Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Politics] Brexit

If there was a second Brexit referendum how would you vote?


  • Total voters
    1,084


Buzzer

Languidly Clinical
Oct 1, 2006
26,121
It will translate into dollars when we import anything, including Trident.

GDP measures total value of goods produced not costs and I really don't want to labour the point but I'll say again that a lot of heavyweight names have said that Sterling was overvalued anyway and that Brexit merely kicked off the revision, it was not the underlying cause and devaluation would have occurred anyway.
 




Baldseagull

Well-known member
Jan 26, 2012
10,987
Crawley
Leaving the EU is no more a big deal for the UK than joining the EU was for all those countries that joined by virtue of referenda and it's no more a big deal than joining a single pan-national currency and tying in your interest rates and banking arrangements with other disparate economies which Norway and Sweden decided against by referenda. I've never ever ONCE heard anyone say that these countries should not have had these referenda on the EU because it's all too complex. And furthermore, if the vote had been to Remain then I know you would not be trying to claim this frankly absurd and illogical position.

Just be honest. You wouldn't give the idea of referenda in a representative democracy even a shadow of doubt if the vote had gone Remain.

Joining is a much more quantifiable thing, the rules, the laws, the treaties are all there in black and white. It is less complex with less mystery.

There is an almost endless list of things that had certainty that currently have none with Brexit. I will admit I have considered the rights and wrongs of holding a referendum on this issue more than I had before the referendum, but I am not convinced I would hold a different opinion now if I had considered this at the same length for any other reason.

I believe it is possible to have held a referendum on this issue, but that it needed to have either more than an all or nothing in/out set of options, and a clear indication of the actions that would follow each choice.
Sounds complicated to do doesn't it?
 


Soulman

New member
Oct 22, 2012
10,966
Sompting
Ok, I'm not really down with this shit. This stupidity that not accepting the results of a referendum is somehow "undemocratic" has been trolled out non-stop by leavers ever since the result came in and I've had enough of it. I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say something that will have the Brexiters spitting their tea out all over their computer screens........

REFERENDUMS ARE UNDEMOCRATIC

There! Didn't see that one coming did you? How can I possibly argue this load of absolute nonsense then? Well, it's gonna be a long one so bear with me.....

There were a series of absolutely corking referendums in Germany in the 1930s....From that famously "democratic" organisation known as the National Socialist German Workers' Party.....

I liked this one in 1933 about withdrawing from The League of Nations....

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_referendum,_1933

And this absolute cracker of a referendum where 38 MILLION people (88% YES) thought it would be a good idea to merge the position of Chancellor and President into one absolute ruler known as "The Fuhrer".....

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_referendum,_1934

Check out this one where 98.8% of "the people" thought it would be a good idea to invade the Rhineland and thus violate the Treaty of Versailles....

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_election_and_referendum,_1936

And let's top off this little series of referendums with this classic (there's actually a pic of the ballot paper here).......

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germa...m,_1938#/media/File:Stimmzettel-Anschluss.jpg

Yay referendums aye? Yay democracy!!!! :clap:

Funnily enough after the war in Europe was over Churchill suggested having one of our own about waiting until victory in Japan before breaking the all-party coalition. Clement Attlee was unimpressed with this idea, saying....

“I could not consent to the introduction into our national life of a device so alien to all our traditions as the referendum, which has only too often been the instrument of Nazism and fascism.” (https://capx.co/referendums-are-a-quintessentially-british-institution/)

Ironically the UK didn't feel the need to hold a referendum until 1975....About the UK’s continuing membership of the European Economic Community. Even Mrs Thatch seemed to think that holding a referendum was a wholly "undemocratic" enterprise at the time....

“The late Lord Attlee was right when he said that the referendum was a device of dictators and demagogues.” (http://www.margaretthatcher.org/document/102649)

Interesting that once she was in office she never held a single referendum in those 11 years....

Of course Germany, now a fully democratic country, still remembers it's wartime past (even if most brexiteers don't) and has banned referendums altogether. Hitler made them realise that referendums are dangerous tools that can be used by weak governments to mobilise "the people" into yelling all at once. This creates a thunderclap of noise centered around the "popular opinion" that legitimises their argument and drowns out opposing views. To say it again for the cheap seats...REAL democracy is a system that recognises the right for the losers to still have representation and a voice. This is why we actually run the country via parliamentary democracy, rather than referendums.

Because referendums are undemocratic.

