Who would you rather have?

[Flicky_12]

Michael Rose
Matt Richards

 

[RM-Taylor]

I thought Rose has joined Peterborough?

EDIT: Oh that's someone from Stockport called Rowe

 

[wallington seagull]

Would we not be better off trying to get Billy Jones from Crewe, cracking left foot and tall as well

 

[Flicky_12]

good shout the other two i think are more likely to sign

Richards because hes been here before

Rose because Jimmy Mcnulty and maybe Gary dicker

 

[Kosh]

Matt Richards, cus he looks like Ben Miller.

Pure comedy gold.

Hoks

 

[the hitman]

would prefere Rose, but what happens when Mcnulty can play again?

 

[Da Man Clay]

I'd not sure we really want to be signing either to be honest, Jimmy Mac is a better left back than both of them and I would assume that they'd be asking for decent wages. Much rather a youngster on loan who can come in and do a job until JM is back.

 

[Flicky_12]

michael rose to play left mid
very attcking good pace and good delivery
or the same just instead of Rose have Richards

 

[Ninja Elephant]

I would prefer Billy Jones of Crewe, or Michael Jackson of Huddersfield.

But of those two, better the devil you know.. I'd like Richards.

 

[keaton]

Sullivan, Fraser, Loft or Hinshelwood

 

[Da Man Clay]

The only issue with that is that we don't really want to start playing players out of position again. I'd rather get an established winger to do that job instead of shoe horning someone into that position.

 

[Flicky_12]

fair enough but what decent naturally left footed wingers are there that would sign for us for a small fee ?

 

[keaton]

fair enough but what decent naturally left footed wingers are there that would sign for us for a small fee ?

Is Brooker still free? wicked

 

[Knotty]

How many people have seen enough of Rose to really be able to make a judgement?

 

[Kosh]

Thorny issue that one petal.

HilariOuS

K'

 

[Finchley Seagull]

Michael Rose
Matt Richards

I don't want to sound harsh but this must be the most pointless poll ever. You are asking us to decide between two full backs (neither of whom we might be interested in) based on seeing one of them play once. Richards we saw regularly but it is hard to compare him to Rose.

 

[NF9]

Both are wank

 

[Mendoza]

What are people basing Michael Rose as a left footed footballing god on?

Ive only seen him play two games, the first, I dont remember him playing in, the second he played OK in. Richards, I have seen enough of to know I dont want him in the team as a regular, but an adequete back would be fine

 

[beorhthelm]

Pics?

oh... its not that sort of thread.

 

[NF9]

Hawkins