timseagull
New member
The way Watford tore us apart last season I'd be tempted to play all three keepers.....
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Team for Watford
- Thread starter Seagulls56
- Start date
SamPeters18
New member
Kuszczak
Calderon - Greer - Upson - Ward
Ince - Andrews
Buckley - Barnes - Conway
Lita
Subs
Ankergren, El-Abd, Bruno, Chicksen, Lopez, Crofts, Barker
Ninja Elephant
Doctor Elephant
- Feb 16, 2009
- 18,855
I watch the game. Upson has been terrible and cost us a lot more than Greer has. Plus he is struggling to kick the football to our players. Greer is our best centre back, Upson is off form and looking tired.
Ultimately though, they are both overexposed by our lack of tactical planning and organisation.
Urchin
New member
- Aug 1, 2011
- 820
I watch the game as well; everyone this season except for QPR in fact.
Firstly, your point about organisation I have to agree with. Why our captain doesn't organise and motivate the team is beyond me. The only thing he does as captain is shout at others (especially Kuszczak) when he himself makes the mistakes. Instead, it's left to a Bolton player on loan to organise, which is shocking in my opinion.
After watching Greer's performances carefully this season, I have come to the conclusion that he's too slow to keep up with the slowest strikers in the league, he backs off way too much, bottles headers and comes across all 'big man' without actually putting a tackle in. Don't even get me started on his passing. Whenever there's a long ball to be played, he decides to pass to Upson. Whenever there's no long ball to be played, he hoofs it up the field. Woeful passing and decision making.
Upson can actually win a header, make a challenge and use the little pace he has to at least keep up with the players. He's also not lazy, unlike others.
Greer needs to be dropped and the armband needs to go to someone else. People seem to forget the El-Abd and Upson partnership at the end of last season. Was completely solid. Greer is a liability.
The Brighton Buzz
Falmer here we come
- Jan 31, 2008
- 1,277
Kuszczak
Calderon
Greer
Upson
Ward
Andrews
Forster-Caskey
Crofts
Conway
Lita
March
Subs
Bruno
Ince
Barker
ElAbd
Buckley
Ankergren
Dickensen or Barnes
Calderon
Greer
Upson
Ward
Andrews
Forster-Caskey
Crofts
Conway
Lita
March
Subs
Bruno
Ince
Barker
ElAbd
Buckley
Ankergren
Dickensen or Barnes
Yes, my pick exactly. The only doubt is JFC or Buckley. Think I'd go for JFC. Would love to see Solly given a start.
brightonmark1234
Well-known member
my team would be big pole calde or bruno greer upson ward andrews crofts buckley or march conway lita barnes
Ninja Elephant
Doctor Elephant
- Feb 16, 2009
- 18,855
Fair post, but I think Upson has been worse. El-Abd replacing either of them would be easily justifiable and personally, I think it is time. Although our defence isn't really what is letting the team down.
I honestly think our players just need to relax a bit, feel a bit more free. Far easier said than done.
Koosh
Bruno---Greer---Upson---Calde
Buckley--Andrews--Crofts--Conway
--------Ward----Lita------------
What's the worst that can happen, that hasn't happened already.
Bruno---Greer---Upson---Calde
Buckley--Andrews--Crofts--Conway
--------Ward----Lita------------
What's the worst that can happen, that hasn't happened already.
BensGrandad
New member
Why play both Calderon and Ward out of position when here are other choices, when there is no guarantee of their ability to play there. No logic
Ward isn't out of position that's where he started.
Calderon is a better option than Chicken and Maxi.
Oh and it's not the most serious of teams, hence the 'what's the worst that can happen' comment.
HenryC
New member
actually that looks quite an interesting line up...!
Blue and White Tiger
Exiled to Exeter
- Jul 6, 2010
- 927
Kuszczak
Calderon Greer Upson Ward
Ince
JFC Crofts
Buckley Barnes Conway
Calderon Greer Upson Ward
Ince
JFC Crofts
Buckley Barnes Conway
Subs: Brezovan, El-Abd, Maksimenko, Andrews, March, Lita & Barker.
I like the team but why Ankergren may I ask?
Munchkin
Well-known member
----------------- Kuszczak ------------------
Bruno ----- Greer ----- Upson ------ Ward
Buckley ----Andrews-----Crofts--- Conway
------------ Lita ------- Barnes ------------
Bruno ----- Greer ----- Upson ------ Ward
Buckley ----Andrews-----Crofts--- Conway
------------ Lita ------- Barnes ------------
Time for a bit of passion put El Abd alongside Upson
Other requests ... leave Spanish at the training ground, give Lita a try (what have we got to lose?), crock Agustien if anywhere near recovering, tell Buckley he performs or back to Rochdale
Other requests ... leave Spanish at the training ground, give Lita a try (what have we got to lose?), crock Agustien if anywhere near recovering, tell Buckley he performs or back to Rochdale
LamieRobertson
Not awoke
Bit unfair to leave Dave over at lancing ...its quite exposed at the mo and what with the wind and the rain
Lancing? Maybe he prefers Osasuna .. who wouldn't?
GreersElbow
New member
May I ask why El-Abd? I think the experience and partnership Greer and Upson have built over the past year has been very strong. This is going to be a game where we want an ultra-tight defence and El-Abd last season was caught out a few times.
----------------Kuszczak------------------
---Calde-------El Abd-----Upson----Ward--
-----------------Ince---------------------
---------Andrews-------Crofts------------
---LuaLua---------------------Barnes-----
-----------------Lita----------------------
---Calde-------El Abd-----Upson----Ward--
-----------------Ince---------------------
---------Andrews-------Crofts------------
---LuaLua---------------------Barnes-----
-----------------Lita----------------------