Player Ratings

[Schrödinger's Toad]

Henderson 7

Reid 6
Butters 7
McShane 7
Hart 6

Frutos 6
Oatway 5
Hammond 6
Carole 6

Robinson 5
Knight 7

Subs: Kazim-Richards 7, Jarrett 6.

Hard to get too excited about that performance, rather half-hearted, and some dreadful tackling. Ho-hum, still a point.

 

[Dez]

can't argue with those ratings at all.

 

[Seagullible]

I'd give Henderson an 8 and oatway a 6. not sure whether Frutos should get lower

 

[parks]

Sort of agree:


Henderson 6

Reid 6
Butters 6
McShane 7
Hart 7

Frutos 5
Oatway 6
Hammond 6
Carole 5

Robinson 6
Knight 7

Subs: Kazim-Richards 7, Jarrett 6.

 

[London Irish]

Henderson 6 Some smart saves but also a few errors, so-so game

Reid 6 OK
Butters 7 Solid
McShane 8 Didn't put a foot wrong
Hart 6 Went absent at one quick free kick but not bad

Frutos 6 Workmanlike but no Carole
Oatway 6 Quiet game but created our best chance for Jarrett near the end before the goal
Hammond 5 Struggling in the centre, get him back out on the left, should have got sent off
Carole 8 Our one consistent bright spot - great cross for the goal

Robinson 6 Ran well, but no luck and needs to work on the first touch
Knight 6.5 Our best player in the first half but then disappeared

Subs:
Jarrett 7 Fine impact, had a great chance that just got away from him and then his hard work created the killer blow at the end
Kazim-Richards 7 Brilliant goal, a great natural talent but a lot of hard work ahead getting rid of those rough edges.

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

Henderson 7 - one great save, but too slow off his line for one chance that was wasted

Reid 5 - not really convincing
Butters 7 - solid, didn't do anything wrong
McShane 7 - same as Butters
Hart 7 - tried hard, never really influenced the game going forward however

Frutos 6 - was ok in the first half, but putting him on the right did not work
Oatway 5 - looked a bit lost tonight, off the pace
Hammond 6 - really needs to work on his first touch! lucky not to be sent off
Carole 6 - busy, but largely ineffective. Great cross for goal though!

Robinson 5 - lots of running but no service
Knight 5 - very quiet

Subs:
Kazim-Richards 7 - didn't do much except score, can't argue with that

Jarrett 6 - not enough time.


Also, did anyone else think their goal was offside?

 

[Kalimantan Gull]

Henderson 6 - couple of decent saves, slightly unlucky with the goal, but where the hell was he for the one-on-one near the end, plus that dodgy clearance in the first half.
Hart 8 - somehow he has become a natural right-back
McShane 7 - solid
Butters 7 - solid
Reid 7 - solid
Carole 6 - very disappointing
Hammond 7 - solid, and seemed to be everywhere
Oatway 7 - typical Charlie, a tiger in defence and hit and miss in possession, but some good work in the second half
Frutos 6 - tidy enough, but mind elsewhere?
Knight 7 - always involved, good touch but never in the places it mattered
Robinson 6 - good involvement when we didn't have the ball, but touch was woeful and made a bad choice to cut inside when through on goal

subs:
Jarrett 7 - great first touch to get one-on-one but poor second touch, involved in the goal
CKR 8 - wonderful header to score, did little wrong

 

[Kalimantan Gull]

Carole 8 Our one consistent bright spot - great cross for the goal

Really?

Still, I gave Oatway a higher mark than you!

 

[London Irish]

Really?

Still, I gave Oatway a higher mark than you!

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Henderson 7

Reid 6
Butters 7
McShane 7
Hart 6

Frutos 6
Oatway 5
Hammond 6
Carole 6

Robinson 5
Knight 7

Subs: Kazim-Richards 7, Jarrett 6.



mom lee peACOCK.

 

[Trigger]

Henderson 6 (some good saves but a couple of shocking errors)

Reid 6
Butters 7
McShane 7
Hart 7

Frutos 6
Oatway 5 (continually gave the ball away and crucially gave it away for their goal)
Hammond 6
Carole 7

Robinson 6
Knight 8

Subs: Kazim-Richards 7, Jarrett 7.

 

[GUNTER]

Can't be bothered to rate them, the whole team in the main played poorly and we were so so lucky to get a point.

 

[Barnet Seagull]

Here's mine.

Henderson 6

Reid 5
Butters 7
McShane 6
Hart 7

Frutos 5
Oatway 6
Hammond 5
Carole 6

Robinson 5
Knight 7

Subs: Kazim-Richards 7, Jarrett 6.