Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Player Ratings



Turkey

Well-known member
Jul 4, 2003
15,587
Flitney - 6
Hinshelwood 7
Cullip - 8
Butters - 7
Mayo - 7
Hart - 6
Oatway - 6
Rodger - 6
Jones - 8
Henderson - 7
Knight - 7
 




Dunkstar

Active member
Jul 6, 2003
2,428
Up a Hill
Flitney-
Hinshelwood-6
Cullip-7
Butters-8
Mayo-6
Hart-5
Rodger-5
Oatway-6
Jones-7
Henderson-5
Knight-7

Turkey i think you are a bit generous giving some people an average 6 when they were actually worse than average such as Hart!And Henderson a 7!? Where were you sitting cos you obviously didn't see him in the 1st half and he had 1 shot wide in the 2nd!
 


Turkey

Well-known member
Jul 4, 2003
15,587
I thought Henderson did pretty well. I also thought the defence did very well.
 


pissoffpalace

New member
Jul 7, 2003
52
Hove
Time for Butters to go. Unfit, lazy Wimbledon style football, over paid.

Cullip needs to tell him that he is the boss. A job Butters seems to want. The backs dont seem to be getting on too well.

Hinsh is looking good
 






Fran Hagarty

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
2,412
Mid Sussex
Flitney - 6
Hinshelwood 7
Cullip - 7
Butters - 7
Mayo - 6
Hart - 6
Oatway - 7
Rodger - 6
Jones - 8
Henderson - 6
Knight - 7
 


Marc

New member
Jul 6, 2003
25,267
Flitney - 7
Hinshlewood - 7
Cullip - 7
Butters - 7
Mayo - 6
Hart - 6
Oatway - 6
Roger - 6
Jones - 8
Henderson - 5
Knight - 7
 


oapdodge

New member
Jul 15, 2003
2,866
Flitney - 6
Hinshelwood 6
Cullip - 7
Butters - 8
Mayo - 6
Hart - 4
Oatway - 5
Rodger - 5
Jones - 7
Henderson - 5
Knight - 7 he can play shit if he scores like that.
Mcphee - 5
 




Dunkstar

Active member
Jul 6, 2003
2,428
Up a Hill
Turkey said:
I thought Henderson did pretty well. I also thought the defence did very well.

Well i was in j and all he did in the first half was give the ball away,not jump for headers,and not make any runs.If you call that pretty well then fine!However i can see how people might be swayed by his second half performance which was ok but nothing special i'd say a 6 so to add to his 4 in the first half and halve it=5 which was what i gave him!
The defence was good but i have to say we were mucking about and giving it away at the back a few too many times for my likeing
and this is reflected in my ratings!
Good result average performance but if we play like this on saturday we're gonna get hammered!
 


Fran Hagarty

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
2,412
Mid Sussex
pissoffpalace said:
Time for Butters to go. Unfit, lazy Wimbledon style football, over paid.

The match sponsors made him MOM! The guest on Harty's phone -in (Paul Hayward or Mike Ward?) gave it to Oatway. I would have given it to Jones!
 






Turkey

Well-known member
Jul 4, 2003
15,587
Dunkstar said:
Well i was in j and all he did in the first half was give the ball away,not jump for headers,and not make any runs.If you call that pretty well then fine!However i can see how people might be swayed by his second half performance which was ok but nothing special i'd say a 6 so to add to his 4 in the first half and halve it=5 which was what i gave him!
The defence was good but i have to say we were mucking about and giving it away at the back a few too many times for my likeing
and this is reflected in my ratings!
Good result average performance but if we play like this on saturday we're gonna get hammered!

I think he does a lot for the team that goes unnoticed but if my rating is going to get such a respone I'll change it to 5. I can't say I care really.
 




Zebedee

Anyone seen Florence?
Jul 8, 2003
8,073
Hangleton
I thought that we were very poor tonight and that there wasn't much between us and the Cheats. I am dreading Saturday if we continue to play like that.

Flitney - 6
Hinshelwood 7
Cullip - 6
Butters - 6
Mayo - 6
Hart - 6
Oatway - 7
Rodger - 5 (absolute shite - what has happened to him?)
Jones - 8
Henderson - 6
Knight - 7

Incidentally, after his terrific performance at Colchester, why didn't Piercey play? Clearly Coppell doesn't rate him but he couldn't be any worse than Rodgers was tonight.


__________________

:(
 
Last edited:






Trigger

Well-known member
Jul 4, 2003
40,458
Brighton
Flitney 6
Hinshelwood 6
Cullip 7
Butters 8
Mayo 7
Hart 6
Oatway 6
Rodger 6
Jones 7
Knight 7
Henderson 6

McPhee 6
Pethick 6
 


fatboy

Active member
Jul 5, 2003
13,096
Falmer
Turkey said:
Flitney - 5 didnt have much to do. made one reasonable save other than that looked dodgy
Hinshelwood 5 right back is not his position
Cullip - 7 reliable as ever
Butters - 7 solid
Mayo - 6 good
Hart - 4 very poor by his standards
Oatway - 6 did well. if you like backpasses
Rodger - 5 quiet
Jones - 7 ok
Henderson - 6 good at times. would rather see wilson dennis
Knight - 8 very good

Pethick 5 did he do anything?
McPhee " "

Fans 1 Why do people sit in the singing section and not sing?
 






Gwylan

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
32,156
Uffern
Player Ratings
Flitney - 7
Hinshelwood 6
Cullip - 7
Butters - 7
Mayo - 7
Hart - 4
Oatway - 5
Rodger - 6
Jones - 8
Henderson - 7
Knight - 7


Subs
McPhee 7
Pethick 6


Couldn't understand why the sponsors made Butters MOTM. He looked solid but was scarcely tested by a poor forward line. I thought Jones was easily our best player. Hart had a 'mare but he can excused this one as he's been excellent for other games
 


berkshire seagull

New member
Jul 5, 2003
5,707
reading
How can people say henderson done alright mmmm!
I think its but time people realised that strikers are supposed to score goals end of it although he has 2 penaltys in the bag.:lolol:
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here