That man DEAN is at it again

[Kinky Gerbil]

If it's a pen it's a red, not sure it's a pen though.

If it was a foul outside the area it would have been a red still.

It looked like he took his time as was talking the the linesman.

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

How is that a red card when the Gomes one against Palace wasn't?

Gomes was deemed to be an attempt for the ball

 

[PILTDOWN MAN]

Gomes was deemed to be an attempt for the ball

I was closer to the ball than Gomes and I was watching it in Sussex

 

[edna krabappel]

Gomes was deemed to be an attempt for the ball

Dean appeared to be mouthing "you pulled him" at Redmond, which would suggest he didn't think he was trying to play the ball. I think if he did pull him, it was the previous attempt, outside the box. Can actually understand why he gave it, from his perspective (same as I can understand why Stroud sent Onuoha off yesterday, even if replays subsequently showed him to be wrong).

 

[Bakero]

Gomes was deemed to be an attempt for the ball

Without your lily-white specs, do you think that was a harsh red card?

 

[Durlston]

Had a bet on 2-1 Spurs.

Without the complete and utter shyster intervention, there's a fair chance I could have won my bet.

Is it natural to want to punch someone in the face for continously ruining football enjoyment again and again and causing so much misery?

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

I was closer to the ball than Gomes and I was watching it in Sussex

But he at least aimed a kick at the ball!

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Without your lily-white specs, do you think that was a harsh red card?

Yes, as I said I'm not sure it was a pen.

However I did the first time I watched it and in Deans defence he would have had the view from behind and would have only seen Redmonds hands in a pulling motion.

The linesman would have had a better view - he should have said something.

It certainly wasn't a terrible decision, it may not have been correct, but you can at least see the thinking behind it.

 

[PILTDOWN MAN]

But he at least aimed a kick at the ball!

And I a stern look at the tv, surely that counts

 

[PILTDOWN MAN]

Yes, as I said I'm not sure it was a pen.

However I did the first time I watched it and in Deans defence he would have had the view from behind and would have only seen Redmonds hands in a pulling motion.

The linesman would have had a better view - he should have said something.

It certainly wasn't a terrible decision, it may not have been correct, but you can at least see the thinking behind it.

There is no defence of the egotistical wa*ker

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

There is no defence of the egotistical wa*ker

For obvious reasons I don't feel the same level of hate against him, dont think think he's a bad ref....

Saying that I don't think many of the refs in the top division are terrible,it's s thankless task

Certainly wouldn't want to do it.

 

[PILTDOWN MAN]

For obvious reasons I don't feel the same level of hate against him, dont think think he's a bad ref....

Saying that I don't think many of the refs in the top division are terrible,it's s thankless task

Certainly wouldn't want to do it.

Well as he celebrates Spurs goals no you're right

 

[Tarpon]

Not over it and the bloke is an absolute w@nker of the highest order. Lest we forget:

1. He saw the challenge and (incorrectly) deemed it a yellow.
2. Upon seeing the injury and after having the yellow card knocked out of his hand he put it away and produced a red.
3. He clearly carded the injury not the challenge.
4. He will never concede or admit any of the above.

Utter shyster.

 

[m20gull]

Utter shyster.

Completely

 

[dazzer6666]

Didn't watch the game but was in the car with Talksport on the radio (and before you start the flaming, Sidwell was one of the presenters for the whole show and he was good value.......long discussion about the championship and the promotion contenders, each team basically involved Sidwell praising them up before saying '......and when we beat them......' plus talking extensively about the spirit in the team). They were crucifying Dean for his decisions - Parlour reckons he doesn't think before he gets a card out.

 

[Tony Meolas Loan Spell]

I confess, I'm pretty much over the Stephens thing. I'm starting to look forward to games The Complete And Utter Shyster referees. He's- unintentionally- hilarious. The gestures, the comedy facial expressions, the no-look yellow cards...it's all brilliant theatrics. Follow @CelebrityRefs on Twitter if you don't believe me.

I feel a lot less bitter about him since I've learned to laugh at him. I'm barely even watching the football. I just can't take my eyes of Magic Mike. Try it. It's quite cathartic.

Glad you are. Im NOT. Like fan stealing Charlton Athletic I will be hating him for YEARS.

 

[sydney]

I confess, I'm pretty much over the Stephens thing. I'm starting to look forward to games The Complete And Utter Shyster referees. He's- unintentionally- hilarious. The gestures, the comedy facial expressions, the no-look yellow cards...it's all brilliant theatrics. Follow @CelebrityRefs on Twitter if you don't believe me.

I feel a lot less bitter about him since I've learned to laugh at him. I'm barely even watching the football. I just can't take my eyes of Magic Mike. Try it. It's quite cathartic.

i can find no humour in the fact that he is tagged as one of the elite referees , supposedly at the top of his profession and yet clearly is a showboating , biased , inept bell end and still a complete and utter shyster.

 

[Tony Meolas Loan Spell]

For obvious reasons I don't feel the same level of hate against him, dont think think he's a bad ref....

Saying that I don't think many of the refs in the top division are terrible,it's s thankless task

Certainly wouldn't want to do it.

And you would say that as a spurs fan and Dean is a spurs fan.

 

[Tony Meolas Loan Spell]

That man cost us 100m anyone who thinks otherwise can do one. Its not a laughing matter. The man needs to be hounded out of football.

 

[Triggaaar]

I confess, I'm pretty much over the Stephens thing.

You need to take a long hard look at yourself.




And ideally let me join in.