[Albion] Player ratings - Albion v Marseille?

[aolstudios]

Is it possible I missed these? Just recovering now, so here goes...

Steele – 7
Hinshelwood – 7.5
van Hecke – 8.5
Dunk – 8
Igor – 8.5
Groß – 8.5
Gilmour – 9 MoM, obviously
Adingra – 6.5
Buonanotte – 7.
Mitoma – 7.5
Pedro – 8.5

Ferguson – 6
Milner – 7
Lallana – 7
Veltman - n/a
Baleba n/a

 

[Machiavelli]

Finally got a bit of time to write mine too. Memory probably hasn't helped:

Steele 7 -- good distribution
Hinshelwood 7 -- his touch is sublime, and positioning just as good, faded before coming off with his passing radar malfunctioning
Van Hecke 8 -- beast
Dunk 8 -- does it again
Igor 8.5 -- the best of our defenders
Gilmour 8.5 -- metronomic, getting more aggressive and snappier in the tackle
Gross 9 MotM -- another assist from Gross, amongst so much more
Adingra 6 -- lively, but very poor with the final ball. He can be excused because he's played so many minutes of late
Buonanotte 7.5 -- best performance this season, a lot more aggressive, was brilliant at leading the press, used his right foot more, and was constantly getting into good positions, kept things ticking over
Mitoma 7.5 -- also lively, one or two disappointing final balls
Joao Pedro 7.5 -- some brilliant running and stretching of their back line and fantastic finish, but his final ball was suspect at times too, and might have finished better once or twice

Subs:
Ferguson 6
Milner 8 -- just the ticket
Lallana 9 -- thought he was sensational, so inventive, playing high up the pitch nearly everything he did paid off
Veltman and Baleba n/a

 

[Austrian Gull]

Don't know if anyone has posted L'Équipe's ratings:

Steele 5
Hinshelwood 5
Dunk 6
Van Hecke 6
Igor 5
Gilmour 7
Gross 7
Agindra 5
Mitoma 6
Buonanotte 4
Pedro 7
RDZ 6
Ref 6

 

[BRIGHT ON Q]

Igor 5 that's spiteful

 

[dazzer6666]

Don't know if anyone has posted L'Équipe's ratings:

Steele 5
Hinshelwood 5
Dunk 6
Van Hecke 6
Igor 5
Gilmour 7
Gross 7
Agindra 5
Mitoma 6
Buonanotte 4
Pedro 7
RDZ 6
Ref 6

How did they rate the Marseille players ?

 

[Austrian Gull]

How did they rate the Marseille players ?

Lopez 6
Meite 5
Mbemba 7
Balerdi 5
Clauss 4
Veretout 4
Ounahi 4
Harit 5
Lodi 4
Vitinha 3
Aubameyang 4
Gattuso 5

 

[dazzer6666]

Lopez 6
Meite 5
Mbemba 7
Balerdi 5
Clauss 4
Veretout 4
Ounahi 4
Harit 5
Lodi 4
Vitinha 3
Aubameyang 4
Gattuso 5

Thanks….not unfair on that basis I guess…..

 

[amexer]

Is it possible I missed these? Just recovering now, so here goes...

Steele – 7
Hinshelwood – 7.5
van Hecke – 8.5
Dunk – 8
Igor – 8.5
Groß – 8.5
Gilmour – 9 MoM, obviously
Adingra – 6.5
Buonanotte – 7.
Mitoma – 7.5
Pedro – 8.5

Ferguson – 6
Milner – 7
Lallana – 7
Veltman - n/a
Baleba n/a

Would these have differed if we had not scored

 

[Uh_huh_him]

Lopez 6
Meite 5
Mbemba 7
Balerdi 5
Clauss 4
Veretout 4
Ounahi 4
Harit 5
Lodi 4
Vitinha 3
Aubameyang 4
Gattuso 5

Assume L'Equipe use 5 as average rather than 6

Otherwiase both sets of scores are overly harsh

 

[Swegulls]

Mbemba was actually quite good.

 

[Farehamseagull]

For anyone not up to speed with L’Equipe ratings, those ratings for us are very generous! They are famously brutal!

 

[One Teddy Maybank]

6 - average

Steele - 6
Hinshelwood - 7
Van Hecke - 7
Dunk - 8
Igor - 8
Gilmour - 9
Gross - 8
Mitoma - 7
Adingra - 5
Buononotte - 7
Pedro - 7

Ferguso - 6
Milner - 6
Lallana - 7
Veltman n/a
Baleba n/a

 

[North of Robertsbridge]

And as someone there has pointed out

SussexByTheSea

Pourtant Gilmour, Gross et Mitoma méritent + qu'un 7... N'oublions pas que les Seagulls ont perdu leur premier match contre l'AEK à domicile, encaissé 2 buts dans les 20 premières au stade vélodrome et sont sortis premiers de leur poule

 

[raymondo]

And as someone there has pointed out

SussexByTheSea

Pourtant Gilmour, Gross et Mitoma méritent + qu'un 7... N'oublions pas que les Seagulls ont perdu leur premier match contre l'AEK à domicile, encaissé 2 buts dans les 20 premières au stade vélodrome et sont sortis premiers de leur poule

"However Gilmour, Gross and Mitoma deserve more than a 7... Let's not forget that the Seagulls lost their first match against AEK at home, conceded 2 goals in the first 20 at the Velodrome stadium and came out first in their chicken"

Google translate often gives me a chuckle

 

[North of Robertsbridge]

>> and came out first in their chicken"

>> Google translate often gives me a chuckle

There's an art to writing so Google translate doesn't get confused and this time I neglected to do that

 

[zefarelly]

8.89378 all round

we scored
We kept a clean sheet

we just won biggest thing in the clubs history.

I think there's room for improvement, but so far so good.

 

[Bodian]

Mbemba was actually quite good.

Thought Clauss was too - they only gave him a 4

 

[aolstudios]

Would these have differed if we had not scored

No. A knackered bare bones of a team worked hard & ground Marseille down in a deserved victory. All of them.
Without the goal only the last word or two change

 

[medwayseagull reborn]

Thought Clauss was too - they only gave him a 4

Didn't realise Santa was playing.

 

[tigertim68]

Is it possible I missed these? Just recovering now, so here goes...

Steele – 7
Hinshelwood – 7.5
van Hecke – 8.5
Dunk – 8
Igor – 8.5
Groß – 8.5
Gilmour – 9 MoM, obviously
Adingra – 6.5
Buonanotte – 7.
Mitoma – 7.5
Pedro – 8.5

Ferguson – 6
Milner – 7
Lallana – 7
Veltman - n/a
Baleba n/a

Probably about right