Player ratings - QPR (A)

[lethaldrizzle]

I would be interested to know a qpr fans point of view on their players ratings

I sat in the QPR end. Does that count?

Andrews and Upson were excellent.
JFC, Conway and Barnes lots of effort but little real effect on the game.
The rest somewhere in between.

 

[nwgull]

Sorry but Conway was awful. Lua Lua must be tempted to put in a transfer request after being left out for him tonight. How Garcia left him on for 90 minutes is beyond me.

I think KLL was rested due to fitness/injury issues after playing 90 mins 3 days earlier. I would expect him to start on Saturday given his performances against Reading and Millwall.

 

[Sam-]

Sorry but Conway was awful. Lua Lua must be tempted to put in a transfer request after being left out for him tonight. How Garcia left him on for 90 minutes is beyond me.

QPR player commentary were very complimentary about him

 

[BRIGHT ON Q]

Thought it was a really good team performance.
Andrews is a fantastic player,superb in the middle of the park.
Forster caskey needs to learn how to beat the first man with his set pieces and crosses.
I actually thought Spanish Dave was a bit better last night but still off the pace.
Frustrating KLL never got a run in the 2nd half although Conway looked ok
Barnes did very well up front on his own I thought.
Overall very pleasing to watch

 

[One Teddy Maybank]

Kuszczak 8
Calderon 7.5
Ward 7.5
Greer 8
Upson 8
Andrews 8
Crofts 7
JFC 6 - lacks presence, delivery ver poor. Lots to learn
Lopez - 5 very poor.....
Conway - 6 - lacking confidence, never really drove on when he had the ball
Barnes - 8

Buckley 6 some nice touches
Bruno 5 reckless, when he needed to be calm
Ince n/a came on around 85 mins

 

[Czechmate]

My interpretation of what 5Live would have given :

Kuszczak 4 made one average save
Calderon 4 should of been sent off
Ward 4 defensive errors
Greer 5 did ok made errors
Upson 3 played awful
Andrews 6 did ok
Crofts 5 did ok
JFC 4 did ok
Lopez 3 bad distribution
Conway 3 not in the game
Barnes 4 no chance against QPR defence

Bruno 2 should of been sent off
Buckley 0 didn't know he came on
Ince spent 5 minutes telling who he is related to so could not give mark

We could not give more points as half the time Brighton had the ball we were talking b__locks about nothing to do with the game.

That will teach me I should of gone to the game !

 

[Double Hard Bastard]

My interpretation of what 5Live would have given :

Kuszczak 4 made one average save
Calderon 4 should of been sent off
Ward 4 defensive errors
Greer 5 did ok made errors
Upson 3 played awful
Andrews 6 did ok
Crofts 5 did ok
JFC 4 did ok
Lopez 3 bad distribution
Conway 3 not in the game
Barnes 4 no chance against QPR defence

Bruno 2 should of been sent off
Buckley 0 didn't know he came on
Ince spent 5 minutes telling who he is related to so could not give mark

We could not give more points as half the time Brighton had the ball we were talking b__locks about nothing to do with the game.

That will teach me I should of gone to the game !

Both of them were w@nkers!

 

[crodonilson]

:

Kuszczak 7 - Rock solid
Calderon 7 - Back near his best, attacking occasionally let him down
Ward 7 - Ever dependable and always looking to take the attack to the opposition
Greer 7 - Never looked in too much danger, distribution was occasionally poor
Upson 8 - A rock at the heart of our defence
Andrews 9 - Quality, always wanting the ball and redstributing it wisely
Crofts 7 - Tidy performance
JFC 7 - Not involved as much as I'd like but dangerous with the ball
Lopez 6 - Much more to come, not on the ball enough to be influential on the game
Conway 7 - Dangerous attacking outlet, some moments of real quality
Barnes 8 - Battled hard against a rock solid defence

 

[Acker79]

Averages

Starting 11 (9 votes)
Andrews 8.89
Upson 8.39
Barnes 7.72
Kuszczak 7.61
Greer 7.22
Crofts 7.06
Ward 6.94 (82mins)
Calderon 6.83
Forster-Caskey 6.67 (87mins)
Conway 6.44
David Lopez 5.94 (70mins)


Subs (5 votes)
Buckley 6.40 (26mins)
Ince 6.00 (9mins - 1 vote)
Bruno 5.60 (14mins)


Team average - 6.98

 

[SussexHoop]

I would be interested to know a qpr fans point of view on their players ratings

Green - 6- solid enough
Simpson - 4 - incapable of going past players, hasn't clicked with Phillips
Onouha - 6 - fine till he went off
Dunne - 8 - we haven't conceded in the League since his 1st game for us
Hill - 8 - another good performance
Phillips - 6 - worked hard but he needs to sort things out with Simpson
O'Neill - 6 - worked hard but is capable of better
Barton -8 - for me once again this season one of our best players, worked tirelessly, created a lot
Wright-Phillips - 6 - worked hard, tracked back,needs to sort out delivering a final ball.
Henry - 5 - disappointing, sometimes forgot he was on the pitch
Austin - 4 - he scored over 20 goals in a season? Really? And Zamora's the panto villain!

Assou-Ekoto - 6 - we improved when he came on but he got done too easily on a couple of occasions
Jenas - 5 - knew when he came on Redknapp was settling for a draw
Traore - 6 - did ok when he came on

 

[One Teddy Maybank]

Green - 6- solid enough
Simpson - 4 - incapable of going past players, hasn't clicked with Phillips
Onouha - 6 - fine till he went off
Dunne - 8 - we haven't conceded in the League since his 1st game for us
Hill - 8 - another good performance
Phillips - 6 - worked hard but he needs to sort things out with Simpson
O'Neill - 6 - worked hard but is capable of better
Barton -8 - for me once again this season one of our best players, worked tirelessly, created a lot
Wright-Phillips - 6 - worked hard, tracked back,needs to sort out delivering a final ball.
Henry - 5 - disappointing, sometimes forgot he was on the pitch
Austin - 4 - he scored over 20 goals in a season? Really? And Zamora's the panto villain!

Assou-Ekoto - 6 - we improved when he came on but he got done too easily on a couple of occasions
Jenas - 5 - knew when he came on Redknapp was settling for a draw
Traore - 6 - did ok when he came on

Really. He grizzled and whined alot, and his dead ball delivery was good, but other than that he created very little. Having been booked, he was lucky to stay on after the continued dissent.

 

[Blue Valkyrie]

Kuszczak - 8
Calderon - 7
Ward - 7
Upson - 8
Greer - 8
Andrews - 9
JFC - 7
Crofts - 8
Conway - 7
Lopez - 7
Barnes - 8