I know it means including another brazilain but I would include Garrincha alongside Pele, Becken Garrincha was outstandingbauer, Moore, Maradona and Zidane - all players who excelled in at least 2 world cups- unlike Cruyff who starred in 1974 but refused to play in 1978. After Pele was injured in 1962 Garrincha was outstanding. I believe Brazil never lost when Pele and Garrincha played together.
Maradonna in '86 was sublime and incomparable
Pele got the deserved plaudits but in1970,
Jairzinho was magnificent
Bobby Moore-brilliant in 1966 and 1970
Cafu-four consecutive world cups, including winners medals in 1994 and 2002