1234andcounting
Well-known member
- Mar 31, 2008
- 1,609
Do we really? Not sure Snr Poyet would see it that way myself.
Ashley Barnes - Your opinion
- Thread starter OSRGull
- Start date
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Do we really? Not sure Snr Poyet would see it that way myself.
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
Two assists and a class penalty, last night. He's third in the Championship scorers table with 5 league goals. He's one of my favourite players at the moment.
ATFC Seagull
Aberystwyth Town FC
Leeds fan who was at the game (and knows very little about our squad) said Barnes stood out to him as a really great player. Couldn't believe how young he was.
Tummy Burger
New member
I have not been Barnes's biggest fan previously. Last night was up there with his best performances for us. His touch and close control has improved so much it's god damn frightening.
ROSM
Well-known member
I really like Barnes but was concerned after his booking that he pulled out of challenges that we needed a striker to be strong on. I was advocating him being replaced by hoskins - but then.he pops up with a great assist. Glad I'm not the boss!
Correct.....he put two sublime passes to CMS for his goals and tucked the penalty away as all penalty takers should.
If fans need to slag Barnes off perhaps they should set up a different forum from which to do it.
Barnes was brilliant tonight.
Add Vincelot to that.
Last edited:
Captain Sensible
Well-known member
Having watched the game back, Barnes was great. Posed a threat and involved well in link up play. I'm glad we don't have a target man type, it stops the hoofing. This hold the ball up nonsense is crap, in the 2nd half when the ball went up to our front two, the ball stayed in the opposition 3rd. They linked up well and got straight down to zipping the ball around, no holding up required.
Barnes is a very good player.
Barnes is a very good player.
Titus
Come on!
It is not a fact and it is not indisputable. Carry on.
JJ McClure
Go Jags
I was saying pretty much the same thing. I guess that's why I'm in the stands. The only thing that concerned me about Barnes last night was how deep he was playing, particularly in the first half the space between him and CMS was massive.
Absolutely this. His movement off the ball is tremendous also. If KLL had looked up before crossing on one occasion last night, he'll have seen Barnes drop back about 12 yards out completely unmarked and that would've been another one. Great player, getting better and better.
Those two penalties good enough for you Burns?I don't change my opinion like the weather and I won't bump a thread if he doesn't perform (although I might bounce this one if the keeper saves his next just of centre penalty
bhaexpress
New member
Be serious ! Mind you the comment that ATFC Seagull said about what a Leeds fan thought speaks volumes. As was also said elsewhere £50,000 as against £2500,000 ? Also, I am a bit concerned about Hoskins, how bad his injury ? Put it like this if Barnes got injured he'd be very missed.
mutton43
New member
He is a forward,forwards are meant to score goals and he is,so i am unsure what else he needs to do
bhaexpress
New member
According to some, be Wayne Rooney without the wealth.
Mr Burns
New member
Yes thank you. I'm still trying to recall a better penalty. The two against Liverpool and Leeds were class, and I'd say the best one was Leeds, as he had masive pressure on him, whereas the Liverpool one didn't matter too much as the game was gone, but Leeds had a lot riding on it, so fair to him.
Still hasn't changed my overall opinion though. He's definately a much better player this season, but he was poor at Bristol and Leicester (along with everyone else), and even when we did start to get going last night, he seemed to be the weak link to start with, but that said I think by the end he had the best game I've seen him play for us, and long may it continue. He does seem to be getting his first touch better, but he still wastes far to many chances and gives away too many lose passes for my likely.
Don't forget if Mackill-Smith was here for the first pen, he may well have had four more goals to his name. I think if we had lost last night, Barnes would have come in for a lot of stick for his recent performances, but fair play to him, as I said in the end he had a blinder last night.
Also without being negative, he's been lucky to play this seaon, and I dont think anyone will question that if Hoskins and Buckley, along with the transfer day signing had been around for all the games, Barnes wouldn't have got a look in. From what i hear he still hasn't convinced Poyet. Appartently Poyet loves his commitment, his attitude, his 100% williness to kee going, but doesn't rate his skill, which is probably why they were trying to sign at least one striker on deadline day, and from what I hear if we are still sniffing around the play offs in January, there will be serious cash available for players in the window.
Bottom line is, if Barnes repeats his second half performance last night for the next dozen games or so, he'll win over his harshist critics, and I hope he does, for his sake and the teams. But when everyone is fit (if that ever happens) Hoskins, Buckley, Vincente, CMS, then we'll see how much Poyet rates Ashley then.
For the first time in a while if ever, we seemed to play to CMS strengths last night, and look what he did, especially witht he first goal. That's a class striker, and hopefully he's over his minor blip now, and hopefully we can start getting the ball to his feet in the box and reap the rewards.
One last thing I will say about Ashley though, I f***ing loved the way he got in that twats Belemey face on Wednesday and laughed at him. Pure class from Barnes. Maybe he is finally growing a pair of bollocks!!!
Mr Burns
New member
Fair comment, but in a Poyet side, obviosuly a lot more.
I'm a fan of Casper's, but if goalkeeper were just meant to save shots, Kuipers would probably still be here, IMO Kuipers was one of the best shot stoppers we've had for a while, but at the same time the most over rated and poor goalkeepers we've had for a long time.
Centre halfs are meant to just win the all pumped in the air and hoof balls away up field aren't thay, but in a Poyet team that wouldn't get them in the ground, let alone the squad.
Mr Burns
New member
He done that a few times last night. I think Gus need to tie a bit of string around KLL head, and every time he goes on one of his runs, tug the string so it lifts KLLs head!! He could do the same with Nooney and even Barnes sometimes as well!!
bhaexpress
New member
It's such a shame he's not the next Messi.
It is not inconceivable that Barnes could learn to play a wee bit better? It seems more likely than finding a striker in England. That latter is not without risks (remember Maybank).