***PLAYER RATINGS*** vs Charlton

[Titanic]

I love how views change, I would be intrested to see how peoples view change depended on where they sit.

In the group of people who I know who get together after the game, WSU and

and what?? The suspense is killing me!

 

[tigertim68]

Stockdale - 5 - yet to make a save. Dynamite with his feet, but should have been sharper on the second goal. Wonder if Kuszcz would have saved the first.....
Bruno - 6 - ok
Bennett - 4 - Had an absolute stinker, culminating his part in their second with JFC
Greer - 6 - turned too easily on the second
Dunk - 8 - largely because of the goals he scored
Holla - 6 - ok
JFC - 5 - some good passes, some bad, but what was he doing on the second with Bennett? Stupid booking
Crofts - 5 -
Tex - 6 - some brilliant things, some very ordinary
Corluga - 6 - great first half, tired second
CMS - 5 - poor performance, against two big defenders, made good runs, but poor control quite often, great swivel and shot in 2nd half.

Gardner - 6 - ok
KLL - 6 - great cross for the second
Baldock - 6 - barely in the game, but tried


Hyypia/Jones - really poor that they didn't demand that Holla took the free kick near the end.

Ref - just a t**t. Pointed to his watch re time-wasting in the 25th minute, and preceded to do nothing.....

agree with all the above

 

[father_and_son]

I find him impossible to rate. Possibly a 5 or a 6 would be fairer but I can honestly say that I never remember anything the guy does. It's not a criticism, I just cannot for the life of me point to any positive or negative contribution he made today (or on any other day).

I would sum up his game as... Tries hard but ineffective. Saw a fair bit of his game from the SWC and he has a tenacity that many of our players lack but there was no stroke of genius that would have made his game memorable.

 

[Acker79]

Average Ratings

Highest Rated:
Dunk 8.59 (96mins, 39 votes)

The Rest:
Teixeira 7.50 (96mins, 38 votes)
Holla 7.22 (96mins, 39 votes)
Colunga 6.50 (96mins, 39 votes)
Greer 6.46 (96mins, 39 votes)
*LuaLua 6.37 (33mins, 34 votes)
*Gardner 6.17 (49mins, 33 votes)
Bruno 6.14 (96mins, 39 votes)
Bennett 6.05 (96mins, 39 votes)
*Mackail-Smith 5.68 (63mins, 39 votes)
*Forster-Caskey 5.62 (79mins, 39 votes)
*Baldock 5.50 (17mins, 10 votes)
*Crofts 5.23 (47mins, 39 votes)
Stockdale 5.18 (96mins, 39 votes)


Squad average: 6.30