rebel51
Well-known member
In a nutshell.Not convinced by him at all. Just seems to lightweight and the midfield always struggles when he plays
In a nutshell.Not convinced by him at all. Just seems to lightweight and the midfield always struggles when he plays
Was saying the same to my son.Billy Gilmour mk II anyone?
It's a shame we went for quantity over quality.I like Ayari, but he lacks the quality we need.
it’s astonishing that he is seemingly first choice after spending a fortune on central midfielders this season.
I reckon there might be some horses for courses selection in midfield.In that midfield two, Baleba is clearly first choice. However, alongside him it's one of Ayari, Hinsh, Wieffer or Gomez. Considering his poor loan spells last season, he's had a remarkable season. He presses well, is decent on the ball, and that goal might just kick him on another notch.
I actually agree with that. Hinsh offers a slightly better goal threat in the box. It's close thoughI reckon there might be some horses for courses selection in midfield.
For games where it's going to be a congested battle, Wieffer gets the nod, for counter attack teams where there are spaces for him to move into Ayari looks the best bet. But on average I would say that Hinsh is currently just about above Yasin and is more likely to start
Definitely a work in progress. I'll forgive him the second goal as a great ball in. However, clearly at fault on two accounts for the first. Fails to track Bowen's run and when the cross comes in he does rather wave a lazy foot at it in an attempt to block it.Where are we with Yasin?
His game seems to be coming on right? He was magnificent going forward for the first half at the weekend and decent in the second.
His goal will have boosted his confidence after a pretty ordinary season of finishing.
His defensive work though? I thought he left Bowen to run in behind for their first and lost Soucek for the second. Yeh, there are other things that went on for both goals, and yeh, getting done by Bowen on the floor and Soucek in the air isn't shameful. But I would contend there is work to do on the defensive side, in particular tracking runners and staying goal side.
Anyway I don't want to be overcritical as he's had a terrific year.
But does he keep his place once Baleba resumes in midfield, and we have a specialist full backs on both sides? I'd suggest maybe not as a starter
I agree with this, except to say that there are situations where Hinsh is required as cover elsewhere on the pitch, and he's not so much better in midfield than Ayari that Ayari wouldn't slot into midfield where Hinsh plays as cover.I reckon there might be some horses for courses selection in midfield.
For games where it's going to be a congested battle, Wieffer gets the nod, for counter attack teams where there are spaces for him to move into Ayari looks the best bet. But on average I would say that Hinsh is currently just about above Yasin and is more likely to start
While true, I think Wieffer is a better right-back than Hinsh so suspect we'll see more of Hinsh in midfield.I agree with this, except to say that there are situations where Hinsh is required as cover elsewhere on the pitch, and he's not so much better in midfield than Ayari that Ayari wouldn't slot into midfield where Hinsh plays as cover.
That's very much my feeling. He might not be brilliant for 90 mins but at his age I do think he shows so much promise (in the Premier League!) that hopefully he can only get better. He has adjusted to top flight football better than I thought he would.He's going great. Fab clearly likes him because he has amazing stamina, his energy in the last 20 minutes is astounding. Still young and developing - he could become amazing. Mac Allister at the same age was just making his Brighton debut, 9 appearances in his first season at the same age.
I think we've always seen something in him - RDZ gave him his premier league debut as a starter in the very last game of the 22-23 season with European football already secured - don't think he would have done that if he hadn't recognised his promise
Agree with this. Wieffer has done OK at right back, where Hinsh looks more uncertain. The opposite is true in midfieldWhile true, I think Wieffer is a better right-back than Hinsh so suspect we'll see more of Hinsh in midfield.
He wasn't alone in being at fault for the first goal.Definitely a work in progress. I'll forgive him the second goal as a great ball in. However, clearly at fault on two accounts for the first. Fails to track Bowen's run and when the cross comes in he does rather wave a lazy foot at it in an attempt to block it.