England's Number 1
- Thread starter Trigger
- Start date
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Basil Fawlty
Don't Mention The War
Robinson was dreadful tonight, doesn't seem to be on any confidence what so ever. I think David James should be given an chance in the next qualifier, but that aint going to happen with an clown in charge.
SussexSpur
New member
Carson or Green would make at least as many mistakes, for all the saves they had to make last season they also looked pretty unreliable and certainly flawed plenty of times as well. Not quite sure why Robbo's turned so occasionally nervy and uncertain during the past two seasons, but as a shot-stopper (yes, yes, a cliche, I know) and authoritative presence he's potentially (potentially, on regular-ish form) about the best we have available right now.
SussexSpur
New member
I dunno, he seems to shift with the wind of whatever most pundits and Press commentators seem to be demanding at whatever present moment in time, so I reckon there's a very good chance James will indeed play at least the first of those qualifiers.
Easy 10
Brain dead MUG SHEEP
I am frankly HORRIFIED at Robinsons recent performances. I honestly thought he was a safe pair of hands for England following the circus act that was David James. The fact that James is now back in contention is a deeply, DEEPLY disturbing development. Ben Foster looked the SHIZ last season, we badly need him to stake a claim. And quick.
Agree with all of that.
Simon Morgan
New member
Foster, when fit, would be my number 1. But as he's injured, it has to be Scott Carson. Good young keepers with no strings attached.
andybaha
Active member
England have been spoilt for keepers for about 30+ years - Banks, Shilton, Clemence and even Seaman. All could probably claim to have been the best keeper in the world at some stage in their career. We just don't have a particularly good batch at the moment. We don't have an English keeper among the top 6 keepers in the Premiership.
Robinson had a poor world cup last year and the fact that we are even thinking about James again speaks volumes.
Robinson had a poor world cup last year and the fact that we are even thinking about James again speaks volumes.
Lord Bracknell
On fire
Time to give a cap to Cudicini?
Easy 10
Brain dead MUG SHEEP
Cudicini has been working part time in Starbucks down Oxford Street for the last 12 months. OK he stirs a mean cappucino, but I just don't think he's ready to help salvage the wreckage of our Euro 2008 qualifying campaign.
Lord Bracknell
On fire
... and Robinson IS ?
Easy 10
Brain dead MUG SHEEP
Well, thats another argument.
*sigh*
If only Hendo were english, eh.
What ? Why are you all looking at me like that ?
SeagullTim
Boomer Sooner
Vatican Citys No.2 Keeper
Rebels & Albion
Apparently England are looking into if there is any way that they could get Kasper Schmeichel to play for them
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/gossip_and_transfers/6959728.stm
JJ McClure
Go Jags
100% not good enough.
Green, Carson, Foster, Robinson and James are all solid enough keepers but they are all prone to stupid mistakes.
While Carson and Foster did well for Watford and Charlton they did both make utter clangers, I mean Foster was beaten by Robinson.
Green hasnt really kicked on from his season at Norwich and has sort of done a Richard Wright in going backwards.
I dunno what it is about Robinson, His ability on crosses as always been OK at best but recently he seems to have turned into a Kuipers at them and flaping a lot.
Saying that that goal last night wasnt 100% his fault, it was a miss hit cross and whilst he could have done better with it I struggle to see how much more, Lets face it least it didnt cost us a place in the World cup like Seaman!
While Carson and Foster did well for Watford and Charlton they did both make utter clangers, I mean Foster was beaten by Robinson.
Green hasnt really kicked on from his season at Norwich and has sort of done a Richard Wright in going backwards.
I dunno what it is about Robinson, His ability on crosses as always been OK at best but recently he seems to have turned into a Kuipers at them and flaping a lot.
Saying that that goal last night wasnt 100% his fault, it was a miss hit cross and whilst he could have done better with it I struggle to see how much more, Lets face it least it didnt cost us a place in the World cup like Seaman!
Easy 10
Brain dead MUG SHEEP
I think you're being EXTREMELY generous there.
Maybe, then again maybe not.
Ive only seen it twice, and thats what I thought when saw it the half time highlights.