OK, if being ill is no excuse to leave a train early, what happens if someone has a heart attack and dies before he reached his stop. Would his estate get hit with a fine because he left the train early? (judging by some of the jobsworths on here, the answer is yes).
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Railway silly season
- Thread starter £1.99
- Start date
Easy 10
Brain dead MUG SHEEP
No. I walked to Pease Pottage with my pants in a carrier bag, and hitched a ride back with a trucker called Simon.
If he arranged a pick-up at the airport, then me not accompanying him to it makes stuff-all difference does it.
your analogy is flwed as it misses half the problem, the cheaper fare. say the cab drivers get a subsidy to run fast services from Preston Park station to Gatwick (no one would run fast service from Brighton station...), they charge you £20 for this rather than the normal £40. on the way, you ask that you want to go up the A23 instead of the M23 and get out in Crawly town center. now would you expect the driver to charge you £20 or £40, considering they will lose their subsidy if found you didnt go on the subsidised route?
Where does it say the couple on the train diverted it to take a different route ?
All they did was hop off early at a station IT WAS STOPPING AT ANYWAY.
But they underpaid, which is why they got fined.
The problem is that breaking this one particular condition makes not a jot of difference to the train operators. Not one.
So much for customer service.
I really can't wait for the reaction on here next time one of your lot goes on strike over something utterly trivial. Expect this thread to be bounced to highlight your utter hypocrisy and total disregard for the customer when compared to your own self serving needs.
And lets face it, we won't have to wait long.
I must be clear. My ticket (which was £3.75) was for the 12:19 Brighton to London Victoria ONLY train. If I had used ANY other service or got off ANYWHERE else I would have expected a fine for breaking terms and conditions of my (DIRT CHEAP FOR A REASON) ticket.
The Large One
Who's Next?
Can I just say that standard single from Lewes to Brighton is £3.40. From Lewes to London Road (the station before Brighton - and the one I jump off at to go home), it's £3.50.
How long is it before I get my fine?
How long is it before I get my fine?
Ernest
Stupid IDIOT
I thought you meant the usual Saver return ticket, that's it that's the condition and I can't see why others can't see why they're wrong.
Ernest
Stupid IDIOT
The only fine you're get is for being an idiot as you know full well that ticket is an anytime single for which you can break your journey.
Maybe next time you board at London Road without a ticket you check the rules for penalty fares
The Large One
Who's Next?
You say that now, but look at the jobsworths you have calling themselves your colleagues.
NOT if the machine serving the tickets is WRONG.Maybe next time you board at London Road without a ticket you check the rules for penalty fares
Last edited:
Ding, ding, ding.
In all the pages of shite here's the key to it all. We're customers of the railway company - which other industry treats its customers in such a shoddy way by fining people.
Thankfully, unless I'm going to London, I avoid the trains at all costs. Just as long as I stick to the speed limit I don't get fined when driving my car and I will continue to do so instead of catching the train.
Easy 10
Brain dead MUG SHEEP
They didn't underpay. They paid the pre-agreed discounted price for a Southampton to London return journey, but decided on the return journey not to use the return ticket for the full duration to which they were entitled and had paid for.
Lets play beorthlems what-if game.
By getting off early, they freed up two seats. What if the train was packed ? What if those two free seats had meant that two additional passengers at Eastleigh could climb on board and take their place, paying full price ?
Hey, suddenly this couple have actually done the rail operating company a FAVOUR.
Southern Advance tickets : Southern
"No break of journey is permitted in either direction"
Not sure about south west trains but it says it in pretty easily readable font there.....
"No break of journey is permitted in either direction"
Not sure about south west trains but it says it in pretty easily readable font there.....
Kalimantan Gull
Well-known member
Easy is right that it is an absolutely pointless rule. One I can't understand. If they can afford to charge £6 return to Southampton, why not charge the same to Eastleigh? What is the benefit to the company to offer cheaper fares to a further destination?
Too many different tickets, different fares, different promos makes this situation stupid.
Of course the couple that got caught obviously looked at all this and tried to cheat the system. Good on them I say, more people making a fuss about this sort of thing MIGHT force a change.
Too many different tickets, different fares, different promos makes this situation stupid.
Of course the couple that got caught obviously looked at all this and tried to cheat the system. Good on them I say, more people making a fuss about this sort of thing MIGHT force a change.
Ernest
Stupid IDIOT
You say that now, but look at the jobsworths you have calling themselves your colleagues.
NOT if the machine serving the tickets is WRONG.
