portslade seagull
Well-known member
None of the starters above a 4, the subs 6/7s
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Brighton vs Everton Player Ratings (H)
- Thread starter Bridcutt
- Start date
Pedro - 1 (charitable) disinterested, obviously didn't want to be there, couldn't wait to leave. I'm ashamed to say I boooooooooed him.
Milano
Well-known member
Which position was Gross playing first half? It certainly wasn’t right back. He was ‘bad Pascal’ today.
Undav was woeful and Bouanontte is nowhere near ready to start. Made the same selection mistakes at Forest. I wanted him to make subs after 20 minutes. Not great Roberto, not great.
Undav was woeful and Bouanontte is nowhere near ready to start. Made the same selection mistakes at Forest. I wanted him to make subs after 20 minutes. Not great Roberto, not great.
Confident RDZ thought the team would win.
Tactically playing two at the back and Estupinan and to a lesser extent Gross ahead of our midfield looks poor now.
Whatever we say with the benefit of hindsight we've seen the best football ever from a Brighton team.
FFS sometimes we'll lose, Everton were superb, lets not rip into individuals, instead recall and rejoyce in the sublime football we've played this season!
Tactically playing two at the back and Estupinan and to a lesser extent Gross ahead of our midfield looks poor now.
Whatever we say with the benefit of hindsight we've seen the best football ever from a Brighton team.
FFS sometimes we'll lose, Everton were superb, lets not rip into individuals, instead recall and rejoyce in the sublime football we've played this season!
aolstudios
Well-known member
Steele 5
Gross 5
Dunk 4
Webster 1 - You're a good CB but please don't come out with the ball, Adam. Ever
Estupinan 5
Caicedo 4
Mac 7 MoM
Mitoma 3
Buananotte 4
Welbeck 5
Undav 3
March 6.5
Enciso 7
Colwill 7
Ferguson 6.5
Gilmour N/A
Gross 5
Dunk 4
Webster 1 - You're a good CB but please don't come out with the ball, Adam. Ever
Estupinan 5
Caicedo 4
Mac 7 MoM
Mitoma 3
Buananotte 4
Welbeck 5
Undav 3
March 6.5
Enciso 7
Colwill 7
Ferguson 6.5
Gilmour N/A
Fair enough. That qualification would be helpful in those cases!
I would personally argue as an Argentinian international this is great experience and will accelerate his development with us.
Just needs someone to give him the confidence to take on his man down the outside. Reminds me greatly of March before this season. Neat, tidy but nowhere near direct enough yet!
Steele - 3 possibly at fault for 2 goals, no chance with other 3
Gross - 2 was like he was running in treacle and never where he needed to be
Webster - 2 shocking positioning on several occasions
Dunk - 2 probably worst performance from him in the Amex era
Pervis - 4 can’t remember anything especially bad but nothing very good
Caceido - 4
Mac - 5 tried to keep it ticking over
Undav - 2 not a premier league footballer
Welbeck - 2 hopeless
Buonanotte - 2 completely anonymous but will come good in time
Mitoma - 2 seems to have just run out of steam
Subs - all 5. Made things slightly better.
RDZ 3. Took too many liberties against a side that where too up for it.
Gross - 2 was like he was running in treacle and never where he needed to be
Webster - 2 shocking positioning on several occasions
Dunk - 2 probably worst performance from him in the Amex era
Pervis - 4 can’t remember anything especially bad but nothing very good
Caceido - 4
Mac - 5 tried to keep it ticking over
Undav - 2 not a premier league footballer
Welbeck - 2 hopeless
Buonanotte - 2 completely anonymous but will come good in time
Mitoma - 2 seems to have just run out of steam
Subs - all 5. Made things slightly better.
RDZ 3. Took too many liberties against a side that where too up for it.
Funny how these threads only appear when we lose or don’t play as well as normal….
Anyway 6 = average
Steele - 4
Gross - 5
Pervis - 5
Dunk - 5
Webster - 4
Caicedo - 5
MacAllister - 6
Buononotte - 4
Mitoma - 5
Welbeck - 4
Undav - 5
Ferguson - 6
Solly - 6
Gilmour - 6
Colwill - 6
Enciso - 6
Anyway 6 = average
Steele - 4
Gross - 5
Pervis - 5
Dunk - 5
Webster - 4
Caicedo - 5
MacAllister - 6
Buononotte - 4
Mitoma - 5
Welbeck - 4
Undav - 5
Ferguson - 6
Solly - 6
Gilmour - 6
Colwill - 6
Enciso - 6
Just seen highlights
Dont know what manager is supposed to do when 2 of his seasons outstanding players give away first 2 goals
I thought when watching first was down to Mitoma. ok he may have lost ball but now see little danger after that because Dunk was with attacker who just walked passed a feeble tackle
For the 2nd goodness knows why Pervis was nearer to right back leaving goalscorer completely free
Wont go into Webster giving ball away for the 4th
Dont know what manager is supposed to do when 2 of his seasons outstanding players give away first 2 goals
I thought when watching first was down to Mitoma. ok he may have lost ball but now see little danger after that because Dunk was with attacker who just walked passed a feeble tackle
For the 2nd goodness knows why Pervis was nearer to right back leaving goalscorer completely free
Wont go into Webster giving ball away for the 4th
Mike Small
Well-known member
- Dec 26, 2008
- 2,714
Today was the ugly side of De Zerbi ball. The players looked like they'd gotten ahead of themselves.
