Adam El-Abd or Lewis Dunk?

[ArcticBlue]

Adam El-Abd alongside Gordon Greer. Best centre back partnership since Cullip and Morgan.

 

[Albion Dan]

Sell Dunk for £5m hopefully then problem solved.

 

[dgh123]

El-Abd

 

[Dick Knights Mumm]

Adam El-Abd alongside Gordon Greer. Best centre back partnership since Cullip and Morgan.

Since Morgan and Anyone. He was a centre-back.

 

[Sonic]

Got to be El-Abd. I've rated him since the first time I saw him play.

 

[BensGrandad]

Without a shadow of doubt the 2 should be Greer and El Abd as they proved last season. Dunk has done well and is a good prospect but he is not yet as good and efficient as Adam El Abd.

 

[Perkino]

Dunk has been very good all season and El-Abd has only looked a shadow of his best from last season since he has been back

 

[middletoenail]

I would prefer El-Abd and Greer in the short term, they served us so well last season and Greer has the ability to ping some Koemanesque balls to the wingers.

Dunk definitely long term but something tells me he doesn't have a long term future here.

 

[deletebeepbeepbeep]

Newcastle have offered £5m for Tomkins, Dunk is worth probably a third of that.

 

[Captain Sensible]

El Abd for me. The season is gonna get tough and he had Lambert all game on Monday.

 

[JBizzle]

Dunk has been very good all season and El-Abd has only looked a shadow of his best from last season since he has been back

With the exception of the ONLY game he played in his natural position. El-Abd was immense against Saints. Utterly immense.

 

[Weststander]

No rush to decide. In 3 games time, one of those two will probably be suspended or injured or abducted by aliens.

True. Probably, yet another ban!

 

[Weststander]

With the exception of the ONLY game he played in his natural position. El-Abd was immense against Saints. Utterly immense.

And a warrior against Burnley. Always in the right place at the right time. The local heartbeat of the club & team.

 

[Weststander]

Dunk has been very good all season and El-Abd has only looked a shadow of his best from last season since he has been back

El-Abd has only been back 5 minutes from a serious injury, and in at least 2 games, has been incredible.

 

[Albion Dan]

Dunk has been very good all season and El-Abd has only looked a shadow of his best from last season since he has been back

2 of those games he played out of position!!!

 

[Arkwright]

Couple of points.
1). Dunk is not worth the money banned about on these threads. We will be lucky to get 1.5 million tops.
2). I have thought for a while that 3-5-2 would suit Gus's style of play so we can then fit all three in with Greer or Dunk sweeping.