Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Football] Villa missing out on the Champions League because...



dazzer6666

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Mar 27, 2013
58,287
Burgess Hill
Beavis And Butthead Comedy GIF by Paramount+
 




WSU Dilettante

Active member
Mar 12, 2014
209
Lancing
That decision will force them to sell players. Lol
Really, their poor financial management/disregard for the rules will force them to sell players.
As others have said, there are 37 other games that they have played this season where they could have picked up more points.
Perhaps if they didn't cheat, dive, and time waste so much they would have had time to score that additional goal they needed.
 


Blues Guitarist

Well-known member
Oct 19, 2020
870
St Johann in Tirol
I’m sure you understand the rules better than me, but it just doesn’t sit right with me. The whistle should either be final or not. If that means the laws need to change then so be it. I don’t see how it’s fair in one scenario and whistle can be overturned and in another it can’t.
The whistle is final - unless the decision affects Man Utd. :lolol:
 








PeterT

Well-known member
Apr 21, 2017
2,562
Hove
Yes, yes, it makes no difference to us, but Jesus Christ.

Villa were denied this goal and, potentially, Champions League qualification because the referee blew his whistle before the ball crossed the line, thereby denying VAR the opportunity to review the incident.


I thought it was their dick of a goalkeeper charging out and getting sent off, and their failing to turn up again in a massive game (like they did against Palace) that cost them today?
 










GT49er

Well-known member
Feb 1, 2009
51,479
Gloucester
The whole thing started to unravel when ;they' decided they had to impose arbitrary rules on when VAR could or could not intervene. Should have just been allowed whenever there is a clear and obvious error (and PGMOL's ridiculous definition of 'clear and obvious' should have been booted straight into touch too).
 






Brian Munich

teH lulZ
Jul 7, 2008
997
Right to have whistled early. Someone might have got injured or something. That’s what the expert pundits were all telling us a couple of weeks ago.

I mean it’s head-injury FC, so fetch me the Windsor Davies meme.
 


GT49er

Well-known member
Feb 1, 2009
51,479
Gloucester
I'm sure I remember there was an incident a couple of years or so ago - I seem to remember it coming up on ref watch on SSN. It was stated then that if the GK's hand was touching the ball, he was in control, and so it was a foul to knock it away from him. Has that changed?
(Daft rule, IMHO, by the way - the Villa goal should in all honesty have stood). But hey, what goes round comes round - make sure the goal line technology is switched on, eh?
 
Last edited:






schmunk

Well-used member
Jan 19, 2018
11,124
Mid mid mid Sussex
I'm sure I remember there was an incident a couple of years or so ago - I seem to remember it coming up on ref watch on SSN. It was stated then that if the GK's hand was touching the ball, he was in control, and so it was a foul to knock it away from him. Has that changed?
(Daft rule, IMHO, by the way - the Villa goal should in all honesty have stood. But hey, what goes round comes round - make sure the goal line technology is switched on, eh?
If it's the one I'm thinking of, it was Jordan Pickford and he had the ball on the ground trapped under one hand - I recall it was pointed out that the rules/laws/whatever state that this now counts as being in control of the ball, equal to having it trapped between two hands.
 




PascalGroß Tips

Well-known member
Jan 29, 2024
1,300
If it's the one I'm thinking of, it was Jordan Pickford and he had the ball on the ground trapped under one hand - I recall it was pointed out that the rules/laws/whatever state that this now counts as being in control of the ball, equal to having it trapped between two hands.
On this one though, at the precise moment that Rogers toe poked the ball, Bayindir was not touching the ball as he’d ’fumbled’ it. If that was against us and that decision potentially cost us Europe… we’d be going absolutely crazy on here.
 
Last edited:










Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here