Your Brighton Team

[the hitman]

Lets assume all bans/injuries (apart from navarro) are lifted, what would be your line up and formation?

If you feel we need a new signing put (new signing)

Mine,

----------------Casper------------------

Inigo------Elphick------Greer------Painter

------------------Kish-------------------

----------Sparrow----(New signing)------

Bennett---------------------(New signing)

--------------(New signing)--------------



3 more players off a team that can challenge for promotion IMO and maybe one more for the bench.

 

[Silent Bob]

With what we've got:

Brezovan
Calderon Elphick Greer Painter
Kishishev
Dicker Sparrow
Bennett-----------------Smith
Murray​

In a fantasy football world I'd like to add Lua-Lua, a top striker, and a top keeper. Realistically I'd be happy enough with just Lua-Lua.

 

[Sam Ovett]

-----------------Brezovan-----------------

Inigo-------Elphick-------Greer------Painter

Bennett--Kishishev--Sparrow---(New Player)

----------Murray----------Barnes----------

 

[Dr. Notthenineo'clocknews]

Steele, Cattlin, Williams, Horton...etc etc

 

[Iamapen15]

Casper
Inigo
Painter
Elphick
Greer
Bennett
Kish
Sparrow
+ ONE (Lua Lua?)
Murray
+ ONE (25 goal a season striker)

 

[Skills]

-----------Casper---------------

--Calderon--Greer--Elphick--Painter

------------Kishishev------------
--Bennett--Dicker--Sparrow--Lua Lua

-------------New signing------------

Back up/rotation
El Abd
Murray
New signing
Battipiedi
Baz
Holroyd
Brez
Caskey
Hart
Dunk
Walker

 

[keaton]

I don't understand how people can be convinced Greer's good enough and Murray isn't

 

[the hitman]

I don't understand how people can be convinced Greer's good enough and Murray isn't

Simple really, Greer has prooved himself to be good enough in a team challenging for promotion, Murray has not.

 

[Mellotron]

I don't understand how people can be convinced Greer's good enough and Murray isn't

keaton, look back through "the hitman"'s posts. I reckon 80-90% of them are purely slagging Murray off. He has a real issue with him.

 

[albionalex]

Brevovan

Calderon
El-Abd
Greer
Painter

Bennet
Dicker
Sparrow
A left winger (Maybe Lua Lua)

Murray
A new striker

 

[clippedgull]

New Signing
Inigo
Painter
Elphick
Greer
Bennett
Kishishev
Sparrow
New Signing
New Signing
New Signing

If we are serious about wanting to challenge for promotion.

otherwise replace goalie with Casper and one of the striker roles with Murray for an accepted top half finish.

I'm not saying Murray is no good, but I don't think he would be prolific enough over the season. (Hope i'm proved incorrect this season!)

 

[Gav1901]

Brezovan

Calderon
Greer
El Abd
Painter

Bennett
Dicker
Sparrow
Monkhouse

Murray
Easter

 

[SirDouglasLoft]

New Signing

New Signing
New Signing
New Signing
New Signing

New Signing
New Signing
New Signing
New Signing

Me.
New Signing

subs:
New Signing
New Signing
New Signing
New Signing
New Signing
New Signing
New Signing

 

[WhingForPresident]

Don't think Smith is quite good enough yet.. Obviously talented, but not quite ready to be in a promotion chasing side.
I would go with

-----------------Brezovan------------------

---Calderon----Elphick----Greer----Painter---

---------------- Navarro--------------------

----Bennett--------Sparrow--------Lua-Lua--

----Wilbraham (MK Dons)------Murray--------


Bench:
Ankergren
Barnes
Dicker
New LB
Kishishev
El-Abd
Smith

 

[fire&skill]

Brezovan

Calderon Elphick Greer Painter

Bennett Kishishev Sparrow Smith

Murray Barnes

 

[jayjaybhafc]

BREZ
INIGO... ELPHICK... GREER... PAINTER
BENNETT... SPARROW... KISH... SMITH... (new signing)
MURRAY/(new signing)

I think we need a "big man" forward, like when we had Trevor Benjamin in 2004

 

[the hitman]

keaton, look back through "the hitman"'s posts. I reckon 80-90% of them are purely slagging Murray off. He has a real issue with him.

I just don't get how you lot see him as one of the best strikers in the league, he is not. Time after time he wastes chances or is offside so does not get the chance. Replace him with a decent striker and we would be much better off.

 

[Gav1901]

I just don't get how you lot see him as one of the best strikers in the league, he is not. Time after time he wastes chances or is offside so does not get the chance. Replace him with a decent striker and we would be much better off.

Murray is up there, but wouldn't say one of the best. We shouldn't replace him though, that's just stupidity.

 

[the hitman]

Not replace him, but replace his position in the team. 451 is the position we should play, and Murray is not good enough for the position

 

[HP Seagull]

----------------Ankergren----------------

--Calderon---Elphick----Greer---Painter---

------------------Kishishev---------------

--Bennett---Sparrow---Hughes---LuaLua--

-----------------New Signing--------------


Wouldn't be too disappointed to see Murray up top but from what we've heard it would seem we are trying to get someone better, so I've gone for them.

Same applies for Dicker in midfield but I've always thought Hughes is an excellent player. Andy Naylor intimated the other day that Gus' only concern with Hughes was his fitness - if this is the case I'm not sure why we haven't snapped him up because surely that is something that can be quickly resolved?