Whilst I agree on points 1 & 2 to an extent, I do agree with Stat Brother that previous injuries should be taken into account when signing a player. I wouldn't say Benno is "injury-prone", but he has had a couple of serious injuries and although any fit player that's never been injured before could get injured, that's a much smaller calculated risk.
Old injuries take their toll on a body and recurrences can be quite regular. I would take Benno back personally, but I'd prefer someone that's played at least one full season in the last two years. With Benno, we don't know what his fitness levels are like or whether his body has fully recovered to a pre-injury state. Look at CMS, for all his flaws, one thing he did have was a bit of pace and the ability to harry defenders and goalkeepers. This was destroyed by his injury.
Until Benno completes a full pre-season and gets some games under his belt, he would be too much of a risk to get in as a main winger but perhaps as a back-up.
or to 
