[Football] Worst managerial change in history

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊







peterward

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Nov 11, 2009
13,052
Can anyone top Leicester City and Ruud? Or even get close?
The useless Stains manager is giving him a run for his money this season.

Blackburn sacked Allardyce and appointed yes man, Steve Kean! (Edit: just seen Han Solo make same point)

And the other Albion booted Pulis and just 4 months later.........

"On 2 April 2018, West Bromwich Albion and Pardew mutually parted company after he had been manager for four months. At the time, Albion had gone ten games without a win, were on a run of eight successive defeats and were rock bottom of the Premier League"
 


stewart12

Well-known member
Jan 16, 2019
2,167
Yeh still never understood getting rid of Wilkins, who was doing a decent if unspectacular job in difficult circumstances and replacing him with Adams
 








Hovegull

Well-known member
Nov 27, 2022
905
Howard Wilkinson - Sunderland

Lawrie Sanchez - Fulham

Egil Olsen - Wimbledon

Tony Adams - Portsmouth

Paulo Di Canio - Sunderland

Steve McClaren - Newcastle

Steve Wrigley - Southampton

Frank De Boer - Palace
 


stewart12

Well-known member
Jan 16, 2019
2,167
Adams 2 was awful.

Lacklustre, hoof ball
I feel like Knight wanted a romantic, nostalgia boost and for Adams to be managing us for the first Amex season

In hindsight it was a diabolical move really and unfortunately made him look very out of touch

Not saying Wilkins was doing an incredible job but he definitely could have held the job until Blooms money came in (in my opinion anyway)
 


peterward

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Nov 11, 2009
13,052
I feel like Knight wanted a romantic, nostalgia boost and for Adams to be managing us for the first Amex season

In hindsight it was a diabolical move really and unfortunately made him look very out of touch

Not saying Wilkins was doing an incredible job but he definitely could have held the job until Blooms money came in (in my opinion anyway)
Wilkins was a Brighton man and he was doing a pretty decent job considering the circumstances, no way did he deserve or did performances justify him being sacked.

Agreed it was Knights heart over head and it was both a terrible decision and very unfair on a great Albion servant.
 






Thunder Bolt

Silly old bat
Wilkins was a Brighton man and he was doing a pretty decent job considering the circumstances, no way did he deserve or did performances justify him being sacked.

Agreed it was Knights heart over head and it was both a terrible decision and very unfair on a great Albion servant.
I'm not going into details but Wilkins did deserve to be sacked.

It was a mistake to get Micky back.
 








Feb 23, 2009
17,943
Marlborough
Birmingham sacking Gary Rowett when they were just outside the play-offs on GD and replacing them with Zola, who had them in 20th and only out of the relegation zone on GD when he resigned four months later.

Also Birmingham sacking John Eustace, who had them in the play-offs, and replacing him with Rooney who lasted 15 games and was the catalyst for their relegation last season.

I'd still argue Van Nistelrooy is the worst appointment ever, mind.
 






Lenny Rider

Well-known member
Sep 15, 2010
6,420
Hinsh at Withdean?
Circumstances old boy, Dick was going to rock the football world with a 6pm press conference at The Grand Hotel to unveil a genuine 'wow' appointment, who promptly pulled out in the afternoon, hence the Chairman's phone call to MH around 4.30.

Two huge factors that summer.

All credit to Peter Taylor for going when he did, he could have collected at least two months money before saying on the eve of the season what he did back in May.

We will never know how Hinsh would have fared that season, if him and Bob had a full pre season, very fine margins, even in the run of straight defeats.
 


Tom Hark Preston Park

Will Post For Cash
Jul 6, 2003
74,025
Circumstances old boy, Dick was going to rock the football world with a 6pm press conference at The Grand Hotel to unveil a genuine 'wow' appointment, who promptly pulled out in the afternoon, hence the Chairman's phone call to MH around 4.30.

Two huge factors that summer.

All credit to Peter Taylor for going when he did, he could have collected at least two months money before saying on the eve of the season what he did back in May.

We will never know how Hinsh would have fared that season, if him and Bob had a full pre season, very fine margins, even in the run of straight defeats.
Was going to be that (German?) guy with the Lion King head of hair fresh from the World Cup wasn't it? Fair play to Hinsh obviously for filling in at very short notice. But even so...
 


coyotitokino

New member
Aug 21, 2024
18
Blackburn replacing Sam Allardyce with Steve Kean. I've talked with a player he had at the time and for me there's no doubt the PL has never had a worse manager.
Undoubtedly this one. The absolute risk of appointing a yes man following an ownership change and with the club trying to disguise the beginning of a process of asset stripping. They made noises about signing Ronaldinho (considered among the best in the world at the time https://www.theguardian.com/football/2011/jan/04/ronaldinho-david-beckham-blackburn-steve-kean). Almost all of the others are legitimate people trying their best but unfortunately failing. When you look at the points per game and consider the squad they had at appointment comparatively to others it's shocking: https://www.football365.com/news/10-worst-premier-league-managers-all-time-parker-mccarthy. The element of deception makes Kean the worst, and the fans called him out and hated him for it.
 








Paris

Well-known member
Jul 17, 2010
4,136
13th district
Can you expand please. Have always thought Wilkins had created a decent team out of the waif and strays of Sussex.
We finished 7th in League One, 2007-2008. I seem to remember that was fairly well received, under the circumstances(blooding youngsters on a regular basis).

Wilkins deserved another crack. Obviously Dick Knight thought otherwise.
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top