I am always WILLING to SERVE you
skipper734
Registered ruffian
Point of order. I don't think SW trains adhere to their own rules or the rules of The National Rail Conditions of Carriage.If you are travelling from a penalty fare station on a penalty fare train, and:
a)
You do not have a valid ticket and are approached by a revenue protection employee, who is an authorised penalty fare collector you may be liable to a penalty fare of £20 or twice the full single fare - whichever is the greater amount to the next station at which your train stops.
If you wish to continue your journey beyond the next station stop you may be required to buy a full single or return fare for the remainder of your journey.
b)
You do not have a valid train ticket and are approached by a guard, who is NOT an authorised penalty fare collector you may be liable to pay the full single or return fare for the journey you have made or wish to make and you will not be entitled to any discounts (for example, Railcards) or special terms, which would otherwise apply. This is in accordance with the National Rail Conditions on Carriage.
When the guard issues you a ticket a penalty fare, a 'warning' will also be issued, so that you are aware of the penalty fare scheme should you be approached by an authorised penalty fare collector on your next journey.
c)
You do not have a valid train ticket and are approached by a guard, who is NOT an authorised penalty fare collector, you may be liable to pay the full single or return fare for the journey you have made or wish to make, and you will not be entitled to any discounts (for example, Railcards) or special terms which would otherwise apply. This is in accordance with the National Rail Conditions on Carriage.
When the guard issues you a ticket a penalty fare, a 'warning' will also be issued, so that you are aware of the penalty fare scheme should you be approached by an authorised penalty fare collector on your next journey.
a)
You do not have a valid ticket and are approached by a revenue protection employee, who is an authorised penalty fare collector you may be liable to a penalty fare of £20 or twice the full single fare - whichever is the greater amount to the next station at which your train stops.
If you wish to continue your journey beyond the next station stop you may be required to buy a full single or return fare for the remainder of your journey.
b)
You do not have a valid train ticket and are approached by a guard, who is NOT an authorised penalty fare collector you may be liable to pay the full single or return fare for the journey you have made or wish to make and you will not be entitled to any discounts (for example, Railcards) or special terms, which would otherwise apply. This is in accordance with the National Rail Conditions on Carriage.
When the guard issues you a ticket a penalty fare, a 'warning' will also be issued, so that you are aware of the penalty fare scheme should you be approached by an authorised penalty fare collector on your next journey.
c)
You do not have a valid train ticket and are approached by a guard, who is NOT an authorised penalty fare collector, you may be liable to pay the full single or return fare for the journey you have made or wish to make, and you will not be entitled to any discounts (for example, Railcards) or special terms which would otherwise apply. This is in accordance with the National Rail Conditions on Carriage.
When the guard issues you a ticket a penalty fare, a 'warning' will also be issued, so that you are aware of the penalty fare scheme should you be approached by an authorised penalty fare collector on your next journey.
Personally I don't think it is clear and it's a pity they didn't choose to take it to court.
The site doesn't define what a "break" is. In my mind it means stopping your journey prematurely and then re-starting it, like having a break in a driving journey. So say I started at Victoria with a ticket for Victoria to Brighton and I decided to stop off in Haywards Heath to see friends before re-boarding to go to Brighton - that would be a break. Nowhere does it say that an early termination of the journey is not allowed.
seagullsovergrimsby
#cpfctinpotclub
clapham_gull
Legacy Fan
- Aug 20, 2003
- 25,509
Utter utter madness.
The sad thing of course is that rail companies are allowed to get away with such nonsense.
For those working on the railways it may seem normal, but you really need to step back for a moment and think.
It's like a Monty Python sketch.
Imagine going out for a meal that was say 20 quid for three courses. You ask for the bill but the waiter notices that you haven't eaten the pudding.
I'm sorry sir - I'm going to have to charge you £50.
Why ?
The meal was discounted sir....
I don't care what the terms and conditions say, they are simply nonsense.
The sad thing of course is that rail companies are allowed to get away with such nonsense.
For those working on the railways it may seem normal, but you really need to step back for a moment and think.
It's like a Monty Python sketch.
Imagine going out for a meal that was say 20 quid for three courses. You ask for the bill but the waiter notices that you haven't eaten the pudding.
I'm sorry sir - I'm going to have to charge you £50.
Why ?
The meal was discounted sir....
I don't care what the terms and conditions say, they are simply nonsense.
Last edited:
This thread is brilliant, I'm loving the fillet steak and taxi analogies.