Craig Noone

[Thunder Bolt]

Under-used by Poyet and run down by the Poyet fans, now in form in the Premier-League. I would have rather kept Noone on the left instead of having to play Barnes there for numerous games.

Time will tell if we sold him at the right price. Personally my pound is on 'we let him go too cheaply'.

I would rather remember Noone for his wonderful assist that won our first Amex game against Doncaster, than your negative noonsense.

What absolute nonsense. We replaced Noone with Orlandi.

 

[Se20]

Apparently Tan joined in with the booing.

An absolute joke of a man, it must be so much fun being a Cardiff fan presently.

 

[portslade seagull]

Noone was class in the 1st half did fade in the 2nd though

 

[Couldn't Be Hyypia]

Did we change the rules to allow these tedious palace trolls to post on any thread?

 

[Stat Brother]

What absolute nonsense. We replaced Noone with Orlandi.

Arse I forgot that.

Thumbs up.

 

[Soulman]

An absolute joke of a man, it must be so much fun being a Cardiff fan presently.

Don't get comfy, your on a non Palace thread.

 

[portslade seagull]

Apparently Tan joined in with the booing.

What an absolute joke that man is

 

[Gullflyinghigh]

Time will tell if we sold him at the right price. Personally my pound is on 'we let him go too cheaply'.

Of course, each to their own, but surely the only fair way to judge a transfer fee is on the quality/potential of the player at the time they were sold?

I used to love watching Nooney tear up and down the wing, his effort or ability on the ball were never in question. Unfortunately, a lot of those moments ended with a wayward cross or an 'interesting' shot...PL starter he was not.

Now he seems to have built the final ball into his game the transfer fee might start to look small but back then Cardiff took a gamble as there was no guarantee he'd kick on...hell, if there was he'd have left Albion for a PL club, not a Championship one.

 

[DumLum]

What absolute nonsense. We replaced Noone with Orlandi.

So Barnes never played on the left for us under Poyet?

 

[Footsoldier]

Nooney subbed on 71 minutes but had a more than decent game ( all the way through )

And they then conceded 2 goals and ended up drawing

 

[LamieRobertson]

Under-used by Poyet and run down by the Poyet fans, now in form in the Premier-League. I would have rather kept Noone on the left instead of having to play Barnes there for numerous games.

Time will tell if we sold him at the right price. Personally my pound is on 'we let him go too cheaply'.

I would rather remember Noone for his wonderful assist that won our first Amex game against Doncaster, than your negative noonsense.

lost me there..not sure how u link poyet supporters to those not liking Noone....plus on form? is this the second or third game he's started...one reasonable game? I liked Noone, but as regards to him being a decent premier league player, i think the verdict is wait until he's started 20 odd games

 

[Stat Brother]

lost me there..not sure how u link poyet supporters to those not liking Noone....plus on form? is this the second or third game he's started...one reasonable game? I liked Noone, but as regards to him being a decent premier league player, i think the verdict is wait until he's started 20 odd games

Thumbs up.

 

[DumLum]

lost me there..not sure how u link poyet supporters to those not liking Noone....plus on form? is this the second or third game he's started...one reasonable game? I liked Noone, but as regards to him being a decent premier league player, i think the verdict is wait until he's started 20 odd games

When Poyet sold Noone many suppoters agreed it was the right thing to do as they had a blind faith in Poyet. They went by the moto 'In Gus We Trust'. They all got aboard a bus that ended up leaving the road and ending up in a Cesspit.

I said he was 'now in form in the Premier-League' although that was only counting the last four games I agree with you that the verdict on him being a decent premier league player can not be made for a good while yet.

I guess the point I have been trying to make is, I wish he was still in our Squad!

 

[Thunder Bolt]

So Barnes never played on the left for us under Poyet?

What has that got to do with anything? Versatile players and covering for injuries. Barnes was more defensive than Noone or Orlandi.

 

[Thunder Bolt]

He collapsed. They don't know the diagnosis yet, but he was reported to be conscious.

An update, he has been released from hospital as it seems he has a virus.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/25538981

 

[Stat Brother]

I guess the point I have been trying to make is, I wish he was still in our Squad!

For much of the last 18 months, so have most Cardiff fans.

 

[Justice]

Stuff like this is down to Burke. Besides, I think we got a good price for Noone considering he was 3rd choice the time.

I find it hard to believe one man a lone makes that kind of decision, I would of thought any bids for any of our top players would be put to the board for discussion.