Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Politics] Brexit

If there was a second Brexit referendum how would you vote?


  • Total voters
    1,081






heathgate

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Apr 13, 2015
3,480
You don't need a political union to trade with another country.
You don't need a political union to co-operate with another country.
You don't need a political union to be friends with another country.

Sent from my SM-G920F using Tapatalk
 


Two Professors

Two Mad Professors
Jul 13, 2009
7,617
Multicultural Brum
I was struck by something Farage said yesterday (much as I loathe the guy).... he said he wanted to leave the EU so ordinary people could buy a home, get a hospital bed, and a place for their kids in their local school. The good news for Nigel is that he can have all that without going to the bother of leaving the EU and risking the economic nightmare that could ensue. We just need sensible policies to stimulate house-building, properly fund the NHS, and re-focus resources on primary education.

However, instead of trying to resolve the problems ourselves we spend years blaming immigrants (who contribute much more per head to the economy than the avge Brit). Even this morning the Leave campaign is relentlessly banging the immigration drum. Very depressing...

Another throwaway 'fact' that has absolutely no proof and no truth.Immigrants contribute much more per head ........:lolol::lolol::lolol::lolol::lolol:
 




JC Footy Genius

Bringer of TRUTH
Jun 9, 2015
10,568
I was struck by something Farage said yesterday (much as I loathe the guy).... he said he wanted to leave the EU so ordinary people could buy a home, get a hospital bed, and a place for their kids in their local school. The good news for Nigel is that he can have all that without going to the bother of leaving the EU and risking the economic nightmare that could ensue. We just need sensible policies to stimulate house-building, properly fund the NHS, and re-focus resources on primary education.

However, instead of trying to resolve the problems ourselves we spend years blaming immigrants (who contribute much more per head to the economy than the avge Brit). Even this morning the Leave campaign is relentlessly banging the immigration drum. Very depressing...

There are a couple of minor flaws in that argument. Not sure if you have noticed but we are not exactly flush with cash (£1.6 trillion in debt) and secondly when taking into consideration that the millions of migrants also use services increasing the strain on already overstretched services ... studies show there is no real net benefit from immigration.

If only we had some way of limiting (not stopping) immigration so we can at least try to address these pressing issues ... impossible to do while we are in the EU as confirmed by Corbyn the other day and by Cameron's friend who informs us the PM knew his immigration target was unachievable years ago.
 






Notters

Well-known member
Oct 20, 2003
24,869
Guiseley
There are a couple of minor flaws in that argument. Not sure if you have noticed but we are not exactly flush with cash (£1.6 trillion in debt) and secondly when taking into consideration that the millions of migrants also use services increasing the strain on already overstretched services ... studies show there is no real net benefit from immigration.

If only we had some way of limiting (not stopping) immigration so we can at least try to address these pressing issues ... impossible to do while we are in the EU as confirmed by Corbyn the other day and by Cameron's friend who informs us the PM knew his immigration target was unachievable years ago.

Out of interest, who would you stop coming here out of the 50,000 EU migrants that work in the NHS? Just the porters/cleaners, just the doctors/nurses or both?
 


Buzzer

Languidly Clinical
Oct 1, 2006
26,121
...but...but...but...we should listen to the economic experts and what they think is the mantra of the REMAIN campaign

CldWIdcUgAAkI2X.jpg



(letter in The Times today)
 






Staying in the EU seems to be wonderful for the well heeled of society and the young single university educated electorate. I don't blame them at all. We are sold the line that we can travel freely and work in 27 other countries, marvellous times for all and a great experience. How is the EU freedom of movement good for the normal families of Great Britain who's are on low wages and work in supermarkets, DIY stores, Clothes shops. I can't see them jumping for joy at the chance to uproot their family to work on the checkout at the Austrian version of Tescos. The federal European Utopia is only beneficial to the the bean counters and the people who regulate the bean counters it is not beneficial to the majority of the UK.
For that reason, I am out.