Flipping Nora, if I had copied and pasted that lot the Remain police would have had a field day.
 










studio150

Well-known member
Jul 30, 2011
29,665
On the Border
GDP measures total value of goods produced not costs and I really don't want to labour the point but I'll say again that a lot of heavyweight names have said that Sterling was overvalued anyway and that Brexit merely kicked off the revision, it was not the underlying cause and devaluation would have occurred anyway.

A leaver supporting 'experts' ?

It is of course total rubbish as clearly the pound fell immediately after the result but in your world that was because that was the day that the heavy weights moved to devalue an over valued pound and absolutely nothing to do with the result.

Yeah right and the sum sets in the east in this fantasy world
 


Buzzer

Languidly Clinical
Oct 1, 2006
26,121
A leaver supporting 'experts' ?

It is of course total rubbish as clearly the pound fell immediately after the result but in your world that was because that was the day that the heavy weights moved to devalue an over valued pound and absolutely nothing to do with the result.

Yeah right and the sum sets in the east in this fantasy world
So what part of that report do you disagree with or, as I suspect, are you substituting bluster and bullshit for reasonable debate? Go on, admit it. You never even looked at the article.
 




Two Professors

Two Mad Professors
Jul 13, 2009
7,617
Multicultural Brum
Only image of a 'sum set' I could find,but given the poster,very appropriate! :lolol:

dim wit.jpg
 


studio150

Well-known member
Jul 30, 2011
29,665
On the Border
So what part of that report do you disagree with or, as I suspect, are you substituting bluster and bullshit for reasonable debate? Go on, admit it. You never even looked at the article.

So uncertainty which effects markets and which Brexit has brought has had zero impact on the pound falling?

The report is only a guess about the future not the reson for the lower valued pound. Indeed the rationale for it falling further effictively have Brexit as the route cause given that inflation is mainly Brexit driven.
 
Last edited:






Mental Lental

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
2,274
Shiki-shi, Saitama


JC Footy Genius

Bringer of TRUTH
Jun 9, 2015
10,568
There was an expectation from me and others that once the plan to drill the hole was given the go ahead, most people would start donning the lifejackets. However, it seems most are happy to carry on as normal, at least until the hole is started, perhaps many will wait till the hole is finished. We will see how happy they are with the plan once they can see that the water keeps rising.

As most people who voted didn't think we were drilling a hole in the boat it was perhaps foolhardy to think they would react like they did believe that. Yes the short term predictions of woe have been proved innacurate so have been conveniantlty pushed further downstream. Hope you are comfortable in your life jacket, if you keep it on long enough you might actually need it.
 


GT49er

Well-known member
Feb 1, 2009
46,843
Gloucester
Aaah you're trying to claim that those Nazi referendums weren't real referendums because the voters were marched into the polling booths at gun point to vote the right way. Just like in those other regimes. Read your history. Both the 1933 and 34 one (the big one) were a result of Hitler's convincing rhetoric and mass propaganda. They were very much decisions made of their own free will. I'll concede that after he became Fuhrer, the later ones had an element of being marched to the poll booth. You only have to see the ridiculous margins of victory to see that. (99.8%!!
)
No. Once again you're completely off message. I'm merely putting forward known facts. Unfortunately, they are facts which do not sit comfortably with your particular views.
 






GT49er

Well-known member
Feb 1, 2009
46,843
Gloucester
Spot on.

In other news......Let's have a chuckle at these windowlickers who actually thought that a Conservative government would make up the shortfall in funds received from the EU if they voted leave.....

https://inews.co.uk/essentials/news...-go-off-cliff-due-lack-eu-government-funding/
"Windowlickers"......... nice. It's impressive how those nice, liberal, politically correct rational remainers never resort to abusive language. It's almost a pity they lost,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
 








studio150

Well-known member
Jul 30, 2011
29,665
On the Border
That wasn't the question I asked. What part of that investment bank's forecasting model do you disagree with?

It correctly references high inflation but fails to mention the reason which is mostly due to Brexit. Similar to many leavers you have failed to accept this as just present the report as written.

So basically all the tough and poorer times are here and set to be in place for years to come.

The super patriots must be so happy
 


Thunder Bolt

Silly old bat
Spot on.

In other news......Let's have a chuckle at these windowlickers who actually thought that a Conservative government would make up the shortfall in funds received from the EU if they voted leave.....

https://inews.co.uk/essentials/news...-go-off-cliff-due-lack-eu-government-funding/

Ignoring the name calling, it's similar to the farmer, who voted leave, because he was fed up with DEFRA taking its time paying out his subsidy.
He genuinely thought DEFRA was an EU organisation.
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here