Have we ever won a cup replay against Premiership/Old League 1 side?

[OzMike]

Just out of interest like.

 

[Gwylan]

Newcastle in our cup run of '83. Pretty sure they were a Div 1 side then

 

[Return of the Rev]

Newcastle in our cup run of '83. Pretty sure they were a Div 1 side then

nope! we were the giants that night

Ipswich in the league cup

 

[Joe Gatting's Dad]

All the teams we played in the 1983 season were in the same first division as us, apart from Sheffield Wednesday in the semi-final who were up the top of the old second division. (Liverpool, Manchester City and Norwich City - plus Manure in the final).

 

[Goldstone Rapper]

Newcastle were in the Second Division in 1982/83. We played them in Kevin Keegan's farewell league match the following season.

 

[Gwylan]

All the teams we played in the 1983 season were in the same first division as us, apart from Sheffield Wednesday in the semi-final who were up the top of the old second division. (Liverpool, Manchester City and Norwich City - plus Manure in the final).

No, as ROTR and GR have pointed out, Newcastle were in the 2nd Division - they got promoted the following season (just looked it up)

 

[OzMike]

To be more specific, I meant any teams a league or two above us.
Sorry if title is misleading.

 

[Return of the Rev]

To be more specific, I meant any teams a league or two above us.
Sorry if title is misleading.

1976
ipswich div 1 brighton div 3
drew 0-0 away
won 2-1 at home

 

[LamieRobertson]

not that often is the answer

 

[drew]

1976
ipswich div 1 brighton div 3
drew 0-0 away
won 2-1 at home

Fred Binney and Graham Cross if I'm not mistaken (without checking on Google).

 

[Gregory2Smith1]

1976
ipswich div 1 brighton div 3
drew 0-0 away
won 2-1 at home

had to go in the south that night with the old man

my two older brothers were allowed to go in the north

what a sight the north stand was too

that was a very good Ipswich side too,Beattie,Mills,Cooper in goal,Gates,was Mariner and Wark playing,I can't remember,Trevor Whymark

other than the win at Anfield in the cup,that must go down as one of,if not the best result we've ever had,all things considered

 

[maltaseagull]

Newcastle in our cup run of '83. Pretty sure they were a Div 1 side then

But so were we then

 

[Return of the Rev]

had to go in the south that night with the old man

my two older brothers were allowed to go in the north

What a sight the north stand was too

that was a very good ipswich side too,beattie,mills,cooper in goal,gates,was mariner and wark playing,i can't remember,trevor whymark

other than the win at anfield in the cup,that must go down as one of,if not the best result we've ever had,all things considered

26,748 and they all attended!

Wba away was a good result too!

 

[Gwylan]

As ROTR said, Ipswich in the League Cup was the last time we beat a 1st tier team after a replay.
The last time we did it in the FA Cup was in January 1930 when we beat Grimsby Town after a replay

 

[Kalimantan Gull]

That is a long time. Came damn close against Liverpool in 1991 though