Sent from my E6653 using Tapatalk
 


5ways

Well-known member
Sep 18, 2012
2,217
Staying in the EU seems to be wonderful for the well heeled of society and the young single university educated electorate. I don't blame them at all. We are sold the line that we can travel freely and work in 27 other countries, marvellous times for all and a great experience. How is the EU freedom of movement good for the normal families of Great Britain who's are on low wages and work in supermarkets, DIY stores, Clothes shops. I can't see them jumping for joy at the chance to uproot their family to work on the checkout at the Austrian version of Tescos. The federal European Utopia is only beneficial to the the bean counters and the people who regulate the bean counters it is not beneficial to the majority of the UK.
For that reason, I am out.

Sent from my E6653 using Tapatalk

That really chimes with what people were saying yesterday on newsnight. The reporter asked some people why are you voting out? She said well with the immigrants and jobs...and sort of trailed off. Then the reporter said well Mark Carney says it is bad for the economy. She responds to the effect that she and Mark Carney live in different worlds; "has he gone round Sainsbury's on a budget?". The next lady cited cancelled operations as a reasoning for leaving. Asked why the young voted in they said "this is what they know, we're older, we remember something better."

What becomes apparent is that anyone with a gripe, potholes, NHS times, being elderly and remembering that they were once young, are all valid reason to give the status-quo a kicking. In no way does leaving the EU solve any of these issues, and actually exacerbates all of them. But they are not happy and see a simple way to air their grievances with the state of the world.

I hope enough people are rational enough to look at what the EU does and does not do. Because a strong UK is a UK in the EU. A strong UK can better fund the NHS, as the NHS chief exec has said, a strong UK in the EU can pay for European care workers to improve Brits standard of living.
 




5ways

Well-known member
Sep 18, 2012
2,217
There are a couple of minor flaws in that argument. Not sure if you have noticed but we are not exactly flush with cash (£1.6 trillion in debt) and secondly when taking into consideration that the millions of migrants also use services increasing the strain on already overstretched services ... studies show there is no real net benefit from immigration.

If only we had some way of limiting (not stopping) immigration so we can at least try to address these pressing issues ... impossible to do while we are in the EU as confirmed by Corbyn the other day and by Cameron's friend who informs us the PM knew his immigration target was unachievable years ago.

Show me a study that says there is no benefit from immigration, or that immigrants stretch services. They don't. They use less services than Brits, and they are net contributors to the UK treasury. These Spanish kids working in bars in Brighton and Polish builders in Angel pay into the system and take very little out. They subsidise British people's services.

Your ignore that we need immigrants to pay down the deficit not increase it.
 


carlzeiss

Well-known member
May 19, 2009
5,854
Amazonia
Vote Remain and fiinance the Sicilian Mafia

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/w...ts-to-start-sicily-forest-fires-a7091321.html

Cats in Sicily could have had petrol-soaked rags attached to them by people linked to the Mafia before being set alight and released into forests to start huge fires, according to the island’s national park officials.

Dozens of forest fires which broke out within hours of each other in Sicily on Thursday are believed to have been begun by mobsters or their collaborators.

Firefighters had to tackle at least 30 blazes in national parks and woodland. Schools and homes have been evacuated and water and power supplies cut. Several children have been treated for smoke inhalation.

The fires all broke out at around the same time on Thursday, which has led the island's national park officials to suggest a co-ordinated plan was behind the blazes.

The effects have been exacerbated by temperatures of up to 40C while the ‘sirocco’, a strong wind which comes from Africa and affects parts of Europe in the summer, has fanned the flames.
Sicilian authorities have pointed the blame at various groups they say have motives for starting the fires, including the mafia, property developers and disgruntled former forest rangers.

“We don’t yet have the proof but we suspect that there are criminal interests behind these fires,” said Rosario Crocetta, the governor of Sicily. “It horrifies me that criminals in Sicily would set fire to national parks and centuries-old woodland, but there are speculative interests behind the fires.”

The mafia recently attempted to assassinate the director of the island’s Nebrodi national park, Giuseppe Antoci, following his efforts to crackdown on the organised criminals making millions of euros through defrauding EU funds set aside for farmers in the park.

Meanwhile, much of the land affected is in areas targeted by developers looking to build homes and holiday villas.

