Not Nutley but only a couple of miles up the road The Green Man in Horsted Keynes.
It's a Green King pub but don't let that put you off as the grub is cracking and there is normally one or two nice bits of fluff working behind the ramp.
would love to hear from you it was my Nan and Grandad who owned the Shelley Arms and am currently trying to do some family research as they are no longer with us