Charlie Oatway critcis

[Silver flying chariot]

Well after all the shit that Charlie took on this board, i hope you arse holes that gave him that shit watched the game today. The bloke was absolutly awesome,

Everytime we go on a bad run, Oatway is absolutly ripped apart and told he is not good enough and what a waste of space he is.

I would pick up over Nicolas everytime at the moment. he runs his arse off, chases everything and his tackling is great. His passing is not the best and never will be, but he is there to win the ball back.

Charlie was different class today and by far the best player on the pitch for us.

Good performance, we battered them the whole game, unlucky not to win but never mind. Lets get a win at burnley. They have lost their last 5.

It is so close at the bottom and won't be over till last game I reckon.

Lets get behind ALL of the players and get us out of this mess!!
We can do it

 

[J Livingstone Seagull]

What he said. I don't know how Butters got MoM. Charlie was awesome today.

 

[ShorehamGull]

Well Done Charlie, true determination today

 

[Basil Fawlty]

Well played Charlie. Anyone reckon that he reads the stuff on this board?

 

[Ernest]

Shame he missed that sitter in the first few minutes

 

[Wilka]

Well played Charlie! I would have him in my starting 11 every time. In this situation Charlie is a vital player to have around.

 

[London Irish]

Well, I hope some of his critics have the guts to admit they were wrong, but on past experience, that doesn't happen much on NSC.

The thing that really stops sensible, civilised discussion about Albion footy on NSC is this bizarre tendency people have to single out players and magnify their faults a hundredfold.

The problem this creates is that people go so bizzarely overboard with their slag-offs, that there is just no sensible way back for them, they just paint themselves completely into a corner. They don't allow some ambiguity or doubt that their 100% slag-off of a player might be wrong. They are then left in the frankly pathetic position of having to rubbish a player at every opportunity just as an act of self-justification. Very, very sad that any Albion fan gets themselves into such a position

 

[n1 gull]

I think Charlie is great in 3-5-2 or 5-3-2, but struggles when we play 4-4-2.
He's a top bloke, but sometimes he can be truly rubbish.

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

Totally agree, great performance from Chaz today

 

[Bakesy]

I think Charlie is great in 3-5-2 or 5-3-2, but struggles when we play 4-4-2.
He's a top bloke, but sometimes he can be truly rubbish.

you're sitting on the fence then

 

[Eggman]

Played well.

Respect where its due.

 

[the right footed denilson]

i am an oatway critic

i didnt go to the game today but reports sound good so fair play to him.

however, my opinion still stands- one good game in the last 6 speaks for itself and anyone suddenly suggesting he is a great player would be alot more foolish than the people who criticise him after seeing him play 100+ times.

(agree entirely with n1 gull. hopefully MM will stick with this formation for the rest of the season so we can see the best of charlie and the squad.)

 

[Harty]

The knockers and doubters will hide away without making comment until the next opportunity arises for them to knock Chas, way of the world I'm afraid.
There will certainly be no humble pie on NSC.

 

[ShorehamGull]

The knockers and doubters will hide away without making comment until the next opportunity arises for them to knock Chas, way of the world I'm afraid.
There will certainly be no humble pie on NSC.

Like the doubters that come on your show Harty knocking down Mcghee, Dick Knight and the players everytime we lose.

 

[the right footed denilson]

thats the beauty of free speach Harty- posters can say what they want when they want. i dont rate Oatway, i never will and im not ashamed to admit it but threads like these are just excuses for slanging matches.

football is all about opinions huh?

 

[Scotty Mac]

class

 

[Waterhall Wizard]

thats the beauty of free speach Harty- posters can say what they want when they want. i dont rate Oatway, i never will and im not ashamed to admit it but threads like these are just excuses for slanging matches.

football is all about opinions huh?

Go and stick your head in that red soil at the end of your road. That's my opinion. It's as valid and as ridiculous as the crap that has spewed forth about Chas on this board over the past few weeks.

 

[Goring Gull]

I said i thought he wasn;t good enough for this division and i still stand by that despite a good performance today - He is not a championship player - fact.

To be honest my slagging of him probably spurred him on too prove me wrong if he read the post on here.

 

[mona]

Oatway was not our MOM. If it hadn't been Guy Butters it should have been Paul Reid or Chippy. But it's a team game.

Charlie was very good for an hour but then drifted. IMO he should have been subbed rather than Dean Hammond - not that I'd have brought on Nathan Jones anyway.
Here comes the abuse.

 

[Safeway]

Anyone reckon that he reads the stuff on this board?

*snigger*