Ive got the lot with Sky and the broadband is appalling at times despite an almost monthly call that fixes something for about a week vef I re it all slows down again. The tragedy is that I cant get Virgin where I live or Id be off like a shot.
Why not BT? Their infinity product is good and you can get as much or little TV as you want? The pricing is pretty good too.
I think much depends on how far you are from the exchange though ... I don't really think it's possible to say one is better than the other, just depends on how lucky/unlucky you are. I gave up on Sky though with dreadful (intermittent) problems with signal dropping that they continually fobbed me off about and put me through torture doing the same old tests. Had BT for 6 months or so now and not one problem ....... until that is!!!