Papa Lazarou
Living in a De Zerbi wonderland
It makes you look racist.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Class fans getting recognised…
- Thread starter Sheebo
- Start date
It makes you look racist.
Green Cross Code Man
Wunt be druv
I would rather players didn't take the knee as I believe it's no longer an effective demonstration, however I consider booing it to be a racist act as it represents an anti racist idea a expresses solidarity with all races.
And you think the alpaca is more important than the way we treat other humans?
Why?
How is it helping?
Why not just stay quiet?
What’s the benefit of booing?
All it does it make the kneeling more relevant, and likely to continue for longer.
Stato
Well-known member
- Dec 21, 2011
- 6,590
Done to death, but still not understood apparently. Or perhaps a straw man argument? Nobody claimed to know what Rodriguez said and what Bong heard. We all know that the FA finding was that the accusation was not proven. The question for us was really always why so many Burnley fans felt the need to weigh in and inflame the situation between a Brighton player and a WBA player. None of them were at the game in question, but they became the most vociferous element giving disgusting sustained abuse to an honest pro and honourable man who committed the sin of just reporting what he believed he had heard. Now there is every chance that Bong misheard, but those Burnley fans who abused him weren't chanting that he may be mistaken, they were saying that he was a liar. Some were just shouting racist abuse at him and were reported to the police by other Burnley fans.
Wearing a remembrance poppy doesn't itself actually 'achieve' anything. It is a symbolic gesture, that people involve themselves in to demonstrate that they support a particular cause.
When you pass somebody in the street, wearing a poppy, do you BOOOOOO them?
Do you understand why people might assume you side with racists when you boo a gesture that is aimed at reducing racism by raising awareness of the (ongoing) issue of racism?
Who are you to decide which causes are important enough for the players to get behind?
As someone trying to boo into submission an anti-racism message that harms nobody (except perhaps racists who take exception to it), I'd suggest that you're not overly picky when it comes to causes to get behind yourself. (unless of course, you are racist and then I can clearly see why you might want to boo an attempt to limit your ability to be racist)
Seeing as you are keen to be recognised as 'not racist', perhaps you might see the importance of not booing, even if you believe taking the knee has achieved nothing.
Obviously, none of this will have any effect on your mindset as it's been done to death on here. I suspect you revel in your "not racist despite fighting anti-racism" stance, but hopefully the penny might drop one day.
dsr-burnley
Well-known member
- Aug 15, 2014
- 2,194
That's something I do not understand at all. I can see why it's wrong to say someone stinks. Even if true, it isn't polite. But why is is specially wrong just because he is black?
Pretty much the only conclusion that can be drawn about anyone booing it really. Simply ignoring it……fine if you want, but booing it is going to be interpreted as positively opposing the aims of it to the majority…….
It makes playing spot the racist a piece of p|ss for a start
daveinprague
New member
How is players taking the knee inconveniencing the people booing? What else do they rail against?
Mancgull
Well-known member
Every player on the pitch took the knee and some fans booed. What I did hear in the majority was a very vocal response to that booing by the Brighton fans around me.
There is unfortunately a racist tone to the booing which is shameful. Zaha feels that he doesn’t want to ‘take the knee’ as he feels that another response is better. I don’t think he should be criticised for that.
What I would say is that after the Burnley plane incident, Ben Mee spoke in a very articulate and inspiring way about how Burnley FC wanted to distance itself from the message displayed by the plane.
So let’s be fair to the vast majority who supported ‘taking the knee’ but not overlook the ignorance of others who feel the need to ‘boo it’.
There is unfortunately a racist tone to the booing which is shameful. Zaha feels that he doesn’t want to ‘take the knee’ as he feels that another response is better. I don’t think he should be criticised for that.
What I would say is that after the Burnley plane incident, Ben Mee spoke in a very articulate and inspiring way about how Burnley FC wanted to distance itself from the message displayed by the plane.
So let’s be fair to the vast majority who supported ‘taking the knee’ but not overlook the ignorance of others who feel the need to ‘boo it’.
You really don’t see that - rightly or wrongly - that could be construed as a racist remark?
I’ve just been reminded above that Rodriguez wasn’t even a Burnley player! Imagine the level of commitment to even potential racism you need to back a player that isn’t even yours.
Of course not. However if the "gesture" continued for month after month after month, well past its sell-by date, then a little booing might be in order.
Papa Lazarou
Living in a De Zerbi wonderland
Given how long this has been going on, what 'other response' has Zaha adopted / suggested?
daveinprague
New member
I've not yet heard a valid argument for people booing an anti racism stance. I will consider booing the gesture as a racist response.
daveinprague
New member
After the racial abuse black players received following defeat in the Euro's, I can't think of it being past any sell-by date.
You’ll be furious when you hear how long we’ve been wearing poppies for.
And you’re the one to decide that racism has ended then? The fact it’s discussion is still so prevalent following the abuse of the 3 black players after England’s exit from Euro 2020 suggests it’s nowhere near “past it’s sell-by date”
The ones who decide what the knee stands for are those kneeling.
They have made clearly SO MANY ****ING TIMES that it’s nothing to do with politics.
They kneel against racism and discrimination. So if you boo, that is what you are booing. An anti racist message.
They have made clearly SO MANY ****ING TIMES that it’s nothing to do with politics.
They kneel against racism and discrimination. So if you boo, that is what you are booing. An anti racist message.
Mancgull
Well-known member
He says that his parents told him he should be proud to be black and stand tall. Therefore I think it’s right that he can send his own message out by doing just that and communicating the reason, which he has. I know he’s our ‘pantomime villain’ but in this instance I back him on that so long as he’s explained his reason for it, which he has. It’s clear that he has suffered racial abuse in the past and that’s wrong, so it’s not as if he is indifferent to the issue.
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
Is it just because he is black? His native language is French (who like garlic) so even referring to stinking, is racist even if skin colour doesn't come into it. It is lazy stereotyping.