Pevenseagull
meh
- Jul 20, 2003
- 21,711
Phil Andrews
Who is the worst player you have seen play for the Albion?
- Thread starter piersa
- Start date
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
My Mistake
Yes that's the one!
Forgot about Tiltman. I played against him at u18 level. He was super fast and that was about it!
Yes that's the one!
Forgot about Tiltman. I played against him at u18 level. He was super fast and that was about it!
- Thread starter
- #83
I played against Darren Freeman just before he went pro. He was strong and fit but that was it. He got sent off too!
My thoughts too. Think we signed him from Whitehawk, but he found the step up too demanding. Not the WORST I have seen though.
He was sold for a million after he left us and also played in an FA Cup final, and won about 30 caps. Good player for us, surprised you put him in this thread.
collins91
New member
ok
couldn't give a shitchez
Johnny Byrne-The Greatest
At least keep the jokes believable!! Robbie was a decent enough loan signing for us, he rarely lost the ball and always found a team mate. Just because he didn't score 30 yarders it doesn't make him a shit player.
Jimbo26
New member
Richard Tiltman without doubt
I saw his one decent game on a freezing afternoon at Barnsley. He picked up the ball 40 yards from goal, wandered aimlessly forward and we took cover in anticipation, and then hit an absolute ZINGER into the top corner, five minutes later he did exactly the same and hit the bar, then returned into his normal self.
It was as if his body had been taken over by the ghost of a footballer, and then the apparition had vacated his body.
Mackenzie
Old Brightonian
Goalkeeper Graham Smith. 'kin useless.
patchamalbion
Well-known member
not the worst but i do remember Tony Rougier handballing it 3 times in one half away at Ipswich one year, luckily the ref saw the funny side at how bad his ball control was and i dont think he got booked.
Mackenzie
Old Brightonian
Worst performance, and I've seen a few, goes to......drum roll......David Livermore V Walsall 
seagullsoverlincoln
New member
- Jul 14, 2009
- 521
Agree-cost £1000 from the army and he was overpriced at that-If my (albeit shit) memory serves me right,even Mickey Adams(or maybe assistant Alan Cork)called him useless
Seasidesage
New member
Richard Tiltman absolutely terrible. Remember him missing about 5 one on one's against Palace in 87 I think?
The Modfather
New member
Is the correct answer
Durlston
Heavy XTC user
- Jul 15, 2009
- 10,220
John Westcott or Jamie Moralee in the Gillingham years. Moralee was shagging Daniela Westbrook around that time. One game springs to mind, the 5-1 defeat at 'home' to Millwall on a freezing cold Tuesday evening in January in the Auto Windscreens Shield. Someone started a chant of "You'll only win the windscreens and you'll smash them anyway!" to the tune of Glory, glory Man United. 
There are some strange people out there, Eric the ninja? You must be joking. Peter Smith won player of the season for christ sake! The worst 3 have been mentioned on here a number of times, they are in no order, Valur Gislasson, Ashley Neal and Michael Mahoney-Johnson. Personally the likes of the Fox brothers should also get dishonourable mentions, but at least they tried - unlike those other three. I'd like to single out Mahoney-Johnson though as the worst, cos I recall him being very disrespectful to the Albion as he thought he was too good to play for us. W*nker.
ForeverAGull
New member
Robbie Savage!!
The Bear
Member
- Dec 21, 2010
- 115
The echos of "la la laaa Rougier" that day were epic!
In my 19 years watching the Albion, Damian Hilton has to be the worst by a country mile. I remember an evening away game at Mansfield, he wouldn't have got within half a mile of the proverbial barn door. On a similar note, the Early Doors behind the away end at Mansfield was a great pub!