Steele - 2 (one good save but that own goal is embarrassing and should save Doucoure's volley. Would have Bob back for Arsenal)
Gross - 3
Dunk - 3
Webster - 2 (inept positioning for the first)
Pervis - 3 (worst game I've seen him play. Looked knackered throughout)
Caicedo - 4
Alexis - 5
Buonanotte - 3 (should not have started and needed to stay wide to give us more space in the middle yet came inside all the time onto his left. Someone tell him to stay wide!)
Undav - 1 (good at starting counter attacks for Everton)
Welbeck - 2
Mitoma - 3 (relied on him too much today and he really didn't deliver)
De Zerbi - 2 (only not a 1 for making 4 half-time subs)
Subs
Ferguson - 6
March - 7
Colwill - 6
Enciso - 5
Gilmour - N/A
Steele - 2 (one good save but that own goal is embarrassing and should save Doucoure's volley. Would have Bob back for Arsenal)
Gross - 3
Dunk - 3
Webster - 2 (inept positioning for the first)
Pervis - 3 (worst game I've seen him play. Looked knackered throughout)
Caicedo - 4
Alexis - 5
Buonanotte - 3 (should not have started and needed to stay wide to give us more space in the middle yet came inside all the time onto his left. Someone tell him to stay wide!)
Undav - 1 (good at starting counter attacks for Everton)
Welbeck - 2
Mitoma - 3 (relied on him too much today and he really didn't deliver)
De Zerbi - 2 (only not a 1 for making 4 half-time subs)
Subs
Ferguson - 6
March - 7
Colwill - 6
Enciso - 5
Gilmour - N/A
- Nov 11, 2009
- 11,366
He was from an attacking sense. wasn't it his hospital pass? on their 18 yard line that lead straight up the field for Everton 4th and his chase back pursuit that caused his injury
maltaseagull
Well-known member
Steele 4 Should have saved at least 2 of their goals. Pickford was so much better.
Gross 5 Not anywhere near his usual level. Improved when March came on.
Dunk 4 Lewis has been off his usual level a few games recently and if we had better options he might be dropped.
Webster 3 -Gave the ball away while attacking too many times and at fault for 2 goals
Estupinan 5 He hardly ever plays at FB and we finish with 2-4-4 and got badly caught out last night. Maybe wing back and 3 CBs?
Caicedo 4 Poor and sloppy.
Mac 6 Better than the rest but not up to usual standard. Still, maybe Liverpool will look elsewhere
Mitoma 4 Some awful crosses. Too deep and too high too often.
Buananotte 4 Out muscled and needs a good pre-season to build some more strength. Also wrong position for him.
Welbeck 4 Very poor did nothing.
Undav 3 Even worse than Welbeck. After the Wolves game I thought he would grow in confidence but he looked like he was a division too high last night.
March 6.5 Made a big impact but now probably out for the season.
Enciso 7 Great player in there and it´s a pity he didn´t/couldn´t start.
Colwill 6 Looked far better than Webster and we really ought to try and sign him.
Ferguson 6 We looked far more threatening when he came on. A pity he didn´t/couldn´t start.
Gilmour 6 Should have come on earlier.
Gross 5 Not anywhere near his usual level. Improved when March came on.
Dunk 4 Lewis has been off his usual level a few games recently and if we had better options he might be dropped.
Webster 3 -Gave the ball away while attacking too many times and at fault for 2 goals
Estupinan 5 He hardly ever plays at FB and we finish with 2-4-4 and got badly caught out last night. Maybe wing back and 3 CBs?
Caicedo 4 Poor and sloppy.
Mac 6 Better than the rest but not up to usual standard. Still, maybe Liverpool will look elsewhere
Mitoma 4 Some awful crosses. Too deep and too high too often.
Buananotte 4 Out muscled and needs a good pre-season to build some more strength. Also wrong position for him.
Welbeck 4 Very poor did nothing.
Undav 3 Even worse than Welbeck. After the Wolves game I thought he would grow in confidence but he looked like he was a division too high last night.
March 6.5 Made a big impact but now probably out for the season.
Enciso 7 Great player in there and it´s a pity he didn´t/couldn´t start.
Colwill 6 Looked far better than Webster and we really ought to try and sign him.
Ferguson 6 We looked far more threatening when he came on. A pity he didn´t/couldn´t start.
Gilmour 6 Should have come on earlier.
It was exhausting physically and emotionally to beat ManUre...that was key to what happened against Everton.
Icy Gull
Back on the rollercoaster
- Jul 5, 2003
- 72,015
And we’ve got Pope to comeI'm not sure why people keep pointing out that Pickford is much better than Steele...pretty obvious, no
Yep, we know most keepers will play blinders against us (oh, ye gods... argh!!!) so we need to be smarter at actually putting the ball in the net. We create so many good positions in and around the box but, Wolves aside, we're really not smart at putting them away. Welbz, AliMac, Mitoma guilty lately. And Mitoma (bless him, clearly one of our stars) could make far better decisions on when to pass, AND...he often does the amazing by bursting past 3 or 4 defenders and then fluffs his lines... I mean, go round the keeper too, Karou, don't smash it at his face!!!!!!!).And we’ve got Pope to come
Sorry, I'm rambling...
I raised this point as it’s not the first time Mitoma has given the ball away on the halfway line and we’ve conceded, happened against Spurs and I’m certain at least one other game.
nwgull
Well-known member
Steele didn't make a single save, did he?