Mr Antoci believes the fires were started deliberately. He said: “It is not possible that the whole of Sicily can go up in flames at the same time simply by chance.

“One of the mob’s arson techniques is to tie a petrol-soaked rag to the tail of a cat and set fire to it,” he added.

According to the Telegraph, there is speculation on the island that forest rangers fired after their links to the mafia were discovered could be responsible.
 






5ways

Well-known member
Sep 18, 2012
2,217
Nouriel Roubini ‏@Nouriel 6 hil y a 6 heures Voir la traduction
Brexit would cause significant damage to the UK economy & to the employment & well being of Britons. The UK is much better off inside the EU


Nouriel Roubini ‏@Nouriel 6 hil y a 6 heures Voir la traduction
Brexit could stall the UK economy and tip it into a recession as the shock to business and consumer confidence could be severe


Nouriel Roubini ‏@Nouriel 6 hil y a 6 heures Voir la traduction
The UK - having large twin current account & fiscal deficits - may risk a sharp currency fall & a sudden stop of capital following Brexit

This guy predicted the 2007 crash btw.


LARRY SUMMERS: Britain leaving the EU would mark the end of an era during which British opinion mattered


http://uk.businessinsider.com/summe...n-would-have-terrible-impact-2015-5?r=US&IR=T
 


Soulman

New member
Oct 22, 2012
10,966
Sompting
Nouriel Roubini ‏@Nouriel 6 hil y a 6 heures Voir la traduction
Brexit would cause significant damage to the UK economy & to the employment & well being of Britons. The UK is much better off inside the EU


Nouriel Roubini ‏@Nouriel 6 hil y a 6 heures Voir la traduction
Brexit could stall the UK economy and tip it into a recession as the shock to business and consumer confidence could be severe


Nouriel Roubini ‏@Nouriel 6 hil y a 6 heures Voir la traduction
The UK - having large twin current account & fiscal deficits - may risk a sharp currency fall & a sudden stop of capital following Brexit

This guy predicted the 2007 crash btw.


LARRY SUMMERS: Britain leaving the EU would mark the end of an era during which British opinion mattered


http://uk.businessinsider.com/summe...n-would-have-terrible-impact-2015-5?r=US&IR=T
Do you need to convince yourself to stay?. As you alluded to in a previous post that some of us remember and appreciated and benefited pre EU. You are of the younger generation who knows no different and seem happy to give up our democracy.
 


One Love

Well-known member
Aug 22, 2011
4,377
Brighton
Do you need to convince yourself to stay?. As you alluded to in a previous post that some of us remember and appreciated and benefited pre EU. You are of the younger generation who knows no different and seem happy to give up our democracy.

Oh our wonderful democracy where we elect governments who stay true to their word.

No problem though, we just vote them out in 5 years time.

And repeat ad infinitum..........
 


GT49er

Well-known member
Feb 1, 2009
46,794
Gloucester
That really chimes with what people were saying yesterday on newsnight. The reporter asked some people why are you voting out? She said well with the immigrants and jobs...and sort of trailed off. Then the reporter said well Mark Carney says it is bad for the economy. She responds to the effect that she and Mark Carney live in different worlds; "has he gone round Sainsbury's on a budget?". The next lady cited cancelled operations as a reasoning for leaving. Asked why the young voted in they said "this is what they know, we're older, we remember something better."

What becomes apparent is that anyone with a gripe, potholes, NHS times, being elderly and remembering that they were once young, are all valid reason to give the status-quo a kicking. In no way does leaving the EU solve any of these issues..............

And in no way does remaining in the EU solve any of these issues either. Like it or not, a vote to remain will be taken by our politicians (and the Eurocrats in Brussels) as a seal of approval for what they are doing. "Panic over, we've got away with it, carry on as before, chaps!"
 




Two Professors

Two Mad Professors
Jul 13, 2009
7,617
Multicultural Brum
Out of interest, who would you stop coming here out of the 50,000 EU migrants that work in the NHS? Just the porters/cleaners, just the doctors/nurses or both?

Sounds like you've been taking stupid pills!When you control immigration,you allow in those you need,not everyone and his brother-duh!
 




Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here