Carlisle Player Ratings

[Acker79]

Listen again:

Dickinson WAS RUBBISH against Stockport. Not compared to Forster, or Murray, or any other striker we have had in the last 10 years.

He had a bad game full stop. His control was dreadful. He kept giving the ball away when attempting link up play. Simple as that.

I can completely see the qualities a Heskey-style player provides, and if you'd read closer you'd notice I said I think he'll come good, making your dig at me baseless.

Still, carry on regardless.

Dig at you? I don't see your name, or a quote of yours, in my post. You didn't even bring up murray, did you?

Psychologists might say you have a guilty conscience.

 

[RM-Taylor]

Kuipers - 8

Virgo - 6 - looked shaky at right-back, need Whingy back rather soon
Elphick - 6
Tunnicliffe - 7
El-Abd - 6 - battled, determined, chased-down, although everyone was gasping when he hoofed the ball up in the air and it went backwards

Bennett - 6 - really quiet
Crofts - 6
Dicker - 7
A. Davies - 8 - how refreshing it is to have good set-pieces delivered. Sign him up

Forster - 9
Dickinson - 6

 

[Couldn't Be Hyypia]

Is Crofts one of those players who you don't see being showy but who just does a good job every game? These types rarely get big scores in player ratings but they are the spine of the team.

 

[Common as Mook]

Is Crofts one of those players who you don't see being showy but who just does a good job every game? These types rarely get big scores in player ratings but they are the spine of the team.

The same types who get called a 'joke' and given 5 just because they don't have a massive afro, a exotic sounding name or score a backheeled goal every other game?

Yep, that's the type.

 

[seagullsovergrimsby]

Kuipers - 8

Virgo - 6 - looked shaky at right-back, need Whingy back rather soon
Elphick - 6
Tunnicliffe - 7
El-Abd - 6 - battled, determined, chased-down, although everyone was gasping when he hoofed the ball up in the air and it went backwards

Bennett - 6 - really quiet
Crofts - 6
Dicker - 7
A. Davies - 8 - how refreshing it is to have good set-pieces delivered. Sign him up

Forster - 9
Dickinson - 6

Agree , except that FDM should get a 9 rating and in my opinion was joint MOM with Foz. Dicko is one of those players who one moment looks clumsy and the next inspires us with his skills. subs : OGH 6 , Thornhill - unrated , not on long enough.