gregbrighton
New member
It's no worse than a belt round he ear in the old Hovis days. What's the problem. Softies.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
US Soccer ban headers for children under 11 over concussion fears
- Thread starter Stat Brother
- Start date
"US Soccer will also limit the number of headers made in practice matches for players between the ages of 11 and 13 and undertake a safety awareness campaign on the issue."
So the ref and the players will have to keep count of how many headers there has been?
Banning headers makes corners pretty much redundant as well, considering the keeper can just catch any ball in the air completely unchallenged.
It's part of the game, if you don't like it, don't let your kids play it. Typical of the Americans, doing their utmost to b astardise everything.
So the ref and the players will have to keep count of how many headers there has been?
Banning headers makes corners pretty much redundant as well, considering the keeper can just catch any ball in the air completely unchallenged.
It's part of the game, if you don't like it, don't let your kids play it. Typical of the Americans, doing their utmost to b astardise everything.
Bold Seagull
strong and stable with me, or...
Kids bang their heads all the time, heaviest part of their body, they fall off things, bang into things, clash heads running around. Goodness me. U10's rarely head it as it is. You may as well make rugby style head gear compulsory for all kids just to wear whenever they wake up. It would make no difference to kids football U10 and below - because most of them don't head it anyway, and it's not often the ball is headable anyway given the power they have to kick it.
What happens when some kid gets it full on in the head or face accidentally? Mild panic pitch side? Seriously, a ban...
brightn'ove
cringe
Land of the free.
Megazone
On his last warning
Short corners and goal kicks will encourage better footballing skills.
Keeping the ball on the deck is what kids should be taught anyway.
Kids will think to pass rather than hoof.
Kids will learn to try and control difficult high balls instead of just jumping at it with their eyes shut.
Keeping the ball on the deck is what kids should be taught anyway.
Kids will think to pass rather than hoof.
Kids will learn to try and control difficult high balls instead of just jumping at it with their eyes shut.
Dick Knights Mumm
Take me Home Falmer Road
Well if it rarely happens it won't be a problem will it ?
And accidental clashes and balls in the face are never going to be stopped. It is a contact sport.
Bold Seagull
strong and stable with me, or...
So why ban it? Why ban something that is a fairly rare, and can happen accidentally anyway?
Dick Knights Mumm
Take me Home Falmer Road
Rugby would not be played at junior level if they took that attitude. Everything is designed to suit the age group. And particular care is taken over scrums. It is changing and developing all the time to protect the players and prepare them for the adult game. Except when they are young - it is not the adult game.
Dick Knights Mumm
Take me Home Falmer Road
The brain is a special case. It needs protecting. Why take the risk for your child ?
I don't know how rare it is - I am taking your word. With different coaches and different attitudes it may be more common.
gregbrighton
New member
I agree with this entirely. My son and I watched an under 11s match on Sunday. The team shooting downhill and wind behind kept lumping it forward and that was their only tactic. How is that teaching them anything? They should keep it on the floor and pass pass pass pass pass.
GT49er
Well-known member
Funny how a heading debate has suddenly brought up 'hoofing'. I always thought opposite ends of the body were involved..........
Best teach them the only thing they're allowed to do is pass across or back, never more than a foot off the ground and never further than five yards. They'll soon give up playing football then, so the safety problem will be solved.
Megazone
On his last warning
What a load of utter rollox. Just tell them that God will protect them!
Troll.
Lankyseagull
One Step Beyond
I just love the reactions of this American couple to rugby on this video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MfQqN8JspVg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MfQqN8JspVg
Megazone
On his last warning
If you watch Kids play football, you'll notice most kids don't actually enjoy heading the ball. Most of the kids keep their eyes shut.
What's the point in making a kid do something it's scared of?
Why not teach the kids skills rather than bravery?
Vegas Seagull
New member
- Jul 10, 2009
- 7,782
Doctor interviewed on Skysports stated it was nothing to do with the ball and all about head to head, elbow to head and head to ground that happens when you contest a header.
He was uneasy when questioned re what appropriate age is OK, admitting they didn't know and guessed at the age they picked as inappropriate.
He was uneasy when questioned re what appropriate age is OK, admitting they didn't know and guessed at the age they picked as inappropriate.
gregbrighton
New member
It's all very well saying to kids don't head the ball in organised matches but most kids play football in the playground and in the streets and will invariably will see their favourite football players head the ball and will try to emulate them. Better to teach them how to do it properly and safely. Heading the ball is an integral and exciting part of the game as well as an important facet in developing individual technical skills.
Bold Seagull
strong and stable with me, or...
So no one is teaching skills because we're too busy coaching bravery and heading? Can skills, ball on the deck, and heading not coexist without the need for a ban?
Megazone
On his last warning
Why adults think heading is an important factor in youth football is beyond me?
I guess some people would rather the see competition than development.
When I was about ten, I was playing at Easthill Park Portslade, in the rain, with a leather ball, and got one right on the forehead, hoofed by some great oaf. Head was bruised on the outside, and what passes as my brain has been rattling around in its bony box ever since. I'm not sure what a rule against heading would do about that - I would have ducked had I had the time (and, er, ability).
Still, a shift to playing it on the floor would benefit from this rule, and I agree with many others who have posted on this thread.
That said, I saw some funny coaching when my lad lived on Vancouver island with his mum, 20 years ago. The coach had obviously learned the 'positions' (left half, centre forward, etc) but expected the kids to sort of stand on an invisible spot for 90 minutes to reflect this. It didn't work, of course, and all 20 outfield players were soon swarming around the ball like flies round a rolling turd.
Still, a shift to playing it on the floor would benefit from this rule, and I agree with many others who have posted on this thread.
That said, I saw some funny coaching when my lad lived on Vancouver island with his mum, 20 years ago. The coach had obviously learned the 'positions' (left half, centre forward, etc) but expected the kids to sort of stand on an invisible spot for 90 minutes to reflect this. It didn't work, of course, and all 20 outfield players were soon swarming around the ball like flies round a rolling turd.