Barnes or CMS upfront ? You decide !!!!

[btseagull]

Who would you rather have upfront

 

[terryberry1]

Neither. Both league 1 strikers who are well out of their depth.

 

[ees complicated no?]

Hoskins.

 

[HawkTheSeagull]

Both need dropping, but CMS is the better of the 2.

 

[wehatepalace]

Hoskins. If Norwich still want Smith, bite their hands off.

 

[Questions]

Hoskins. If Norwich still want Smith, bite their hands off.

Most definetly. If we can get our money back or anyway near it ffs sell.

 

[trueblue]

CMS. Nobody can cover the ground he does match in, match out to give us an attacking threat.

 

[clippedgull]

If Norwich still want Smith, bite their hands off.

I seriously can't believe any Premiership sides, even shit ones are looking to buy him!

 

[Trigger]

Er, definitely neither at the moment.

 

[Bwian]

Neither at the moment

 

[Blues Rock DJ]

CMS. Nobody can cover the ground he does match in, match out to give us an attacking threat.

please, amplify.......

 

[salty seagull]

Cms + Hoskins (until January anyway)

 

[Stat Brother]

CMS.

But only if somebody/anybody is going to be within 20 yards of him.

Why off load Nav's get in Crofts & Hammond then ask them to play exactly the same way as Navarro.

 

[brightonmark1234]

cms all day long

 

[Stat Brother]

For the last 18 months we must have been the easiest team to scout against.

Sit on top of Bridcutt, that will keep at least one, probably 2 midfielders next to him.

CMS will be isolated so 1 centre back sticks to him while the other drops off and tidies up.

And there you go, Brighton main attacking striker snuffed out of the game.

 

[DumLum]

CMS

I really believe that when Barnes leaves the Albion he will find his level in league 1 or 2. Don't bother coming back with how many goals he scored in league one either because I was at nearly every one of those games and he should have scored about 50% more than he actually did. We were a very special team, at that level, that year any decent striker would have filled their boots.

It's time Dobbie and Hoskins were given a chance!!!!

 

[Super Steve Earle]

CMS

I really believe that when Barnes leaves the Albion he will find his level in league 1 or 2. Don't bother coming back with how many goals he scored in league one either because I was at nearly every one of those games and he should have scored about 50% more than he actually did. We were a very special team, at that level, that year any decent striker would have filled their boots.

It's time Dobbie and Hoskins were given a chance!!!!

They had their chance Tuesday night against a average Bristol City side. Dobbie was poor and disinterested and Hoskins still lacks match fitness. We needed two goals from midfielders to win it.

 

[matthew]

Neither. Both league 1 strikers who are well out of their depth.

This.

And a poll would be good

 

[clippedgull]

They had their chance Tuesday night against a average Bristol City side. Dobbie was poor and disinterested and Hoskins still lacks match fitness. We needed two goals from midfielders to win it.

Which begs the question, at 3-0 down and game lost Gus didn't give at least one of those two the last 20 minutes if only for a run out.

 

[DumLum]

They had their chance Tuesday night against a average Bristol City side. Dobbie was poor and disinterested and Hoskins still lacks match fitness. We needed two goals from midfielders to win it.

However it was the first time we won by 2 goals in 14 games. I believe we found Barnes' natural position that night.