[Albion] Brighton vs Everton Player Ratings (H)

[Bridcutt]

Steele - 2
Gross - 5
Dunk - 3 - Destroyed by DCL
Webster - 2
Pervis - 4
Caicedo - 5
Alexis - 3
Buonanotte - 4
Undav - 5
Welbeck - 3
Mitoma - 3


De Zerbi - 2. He's the reason we lost this. Poor performances all round but not making a single change within at least the first 20 minutes let alone the whole first half is just awful. Arrogance

Subs
Ferguson - 6
March - 7
Colwill - 6
Enciso - 5
Gilmour - N/A

 

[Uh_huh_him]

Wrong tean
Gilmour, march, enciso shoyld havs started

Steele 4
Gross 5
Dunk 4
Webster 5
Estupinan 5
Caicedo 5
Mac 7 Motm
Mitoma 5
Buananotte 4
Welbeck 4
Undav 4

March 7
Enciso 6
Colwill 6
Ferguson 7
Gilmour 6

De Zerbi 3- that one is on you.

 

[Rookie]

Not sure RDZ is to blame for Mitoma giving the ball away with Pervis stranded up field allowing Everton the freedom of our left in the first minute.

 

[Farehamseagull]

@Stat Brother has been waiting for this!

 

[A1X]

Steele - 2
Gross - 4
Dunk - 2
Webster - 2
Estupinian - 4
Caicedo - 4
Mac Allister - 5
Buenonotte - 1
Undav - 1
Mitoma - 2
Welbeck - 2

March MOTM

 

[Eeyore]

Steele - 2
Gross - 5
Dunk - 3 - Destroyed by DCL
Webster - 2
Pervis - 4
Caicedo - 5
Alexis - 3
Buonanotte - 4
Undav - 5
Welbeck - 3
Mitoma - 3


De Zerbi - 2. He's the reason we lost this. Poor performances all round but not making a single change within at least the first 20 minutes let alone the whole first half is just awful. Arrogance

Subs
Ferguson - 6
March - 7
Colwill - 6
Enciso - 5
Gilmour - N/A

Why would he make changes with the team 1-0 after 20 minutes ? Doesn't send out a good signal, regardless of the eventual outcome. 'Arrogance' ? Caution if anything. He trusts the players.

 

[brighton_dave]

Can't be bothered to rate the starting 11.
March 8
Ferguson 8
done more than any of the others did in the whole game they were on.
No point sugar coating it, most of the team were terrible today.

 

[kevo]

I thought the biggest selection error was not playing Enciso. He brings so much energy and threat to the team. Having said that, March and Ferguson were the best players on the pitch when they came on. Webster, Steele and Gross were all poor, Mitoma and Mac well below bar and I'm still not convinced by Buonanotte.

 

[Hamilton]

March was fantastic, as were all the subs. But by then we were chasing the game.

 

[1066familyman]

Wrong tean
Gilmour, march, enciso shoyld havs started

Steele 4
Gross 5
Dunk 4
Webster 5
Estupinan 5
Caicedo 5
Mac 7 Motm
Mitoma 5
Buananotte 4
Welbeck 4
Undav 4

March 7
Enciso 6
Colwill 6
Ferguson 7
Gilmour 6

De Zerbi 3- that one is on you.

March didn't start because of fitness issues, RDZ said before the game.

He was excellent when he came on, but the hamstring pull up seems to have confirmed the fitness doubt

 

[1066familyman]

I thought the biggest selection error was not playing Enciso. He brings so much energy and threat to the team. Having said that, March and Ferguson were the best players on the pitch when they came on. Webster, Steele and Gross were all poor, Mitoma and Mac well below bar and I'm still not convinced by Buonanotte.

Agree with all this, bar the early judgement on Bounanotte. Agree he hasn't looked great, and didn't really deserve to start today on performance, but he's still very young and I have very high hopes for him.

 

[scooter1]

I’m not sure why he played Bonanotte, when it felt like nobody was going to pass to him. Anything he did in the first half was of his own doing, and bless him but it wasn’t very much.
bad day at the office. I’m glad we haven’t got to play Man Utd again, as we seem to be shite straight after we’ve played well against them…

 

[Sea Cider]

I thought the biggest selection error was not playing Enciso. He brings so much energy and threat to the team. Having said that, March and Ferguson were the best players on the pitch when they came on. Webster, Steele and Gross were all poor, Mitoma and Mac well below bar and I'm still not convinced by Buonanotte.

FFS why do people keep saying things like "not convinced by Buonanotte"?

HE'S 18 AND ONLY MOVED TO EUROPE 4 MONTHS AGO

He will be a brilliant footballer one day. Right now he is a kid in a new country learning the ropes. Give him a break

 

[kevo]

FFS why do people keep saying things like "not convinced by Buonanotte"?

HE'S 18 AND ONLY MOVED TO EUROPE 4 MONTHS AGO

He will be a brilliant footballer one day. Right now he is a kid in a new country learning the ropes. Give him a break

I'm sure he will come good, but I don't think he's ready yet.

 

[The Fits]

The reality is we have no idea about Buoanotte. Not every 18 year old makes it, even if they have youth honours at International level. What is clear is that playing him instead of March is not only a massive downgrade but creates havoc with our tactics and shape.
Whether or not he will eventually be a good player is a debate for a later time, what's not up for debate is that you're not going to get consistent quality from every single teenager in your squad.

 

[Flagship]

Poor team selection. End of.

 

[Sid and the Sharknados]

FFS why do people keep saying things like "not convinced by Buonanotte"?

HE'S 18 AND ONLY MOVED TO EUROPE 4 MONTHS AGO

He will be a brilliant footballer one day. Right now he is a kid in a new country learning the ropes. Give him a break

Nah. I think we should scrap him and use him for parts.
Solly looks like he could do with a new leg for the next match, for a start.

 

[faoileán]

FFS why do people keep saying things like "not convinced by Buonanotte"?

HE'S 18 AND ONLY MOVED TO EUROPE 4 MONTHS AGO

He will be a brilliant footballer one day. Right now he is a kid in a new country learning the ropes. Give him a break

Perhaps they actually mean... not convinced by him being ready for starting in the first team, for the reasons that you state.

 

[Bridcutt]

Why would he make changes with the team 1-0 after 20 minutes ? Doesn't send out a good signal, regardless of the eventual outcome. 'Arrogance' ? Caution if anything. He trusts the players.

He can make tactical changes, it didn't have to be subs.

 

[amexer]

Rather than individual scores prefer to mark the team performance
All very well saying Mitoma was poor. This was down to poor mistakes he made but fact is he throughout looked the only one who would create anything.