Was JFC’s goal at QPR unfairly disallowed?

[StanmoreSeagull]

Still trying to work out how we didn't get a free-kick in the 1st half when Andrews was brought down right on the edge of their box?

 

[Carrot Cruncher]

If that was when Andrews was pulled back just as he was shaping to shoot after a good few passes to set it up, then yes but I only heard it on Player. Commentators were 100% sure it was a free kick but it wasn't given.

If I'd still been listening on 5 live then it would probably have been a great tackle if the commentator had even seen it and wasn't looking on the floor for his stopwatch

I think it must've been then.

Still trying to work out how we didn't get a free-kick in the 1st half when Andrews was brought down right on the edge of their box?

 

[GT49er]

We had a goal disallowed? Blimey - I only had BBC and Sky match reports to go on, so I didn't think we ever got out of our own half!

 

[portslade seagull]

Yeah no mention of the disallowed goal anywhere

 

[symyjym]

Yeah no mention of the disallowed goal anywhere

We had a goal disallowed? Blimey - I only had BBC and Sky match reports to go on, so I didn't think we ever got out of our own half!

What, so you missed this:



Still convinced that Barnes didn't do anything other than go for a header.

 

[Jack Daniels]

There was an incident in the first half where one of ours was shaping to shoot and appeared to have his legs taken away. Ref waved play on. Anyone else get a better view of it?

That's exactly the situation that sprung to my mind. Especially when the slightest touch yielded a qpr free kick.

I also thought, the Albion player kicking the ball out for what should have been a qpr corner and was given goal kick was hilarious.

 

[Jack Daniels]

Ref was alright. He got the big decisions right apart from when he should have booked Barton for deliberate handball that would have been his second yellow. As usual it always appears that the opposition are getting the rub of the green - but that's because we are biased.

A guy near me was constantly doing his nut at the referee , which was funny because the decisions which upset him were minor.

Could have easily been me. Sadly the referees incompetence probably changed the whole shape of the game.

Anyways I am excited for Saturday when I am going to watch a man in the middle make lots of random decisions. I hope the scheduled football match does not get in the way too much.

 

[portslade seagull]

What, so you missed this:

View attachment 47100

Still convinced that Barnes didn't do anything other than go for a header.

Can't see anything wrong with what Barnes did at that angle

 

[symyjym]

Yeah no mention of the disallowed goal anywhere

We had a goal disallowed? Blimey - I only had BBC and Sky match reports to go on, so I didn't think we ever got out of our own half!

Can't see anything wrong with what Barnes did at that angle

I don't know if you clicked on the image, but it's an animation if opened by the way.

 

[BrianWade4]

Worst ref ever

 

[hans kraay fan club]

If that was when Andrews was pulled back just as he was shaping to shoot after a good few passes to set it up, then yes but I only heard it on Player. Commentators were 100% sure it was a free kick but it wasn't given.

If I'd still been listening on 5 live then it would probably have been a great tackle if the commentator had even seen it and wasn't looking on the floor for his stopwatch

Nope. Even Bright and his equally knobbish chum called that one as a foul.