backs. But apparently we've 'tracked' Dunk for a while. Yous should take Williamson, Gouffran & Obertan in return. All shite but would do a good job in the championship."
Wes Brown with 7 league titles , 2 FA Cups , 3 league cups , 4 Charity shields , 2 champions leagues , PFA team of the year (voted by players) + 23 England caps.
Yes sounds awful , would never cut it at Rotherham on a wet Tuesday
Blue Valkyrie
Not seen such Bravery!
Why would Williamson move to us for a massive pay cut ?
lethaldrizzle
New member
Why would Williamson move to us for a massive pay cut ?
Presumably Newcastle would offer some sort of lump sum to him as compensation for the rest of his contract?
Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo
Waxing chumps like candles since ‘75
- Oct 4, 2003
- 11,286
Can't we sell Dunk for say £6million and have him on loan for the rest of the season, they can keep Williamson, he's utter gash.
For those saying he's played however many Premier League games, Titus Bramble played nearly 300 games in the Premier League and I wouldn't have wanted him anywhere near a Brighton team either.
For those saying he's played however many Premier League games, Titus Bramble played nearly 300 games in the Premier League and I wouldn't have wanted him anywhere near a Brighton team either.
He's out of contract at the end of the season so they'd no doubt come to an agreement on the remainder of the contract. If Williamson moves now he knows he's got a 2 or 3 year deal sorted plus whatever compensation and doesn't have to compete with loads of other out of contract players come next summer.
Blue Valkyrie
Not seen such Bravery!
Would it not be better just to add that to our fee, so we can spend it as we choose ?
GT49er
Well-known member
Would it not be better just to add that to our fee, so we can spend it as we choose ?
In an ideal world, yes, but if the world new we had pumped 5 or 6 million out of Newcastle, the price of anyone we wanted to buy would sky-rocket.
There is a certain logic to taking Williamson as a make-weight in the deal - we do at least have a temporary replacement third choice CB until hopefully one or two of our youngsters are ready to step up. This is the bloke who Carver accused of getting himself sent off deliberately though, so possibly a question mark over his attitude. Wouldn't be too happy with the deal, but it might be the best we can get.
And the same would be true over Williamson if no one had seen him play.
It's obviously a bit uninspiring, but if Dunk goes (to whomever) we need more cover for Uwe and Greer, and I imagine he's a reasonable option. I imagine wages would be a problem though.