Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Search results

  1. Mellotron

    [Music] Joy Division

    Fun story - was responding to some thread on Twitter a few months back about great/influential bassists, my response was along the lines of; “Carlos D of Interpol - took the melodic template laid down by Peter Hook and developed/expanded on it massively.” Who was the first person to like and...
  2. Mellotron

    [Football] FIFA World Club Cup Nonsense

    Another one here asking why it is Chelsea and City have qualified, other than possibly being the two most egregious examples of dirty money in English football.
  3. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup 2025 (GUBC25) - Official Group Draw

    f*** me, the UK has produced a LOT of good music. Perhaps we’ll go crazy and go to 48 or 64 next time.
  4. Mellotron

    [Albion] Which ex manager do you have the least respect for?

    I don’t really bear any of them any ill will. As said above, they all improved us, I’m glad all of them were our managers at the time.
  5. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup 2025 (GUBC25) - Official Group Draw

    I think if you were aiming for “biggest”, you’d bring in Led Zeppelin, Oasis, The Police, Coldplay, for the likes of Talk Talk, XTC, Hawkwind. The Who also of course, although I’ve always personally found them monstrously overrated.
  6. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup 2025 (GUBC25) - Official Group Draw

    Always going to be the way. The other options I see are all not ideal - a 64 team tourney is just too long and unwieldy, another option is bands needing to be THIRDED but again that doesn’t guarantee certain bands getting in. Just like real life footy tournaments, always a chance some big...
  7. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup 2025 (GUBC25) - Official Group Draw

    To confirm, the nominations were provided by the good people of NSC - so it’s who in the NSC view is the greatest.
  8. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup 2025 (GUBC25) - Official Group Draw

    Those are the venues for each group. Notable/famous venues across the UK.
  9. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup 2025 (GUBC25) - Official Group Draw

    ??? Where do you think the bias is? The bands I really like are generally in hard groups. I definitely didn’t manufacture the groups.
  10. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup 2025 (GUBC25) - Official Group Draw

    I had considered taking them out, as they are surely favourites. The nominations thread made me wonder though. We’ll see. If they walk it, they’ll be taken out next time. If there is a next time.
  11. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup (GUBC) 2025 - Nominations CLOSED

    That’ll be REM from Athens, Georgia?
  12. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup 2025 (GUBC25) - Official Group Draw

    Here we go. Completely unseeded, as this is first of these competitions. Used a Random Group Generator online, no bias. Requests for comment from the Oasis camp on their absence led to a two fingered salute from Liam to reporters, and Noel stated to XFM “It’s all a load of pretentious, let’s...
  13. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup (GUBC) 2025 - Nominations CLOSED

    The 8 venues have been decided for the tournament; Group A - The O2, London - rubbish venue but they needed something large Group B - King Tut's Wah Wah Hut, Glasgow Group C - Shepherd's Bush Empire, London Group D - Rock City, Nottingham Group E - The Roundhouse, London Group F - Concorde2...
  14. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup (GUBC) 2025 - Nominations CLOSED

    Can a mod please rename the thread to confirm NOMINATIONS CLOSED? Many thanks. (Won't stop people anyway, based on previous experience...)
  15. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup (GUBC) 2025 - Nominations CLOSED

    Ha, egg is on my face. Smiths are in. But no Zep or Oasis.
  16. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup (GUBC) 2025 - Nominations CLOSED

    Blimey, no Led Zeppelin, no Oasis, no The Smiths, no The Police. I was worried 32 would be too many. Certainly not. As this is the first ever, the groups will be UNSEEDED. Group draw will arrive soon.
  17. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup (GUBC) 2025 - Nominations CLOSED

    FINISHED GENESIS MAKE THE FINAL SPOT. Sorry I missed the above.
  18. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup (GUBC) 2025 - Nominations CLOSED

    Rolling Stones and XTC in - Jam were already in. ONE SPACE LEFT. The biggest UK band of the 90s in BIG danger here, and one of the biggest of the 70s, if not the biggest.
  19. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup (GUBC) 2025 - Nominations CLOSED

    UPDATE QUALIFIED: - The Cure Radiohead Depeche Mode The Smiths New Order The Jam Manic Street Preachers Arctic Monkeys The Kinks Queen The Beautiful South Joy Division The Human League Squeeze The Charlatans Pink Floyd Pulp Deep Purple Pet Shop Boys The Clash Hawkwind The Stone Roses The...
  20. Mellotron

    [Music] NSC Greatest UK Band Cup (GUBC) 2025 - Nominations CLOSED

    Surprising lack of certain HUGE bands so far...

Top
Link Here