You are the Ref! How well do you really know the laws?

Kuipers Supporters Club · Mar 31, 2011

Scenario:

Brighton have been given a free kick (FK) inside their own half, just outside the penalty area. Greer takes the FK, passing it back to Casper. But disaster strikes when the ball hits a bobble, bounces over his foot and goes directly in from the FK without touching anyone.

What is your decision?

fire&skill · Mar 31, 2011

Goal. Assuming it's not indirect?

You Are The Ref for iPhone, iPod touch and iPad on the iTunes App Store

Kuipers Supporters Club · Mar 31, 2011

It's Direct FK by Painter.

fire&skill · Mar 31, 2011

Or Greer? I'm confused now. Still think it's a goal though.

Kuipers Supporters Club · Mar 31, 2011

Yes Sorry Greer! I used it as a demo with Painter earlier! Sorry!
But you are wrong F&S

Stevie Boy · Mar 31, 2011

all depends if its direct or in direct

Kuipers Supporters Club · Mar 31, 2011

Stevie Boy said:
all depends if its direct or in direct

Direct.

Stevie Boy · Mar 31, 2011

its a goal then

Lord Bracknell · Mar 31, 2011

It's a corner to the other side.

Kuipers Supporters Club · Mar 31, 2011

Lord Bracknell said:
It's a corner to the other side.

We have a winner!

The reason being you CAN'T score an OG from your own dead ball situation be it a Direct FK, Corner or Penalty.

Alex Alex Dawson oo! oo! · Mar 31, 2011

Not a goal, in your example the ref hasn't blown the whistle for the FK to be taken so the ball is never in play.

Lord Bracknell · Mar 31, 2011

Lord Bracknell said:
It's a corner to the other side.

Blimey! I'm right.

I've just looked it up. Law 13, page 36.

http://www.fifa.com/mm/document/affederation/generic/81/42/36/lawsofthegame_2010_11_e.pdf

Uter · Mar 31, 2011

Alex said:
Not a goal, in your example the ref hasn't blown the whistle for the FK to be taken so the ball is never in play.

The ref doesn't have to blow his whistle for play to resume.

Uter · Mar 31, 2011

Brighton4Cambridge3 said:
We have a winner!

The reason being you CAN'T score an OG from your own dead ball situation be it a Direct FK, Corner or Penalty.

OMG We should actually do this on purpose one match and then watch the opposition players supporters and manager go mental when they realise a goal hasn't been awarded.

Kuipers Supporters Club · Mar 31, 2011

Uter said:
The ref doesn't have to blow his whistle for play to resume.

The whistle is NOT needed to:
• stop play for:
– a goal kick, corner kick or throw-in
– a goal
• restart play from:
– a free kick, goal kick, corner kick, throw-in

Kuipers Supporters Club · Mar 31, 2011

Anyway here is another:

It's a GK, and Casper goes to take it short to Painter, who realising the opposition striker is waiting to pounce on the ball. Runs and picks up the ball inside the area.
What do you give? And are any cards necessary?

Uter · Mar 31, 2011

Brighton4Cambridge3 said:
Anyway here is another:

It's a GK, and Casper goes to take it short to Painter, who realising the opposition striker is waiting to pounce on the ball. Runs and picks up the ball inside the area.
What do you give? And are any cards necessary?

I'd guess the GK needs to be retaken as it has to leave the penalty area. Maybe a yellow card for unsporting behaviour for Painter?

stss30 · Mar 31, 2011

Brighton4Cambridge3 said:
Anyway here is another:

It's a GK, and Casper goes to take it short to Painter, who realising the opposition striker is waiting to pounce on the ball. Runs and picks up the ball inside the area.
What do you give? And are any cards necessary?

if Painter touches the ball, it's a backpass and pen should be awarded?

Edit:Apologies I thought Casper picked the ball up and you didn't say whether the ball left the box- be more specific!

Kuipers Supporters Club · Mar 31, 2011

Uter said:
I'd guess the GK needs to be retaken as it has to leave the penalty area. Maybe a yellow card for unsporting behaviour for Painter?

Very good! Even with the unsporting behaviour!

Kuipers Supporters Club · Mar 31, 2011

Ok! Trying to be more difficult !
From the first KO Murray who is the only player to have touched the ball shoots directly at goal and the ball goes straight in.
Goal? Or re -take?

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

You are the Ref! How well do you really know the laws?

Well-known member

Killer-Diller

Well-known member

Killer-Diller

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

On fire

Well-known member

Primary data is fact

On fire

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Registered User

Well-known member

Well-known member

Share this page