Rooney - What if

[Kinky Gerbil]

He had signed for Chelsea two years ago instead of signing for Utd?

Would he have been the same player he is now or would he have gone the SWP route and be destroyed as a player inside a season due to lack of football?

 

[larus]

He would be playing regularly for them.

Look at Cole/Lampard, they've both improved dramatically at Chelsea.

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

I don't think he would be the player he is now - like him or hate him, Ferguson knows how to get the best out of young talent better than anyone in my opinion

 

[Stinky Kat]

bit off subject but if Rooney plays any part against T&T on Thurs I cant wait to see who red in the face Sir Alex goes

 

[blockhseagull]

He had signed for Chelsea two years ago instead of signing for Utd?

Would he have been the same player he is now or would he have gone the SWP route and be destroyed as a player inside a season due to lack of football?

I think he would have been ok at Chelsea, probablem with SWP is he went to a team overloaded with wide players, Duff, Robben, J.Cole even Geremi plays on the right sometimes

Still probably better off at Utd, Ferguson might be a twat but does know how to manage young players