From the hour I saw last night I believe Cook-Carberry was more of a "partnership" than what I recall of Cook-Compton.
I always felt Compton chose to battle his demons alone, whereas Cook and Carberry were doing plenty of talking, lots of "clenched-fist knocking" between overs last night...
I watched the first hour or so when the ball was doing a bit. Carberry was compact, watchful, he took a while to get going. My concern would be that better bowlers would tie him down and he'd eventually play a loose shot and get out. Although not in the class of Trott or Bell he might do a...