Player ratings Reading (H)

M

Matt Richards

Member

Jan 22, 2009

37

• Apr 11, 2012

• #41

watsongooal - I now understand where you are coming from but it is just not right - you surely have to mark on what they have contributed not how well they have performed in relation to their own ability - or am I missing something?

 

watsongooal

New member

Jul 7, 2003

2,556

Chislehurst

• Apr 11, 2012

• #42

Matt Richards said:

watsongooal - I now understand where you are coming from but it is just not right - you surely have to mark on what they have contributed not how well they have performed in relation to their own ability - or am I missing something?

Click to expand...

Ok Matt just for you- I will give vicente 8 and barnes 7

Dont say I dont do anything for you.

 

JCL666

absurdism

Sep 23, 2011

2,190

• Apr 11, 2012

• #43

Matt Richards said:

watsongooal - I now understand where you are coming from but it is just not right - you surely have to mark on what they have contributed not how well they have performed in relation to their own ability - or am I missing something?

Click to expand...

Yeah, otherwise Brez gets 10 for catching the ball TWICE.

 

Shooting Star

Well-known member

Apr 29, 2011

2,798

Suffolk

• Apr 11, 2012

• #44

All I'll say is that LuaLua is clearly a better starting player than Buckley. Buckley is a better impact player.

Oh, and I'm one of the few who thought CMS had a good game.

 

Acker79

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Nov 15, 2008

31,921

Brighton

• Apr 13, 2012

• #45

Reading average match ratings (26 votes)

El-Abd 8.19
Vicente 7.98
Navarro 7.71
Brezovan 7.00
Calderon 7.00
Greer 6.88
Barnes 6.58
Dicker 6.15
Jara Reyes 5.65
Mackail-Smith 5.19

Subs (17 votes)
Lualua 6.32 (19 votes)
Assulin 5.65
Vokes 5.65


Team Average: 6.61