Say it's a straight fight between us and Palarse for 6th place come 4th May.....

[Deleted User X18H]

...we recall Dobbie? Right?

 

[bn1&bn3 Albion]

He's gone. Only reason he isn't sold yet is because he can't have been signed for 3 different clubs in 1 season.

 

[I_am_JOSH]

...we recall Dobbie? Right?

I'm sure I read somewhere when we loaned him out that he couldn't be used in the playoffs if we made top 6.

 

[ees complicated no?]

Can't have played for 3 different clubs, slight difference.

 

[chrissyboy01]

...we recall Dobbie? Right?

Isn't there a clause in the loan agreement preventing him from being fielded against us in league/playoff situation?

 

[Albion Dan]

There is def a clause stopping him playing in the play offs. Can he play against us at The Amex?

 

[Deleted User X18H]

I'm sure I read somewhere when we loaned him out that he couldn't be used in the playoffs if we made top 6.

Yeah but I am pretty sure 4th May comes before the play-offs. Very sure in fact.

 

[Deleted User X18H]

There is def a clause stopping him playing in the play offs. Can he play against us at The Amex?

No of course he can't. My question is based around him scoring against P'boro, if that had an affect on us needing to better that result, when we play Wolves.

 

[bn1&bn3 Albion]

Can't have played for 3 different clubs, slight difference.

Ah yes, just read that, someone told me it was you can't be signed to 3 clubs..

 

[deletebeepbeepbeep]

There's probably an agreement that we can't recall him.

 

[Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo]

Dobbie cannot be recalled as its a half season loan, you can only recall players in who are loaned out under emergancy loans. We put a clause in the loan agreement that means Dobbie cannot play against us in the League or in any potential play off match between the two sides, however Palace can play him in any other game including the play offs.

 

[Deleted User X18H]

Isn't there a clause in the loan agreement preventing him from being fielded against us in league/playoff situation?

So does a play off situation mean if his appearance and subsequent goal , might prevent us from getting a playoff place?

 

[SeagullSongs]

It's an emergency loan (?) so AFAIA we can't recall him.
We also put a clause in the loan that says he can't play against us.

 

[deletebeepbeepbeep]

Dobbie cannot be recalled as its a half season loan, you can only recall players in who are loaned out under emergancy loans. We put a clause in the loan agreement that means Dobbie cannot play against us in the League or in any potential play off match between the two sides, however Palace can play him in any other game including the play offs.

Actually this, you can't recall long term loans (93+ days) full stop.

 

[Biscuit]

Dobbie cannot be recalled as its a half season loan, you can only recall players in who are loaned out under emergancy loans. We put a clause in the loan agreement that means Dobbie cannot play against us in the League or in any potential play off match between the two sides, however Palace can play him in any other game including the play offs.

That is shocking. Should never have loaned him out to a play-off rival, whether that be Hull/Middlesborough or the scum.

 

[Deleted User X18H]

Dobbie cannot be recalled as its a half season loan, you can only recall players in who are loaned out under emergancy loans. We put a clause in the loan agreement that means Dobbie cannot play against us in the League or in any potential play off match between the two sides, however Palace can play him in any other game including the play offs.

So 4th May we need to win against Wolves to get 6th place. Palarse need only a draw against Peter borough............89th Dobbie equalises and Palarse get into the play-offs at our expense courtesy of a goal from one of our players.

Can't we recall him if we have an injury crisis?

 

[severnside gull]

Isn't there a clause in the loan agreement preventing him from being fielded against us in league/playoff situation?

that is an automatic rule under football league regs & not something we have insisted on
Assuming his loan is 93 days (the max for an emergency loan I think) then unless my maths is wrong I don't think he is available for palarse in the play offs but I am 100% he will not come back to us at that time.

 

[Paddy B]

So does a play off situation mean if his appearance and subsequent goal , might prevent us from getting a playoff place?

His "loan" is just a technicality. He is a Palace player in all but name. So in answer to your question yes he could possible deny us a play off place.

 

[Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo]

Can't we recall him if we have an injury crisis?

No there is no ability to have a recall option in any full or half season loan. The only clauses allowed are the player cannot play in games against the parent club.

 

[Deleted User X18H]

No there is no ability to have a recall option in any full or half season loan. The only clauses allowed are the player cannot play in games against the parent club.

Dicker did for us against his parent club (Stockport) last match 2008/9