[Albion] Green Party attempt to ban cars in Central Brighton

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

You might well ask

#pissoftimmy

 

[Raleigh Chopper]

Thanks to Hitler, we have already got one.
But I hadn't really thought about it much until this thread appeared.

 

[Publius Ovidius]

Every single forward-thinking car-free shopping zone in the world will have come up with a perfectly adequate workaround for that old chestnut. Why would Brighton be any different?

Because this is Brighton!

 

[Eeyore]

You might well ask

I didn't ask myself. Although I'm guessing the alternative was even less palatable ? *Meow*

 

[jimhigham]

I love Brighton but don't live there. On the one occasion I come down to stay each year, Marathon Weekend, I come down in the car. The rhino is tough to bring down on the train. But I honestly wouldn't mind at all if this measure came in. Forward thinking and not before time so long as the council subsidised public transport to facilitate getting around.

 

[giveusfalmerplease]

We use the bus to get into town because driving in and around Brighton is costly and time consuming. Irony is that the buses spew out more crap than the cars. Ban cars and increase the number of buses and we’ll all choke to death. Bring on the monorail.

hmm when was the last time you went on a bus - at least 25% of them are all electric now. im sure the bus co would bend over backwards to buy more knowing their passenger numbers could double or treble.

 

[golddene]

I love Brighton but don't live there. On the one occasion I come down to stay each year, Marathon Weekend, I come down in the car. The rhino is tough to bring down on the train. But I honestly wouldn't mind at all if this measure came in. Forward thinking and not before time so long as the council subsidised public transport to facilitate getting around.

aren't the bus's subsidised by the parking charges/fines etc already ?

 

[Guinness Boy]

You might well ask

No, I think pretty much everyone on NSC understands why the Greens were a more appealing proposition than one of their opponents in leafy, Tory, Withdean

 

[peterward]

For social media/dinner party virtue signalling reasons or self-delusion that they are 'saving the planet'?

completely right. Making Brighton centre car free as some sort of vitual signalling for global climate problems is about as realistic as thinking you can help solve the Aussie fires by taking a piss in the bush.

What is the problem? is it cars? or is certain categories of emissions?

What is greener allowing electric cars into Brighton and banning diesel busses? or vice versa.... its bollocks.

Even modern blue motion diesel cars which convert the Nitrous Oxide are far greener than many of the shitty older busses in the city centre.

Lets see the actual science versus the politics that also hinders old people, the disabled, families with young kids, prams and all the shit you need to carry as parents.

 

[Guinness Boy]

No. Unfortunately despite growing up in Brighton I could not afford to live there. Thanks to all these ********s and lovies that moved down from London and seeing all the house prices shoot up.

It is better to have a house in Worthing than a flat in Brighton.

Funny thing though, Worthing is actually a nicer place to live than Brighton. Brighton went down hill in early 2000s.

So you're railing against a policy that doesn't affect you made by people you couldn't elect as a result of envy. At least we know where we all stand.

 

[giveusfalmerplease]

this will kill shops like Argos, Currys/PC World and all retailers where bulk items need to be collected and cant be carried on public transport. Cant see too many people paying to travel to the town centre to buy something and then having to pay delivery charges to have it delivered back home.

 

[Guinness Boy]

Just think. In three years time we could have a real reduction in town centre pollution and accidents AND also no fat bloke in a Union Jack waistcoat hammering out a poorly written twitter feed about how great Boris is. Local politics is wonderful.

 

[Deleted member 2719]

I assume all the people supporting this banning of cars in Brighton will also stop flying

 

[jessiejames]

Only allow deliveries between 10pm and 6am.

Impossible, Transport Working time directive, office blocks that work 9am to 5 pm.

 

[Blue shirt and passport]

What about people with disabilities?

 

[beorhthelm]

Bring back trolley buses.

i used to flirt with these or trams, came to conclusion there is no advantage over electric buses, which are more flexible too.

 

[Coldeanseagull]

I need to see the proposed area to be pedestrianised, before I make an informed comment.......but regardless, it still won't stop Lewes Road being a complete nightmare

 

[The Clamp]

Impossible, Transport Working time directive, office blocks that work 9am to 5 pm.

Many towns and cities across the world use this system. So, no. It’s not impossible.

 

[worthingseagull123]

​

I assume all the people supporting this banning of cars in Brighton will also stop flying

Or having kids

Some stupid woman in the Argus yesterday going on an Extinction protest said she was the mother of 5.

What a t**t.

 

[dejavuatbtn]

hmm when was the last time you went on a bus - at least 25% of them are all electric now. im sure the bus co would bend over backwards to buy more knowing their passenger numbers could double or treble.

Yesterday. It was diesel. Mostly filled with wrinklies like me whips don’t have to pay. I do think the rules on free bus passes needs looking at. Whilst those who are only on a basic pension must qualify, there are others who could afford to pay, including me.