[Music] Most over-rated albums

[Guinness Boy]

Anything by Queen.

 

[Stato]

Don't start me.

Ok....

Hotel California
All Hawkwind except that single

Have to agree with Hotel California. The Eagles: Laurel Canyon's Coldplay.

Although, I've no particular opinion of Hawkwind, don't you have to be rated to be overrated?

 

[The Antikythera Mechanism]

All albums by;
The Smiths
Beautiful South
Both Elvis’s - Presley & Costello
The list goes on, but all the above immediately switched off if heard on the radio.

 

[Harry Wilson's tackle]

Have to agree with Hotel California. The Eagles: Laurel Canyon's Coldplay.

Although, I've no particular opinion of Hawkwind, don't you have to be rated to be overrated?

One word. Stacia.

 

[Herr Tubthumper]

Stone Roses. Great couple of albums but the first is not the ground shaking long player most seem to think.

 

[Pevenseagull]

Most of "Sgt. Pepper's " is doggerel

 

[Pevenseagull]

Stone Roses. Great couple of albums but the first is not the ground shaking long player most seem to think.

That first album is crap.

Give it another listen.

It's bollocks.

 

[shingle]

another vote for dark side of the moon

 

[Guinness Boy]

Stone Roses. Great couple of albums but the first is not the ground shaking long player most seem to think.

Mate!

The first album is incredible. The second is absolute bollocks. It’s rare I agree with critics and public opinion, but the common perception of the Roses is bang on.

In my humble opinion.

 

[Weststander]

Following sweeping posts by others (not album specific). Any albums by:

M People
Lighthouse Family
Duran Duran
Oasis
Starship
Kaiser Chiefs
Simply Red
Dave Clark Five
Justin Bieber
Ed Sheeran
Olly Murs
James Blunt

 

[Guinness Boy]

That first album is crap.

Give it another listen.

It's bollocks.

Boooooo

 

[Pevenseagull]

'Low' Bowie


Patchy


Couple of cracking songs

Couple of decent ones

Lots of nonsense

 

[Pevenseagull]

Boooooo

Boo yourself


It's weak.

 

[BN9 BHA]

All albums by;
The Smiths
Beautiful South
Both Elvis’s - Presley & Costello
The list goes on, but all the above immediately switched off if heard on the radio.

FFS this isn’t a thread about bands/ singers you don’t like

 

[Stato]

One word. Stacia.

So you liked a couple of things about them then.

 

[BN9 BHA]

'Low' Bowie


Patchy


Couple of cracking songs

Couple of decent ones

Lots of nonsense

Agree, I like the album cover though

 

[Sid and the Sharknados]

Following sweeping posts by others (not album specific). Any albums by:

M People
Lighthouse Family
Duran Duran
Oasis
Starship
Kaiser Chiefs
Simply Red
Dave Clark Five
Justin Bieber
Ed Sheeran
Olly Murs
James Blunt

Has anybody particularly rated anything Kaiser Chiefs have done?

One of my main memories of Tideway is some twat going around singing "Ruby Ruby Ruby" all the time (realistically this probably lasted about a month).

As it happens, I'm pretty sure his wife (same year at Tideway) has a season ticket in the North Stand, which completely passed me by at the time.

 

[Herr Tubthumper]

Mate!

The first album is incredible. The second is absolute bollocks. It’s rare I agree with critics and public opinion, but the common perception of the Roses is bang on.

In my humble opinion.

I love the first album, and the second has its moments, I just don’t think it’s as seminal as others feel.

You love Sabres of Paradise, I can’t argue with you

 

[Stato]

'Low' Bowie


Patchy


Couple of cracking songs

Couple of decent ones

Lots of nonsense

Not a huge Bowie fan. Never heard it. However I love that after it was released, Nick released this:

 

[BN9 BHA]

Has anybody particularly rated anything Kaiser Chiefs have done?

One of my main memories of Tideway is some twat going around singing "Ruby Ruby Ruby" all the time (realistically this probably lasted about a month).

As it happens, I'm pretty sure his wife (same year at Tideway) has a season ticket in the North Stand, which completely passed me by at the time.

This version is far better