Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Train delays due to high temperatures .... what!!!







markw

Member
Aug 28, 2009
274
It's the rail temperature that counts not the air temperature, Once the rails get to a certain temperature there's an increase in the risk of buckled rails and point failures which is when they go into hot weather working and that causes delay's unfortunately.

This is correct and has been happening for years unfortunately I am on call this week! its one of the issues with continuous welded rail which gives a much better ride as opposed to jointed rail of years ago and happens everywhere in the world. CWR rail is normally stressed so that it can handle higher temps but the problem lies when maintenance at night does not allow for this procedure and a new rail is installed without restoring the stress. It is better to have a speed restriction so that trains have a chance if a buckle happens, but we do have watchmen on site at known unstressed sites. This photo shows what happens in hot weather and quite common, I think you would rather a slight delay than go over this at line speed!

GID00517_5847b.jpg

As a matter of interest, what temperature do you think the rail reached on Saturday just gone with air temp of 26 degrees?
 


Jimmy Grimble

Well-known member


beorhthelm

A. Virgo, Football Genius
Jul 21, 2003
35,332
So back to my earlier question. How do all the many many countries with very much hotter summers than us manage to operate their trains?

i'm going to hazard a guess its the change that has more impact than outright temperature?

This photo shows what happens in hot weather and quite common, I think you would rather a slight delay than go over this at line speed

wowzers, shirley thats not really from heat affect, either a photoshop or the laid it pissed?
 


HawkTheSeagull

New member
Jan 31, 2012
9,122
Eastbourne
Metal/Rail temperature is ALWAYS much higher than air temperature - just feel your metal car bonnet on a hot day and you will find that out.

Apparently in the area yesterday, the rail temperature just outside Vauxhall on the Clapham - Waterloo line was 30 degrees hotter than the air temperature (air 25C, Rail 55C). Running over these lines at line speed can result in the rails buckling and major accidents. New rails arent affected as much but its the old rails being affected - it also affects overhead power lines which "sag" in hot temperatures as the wires expand.
 




markw

Member
Aug 28, 2009
274
i'm going to hazard a guess its the change that has more impact than outright temperature?



wowzers, shirley thats not really from heat affect, either a photoshop or the laid it pissed?

That's a mild buckle! Try this for size...

rail_buckle_512.jpg
 




markw

Member
Aug 28, 2009
274
Metal/Rail temperature is ALWAYS much higher than air temperature - just feel your metal car bonnet on a hot day and you will find that out.

Apparently in the area yesterday, the rail temperature just outside Vauxhall on the Clapham - Waterloo line was 30 degrees hotter than the air temperature (air 25C, Rail 55C). Running over these lines at line speed can result in the rails buckling and major accidents. New rails arent affected as much but its the old rails being affected - it also affects overhead power lines which "sag" in hot temperatures as the wires expand.

The highest on Saturday was in Eastbourne where it always seems to get hotter than others and was 48 degrees and rail temp at 18.00 tonight there was 41 degrees. Heat affects new and old rails the same, it all depends if it has the correct stress when installed or maintenance carried out.
I was at a site of railway work many years ago and watched a gang cut a rail on the hottest day of that year(wouldn't happen now), when the rail was lifted out and 200 yds of clips removed that secure it to the sleeper, it was overlapping 2 1/2" such was the expansion and could not be put back in until 10 hours later at 2 am!
 




goldstone

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
7,131
That's a mild buckle! Try this for size...

View attachment 44575

Wow! You obviously know your subject, but I am still amazed that in 2013 we cannot find a solution to the problem.

So in the California desert where temperatures regularly reach over 100F presumably the track is not continuous welded? and of course the trains, mostly freight, travel at a much slower speed.
 










markw

Member
Aug 28, 2009
274
Wow! You obviously know your subject, but I am still amazed that in 2013 we cannot find a solution to the problem.

So in the California desert where temperatures regularly reach over 100F presumably the track is not continuous welded? and of course the trains, mostly freight, travel at a much slower speed.

There is a solution to the problem but when a defect rail has to replaced and it is not stressed, you need to plan in restressing but as you probably realise its not as easy as that with time restrictions at night. if hot weather occurs before this then it can become an issue. The solutions are in place, there are lots of expansion switch rails dotted around which allow for movement in hot and cold weather and in west sussex there are only 2 watchmen sites with the lowest at 43 degrees so its a very low percentage.
This video shows how quick it happens and its not speeded up!
 








Jimmy Grimble

Well-known member








Mental Lental

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
2,274
Shiki-shi, Saitama
What a pathetic shambles of a public transport system.

Quite. It gets pretty close to 40 degrees C every summer in Tokyo. I never have to wait more than 10 minutes for a train (in the suburbs!) and The Yamanote (Tokyo's circle line) manages to run a train every THREE MINUTES.

The only time they are ever late is when some stressed out overworking salayman jumps in front of one them and even then it only takes about 20 minutes for them to clean up the mess and get the trains running again.

Oh and the trains were also running less than 24 hours after experiencing a major EARTHQUAKE.

How the British public just accept these levels of incompetence is quite beyond me frankly.
 


British Bulldog

The great escape
Feb 6, 2006
10,899
Quite. It gets pretty close to 40 degrees C every summer in Tokyo. I never have to wait more than 10 minutes for a train (in the suburbs!) and The Yamanote (Tokyo's circle line) manages to run a train every THREE MINUTES.

The only time they are ever late is when some stressed out overworking salayman jumps in front of one them and even then it only takes about 20 minutes for them to clean up the mess and get the trains running again.

Oh and the trains were also running less than 24 hours after experiencing a major EARTHQUAKE.

How the British public just accept these levels of incompetence is quite beyond me frankly.

I think the main difference is other countries have had the intelligence to invest the time, Money and the land in creating decent rail networks where as in this country we're still trying to run a modern railway on an old fashioned network. Another difference being that again in other countries they seem to just get on and do things but here we spend most of our time looking for reasons why things can't be done.
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here