Se20
Banned
- Oct 3, 2012
- 3,981
Who are they ?
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Guidetti, Falque, Barnes, Kane
- Thread starter northstandsteve
- Start date
Who are they ?
Exactly!
forumwayseagull
Well-known member
Couldn't agree more, either buy him for around 1- 1.5 million of season loan..
portslade seagull
Well-known member
Can't believe people think Barnes is so bad ... Play him upfront and he will yes WILL score goals ... Play Ulloa on the wing and see how many he scores
Seagull on the wing
New member
That's what I thought with that career ending tackle that put him out of the game for life....personally don't think Billy Sharp would come here anyway...
fat old seagull
New member
Hello Pee Wee... You little rascal you, I think you need treatment at NSC Anonymous, there must be one in the Croyden area.
But there again I suppose you're either telling us how good this forum is or how crepe Eaglespoo forum is. Bit of both I suppose.
But you don't talk poo all the time (just mostly) Barnsy is not in the millions of pounds bracket but of course everyone else is selling you players at over their value so who knows ?
Basil Fawlty
Don't Mention The War
300K is just laughable for Barnes, if the scum are serious then a £1 or £2 Million pound offer could be reasonable. Especially now that we have placed a deal on the Table for him last week, hopefully he will sign it ASAP.
Philzo-93
Well-known member
If Barnes has been statistically more proven at this level than CMS, then I'm definitely asking no less than £2.5 million!!!
Rambo
Don't Push me
I have a gut feeling that a deal has already been done for Barnes, with Becchio coming in as a replacement. Don't know why just think he is going.
TSB
Captain Hindsight
Erm ok, well firstly there's a BIG reason not to. Secondly, Murray rejected our offer of a contract and signed for them. He was a free agent. With Dobbie, we were DESPERATE to get rid of him from the wage bill.
Ash is neither free, nor is he surplus to requirements.
So, no sale to 'Nil Point' palace.
TSB
Captain Hindsight
Would hope that Ash is staying. He won't be leaving for Becchio anyway, that's for sure. Why not?
Becchio is an inferior version of Leo. You couldn't play the two together. So that means he'd have to drop down a division to be a bench filler. Can't see that.
Leo going and Becchio coming in for him? Now that I can see. Not in this window though.
DanielT
Well-known member
So we have to give them £250k to take him?
BensGrandad
New member
Barnes is nearly 25 so can walk away at the end of his contract, end of the season, for nothing so why would CPFC buy him they would probably do as they did with Murray and give him the money as a signing on fee rather than us.
a) They need players now (not that I think Barnes is what they need)
b) Once he's a free agent he can go anywhere
c) Barnes might be better advised to take the security of a contract rather than wait for a season and take his chances
BensGrandad
New member
The point in A is correct as indeed is B but if he went to Palace no moving etc. He will find club at least in The Championship so C isnt a problem or due much consideration.
TSB
Captain Hindsight
You're an idiot if you think we'd sell Ash to palace without first having someone else lined up AND palace paying ridiculously over the odds.
I'd say point C was pretty important. Dicker is a free agent but don't see too many biting his hand off and only 18 months ago he was being talked about as getting into the Irish team. If Barnes hangs on and has a bit of a gash season then come next year he may well get offers but maybe on significantly lesser pay at a club with no real prospect of promotion.
1 in Kate Bush is better than 2 in the hand as they say!
darters74
New member
Injured is he?