Which musicians do you think were born with the (real) X Factor?

[Mellotron]

Michael Jackson HAS to be top of the list surely.

Absolutely top of the pile. Reading his life story atm, fascinating and explains a lot about why he ended up the way he did.

There is no way Michael Jackson was ever going to be anything other than a world famous pop star.

 

[Garry Nelson's Left Foot]

Spot on again. What a crap thread, sorry

I don't know, it had massive potential to descend into a binfest of epic proportions but it hasn't so I reckon it's doing alright.

I prefer Noel's singing to be honest, Conboy. His voice has a kind of pathos and depth to it that Liam just can't or won't ever have.

Noel sang a wicked version of Cum on feel the noize on Jools Holland once that pees over Liam's version. It is on Youtube but the quality is awful and doesn't do it justice.

Can you imagine Liam singing "Half the World Away"? He's murder it.

It's pointless to compare their voices like that, I think. Noel's voice does have a certain something to it that Liam's doesn't but then you can say the same the other way round. Imagine if Definitely Maybe had been sung by Noel instead of Liam. If that had happened it's highly unlikely any of us would have even heard of Half the World Away...

For what it's worth I think both Gallaghers have the 'x-factor', although for me Liam has more.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Class? are you sure?

I do actually.