Star Wars - brilliant or bollocks

[beorhthelm]

originals are the mutts.

episodes 1 and 2 try too hard to pander to a broad range of public while trying to stay faithful to all the nerd jedi worshippers. RotJ suffered a little from this too.

 

[Tooting Gull]

Star Wars and Empire Strikes Back are both great films, I could watch them over and over, and have done. I thought the rot was already setting in with the Return of the Jedi, bit too slapstick, and those since haven't really cut the mustard. I think to fully appreciate Star Wars mania first time round you had to be living it as a kid, it was massive. And the maths set was a de rigeur fashion accessory.

 

[Rambo]

New ones are not as good, but then I was a kid when the old ones came out.

 

[gonzo666]

f@:king love it

 

[Marc]

Star Wars rocks....Episode III will be amazing

 

[coach03]

very very overrated and Attack of the Clones rates as the worst film i have ever seen at the cinema

Didn't you see Gone With the Wind?

Only film I've seen at the cinema where I fell asleep !

(I should hasten to add it was a re-release...... I'm not THAT old)

 

[CAFC Matt]

The originals are amazing However new ones are still good but no where near as good as originals

 

[Brovion]

Like Danny Seagull I've managed to live my whole life without seeing any Star Wars film, consequently I'm not in a position to pass an opinion.

However in the spirit of all those people who vote in 'Ward or Zamora?' polls when they never saw Wardy play I have voted 'Bollocks'. The titles alone are excerable, heaven only knows what the actual films are like.

 

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

Even Ewan McGregor thinks the new ones are bollox - and he's IN them. Nice pay-day tho. Let's him do decent films in between.

 

[CAFC Matt]

Does he